大象传媒

Ahoy me hearties! Welcome aboard our quest to sift the fact from the fiction in pirate history.

From parrots to treasure, planks to flags, we鈥檒l see just how much truth there is in the pirate stories we鈥檝e grown up with.

Dr Rebecca Simon, an early modern piracy expert, is on hand to guide us through some of these murky waters.

So let鈥檚 weigh anchor and begin鈥

Pirates had their own special slang

False!

Most of the slang that we associate with pirates actually come from pop culture.

Dr Simon highlights one film in particular as the culprit, based on the book by Robert Louis Stevenson: 鈥淩obert Newton, who played Long John Silver in the 1950 adaptation of Treasure Island, gave us many popular pirate phrases.

鈥淗is pirate accent was a very exaggerated version of his own accent (southwest England/Cornwall) and created the arrrrrr as a character signature. He also used phrases he picked up from sailing communities back home.鈥

Robert Newton and Bobby Driscoll in Treasure Island, 1950Image source, LMPC

Pirates buried their treasure

X doesn鈥檛 mark the spot, unfortunately.

It鈥檇 actually be quite hard to bury the sort of treasure that pirates were after. The idea of pirates hunting for gold and jewels is bit of a myth, as it would just weigh down the ship.

Pirates preferred to target large merchant ships along the shipping routes. They were primarily looking for medicines, spices, silks, sugar, rum and wine. Due to British trade restrictions, there was a demand for these items in the colonies and governors would often turn a blind eye.

Medicines were highly prized by pirates looking for cures for diseases they picked up on their travels, typically STIs. Mercury was incorrectly thought to cure syphilis.

The infamous Blackbeard once blockaded Charleston Harbour for a week, before taking hostages and demanding a ransom of mercury for his suffering crew.

Pirates were forced to walk the plank

Another piece of fiction.

Dr Simon explains some of the actual punishments: 鈥淒iscipline would be being put into the hold (a sort of prison on the ship), marooning with only a pistol and one shot and one day鈥檚 worth of water, and on extreme occasions death. But death was super rare.鈥

Jolly Roger pirate flagImage source, 大象传媒

Pirates flew the Jolly Roger

This one鈥檚 actually true.

The Jolly Roger is the name given to a flag which identifies a pirate ship. It was typically a black flag that featured either a skull and crossbones, or a figure of a man holding a spike with a bloody heart next to it.

Pirates would sometimes replace their own flag with that of the nation of the ship they were targeting. So if they wanted to capture a French ship, they would fly the French flag. Once they were too close for the target ship to easily escape, the pirates would quickly throw up the Jolly Roger.

The purpose of the Jolly Roger was to cause fear and intimidation among the raided ship, increasing the likelihood of surrender with minimal fighting.

Pirates kept parrots

Yo-ho-ho, this one is also thought to be true.

There aren鈥檛 many animals that would be suitable for life on a ship, with long periods out at sea. For a pirate looking for companionship, a parrot was probably a pretty good option.

Jolly Roger pirate flagImage source, 大象传媒
A participant dressed as a pirate looks at his parrotImage source, Matt Cardy

Pirates obeyed a Pirate Code

This one is a bit more complicated.

Pirates codes certainly did exist, and copies can be found in A General History of the Pyrates, published in 1724 and the source of much of our pirate knowledge.

The Bartholomew Roberts code, for example, includes these rules:

  • No person to game at cards or dice for money
  • No striking one another on board, but every man's quarrels to be ended on shore, at sword and pistol
  • To keep their piece, pistols, and cutlass clean and fit for service

For those pirates who were injured, many codes set out a standard compensation. Loss of a leg, for example, could be worth 600 pieces of eight. This currency is also known as the Spanish dollar, whose value was determined by its weight in silver.

However, it is not clear whether or not the codes were actually enforced.

Dr Simon highlights that the codes don鈥檛 differ much from law-abiding ships, particularly the rules relating to weapons, gambling and fighting.

鈥淚t is true that pirate quarrels were taken on shore to basically prevent them from polluting the pirate ship on the whole and to symbolise that pirate in-fighting could never happen on a ship. Compensation to injuries was true as many pirates would retire after said injury with a good amount of cash.鈥

Pirates all came from a criminal underworld

What鈥檚 that, another lie on the horizon?

It turns out that most of the higher ranking crew members on a pirate ship likely came from quite traditional middle class backgrounds. A certain level of literacy was required in order to read maps, arrange deals with merchants and keep track of the inventory.

Blackbeard was born as Edward Teech in Bristol, in around 1680. It was likely a middle class maritime family and he was educated before joining up with the Royal Navy.

Six blockbuster films that got history wrong

From Bohemian Rhapsody to Titanic, movie-makers have been very creative with historical timelines.

Six blockbuster films that got history wrong

The other medieval job Danny Dyer may have in his blood

It's tailor made for the EastEnders actor - and it's not a pub landlord.

The other medieval job Danny Dyer may have in his blood

Myth-busting food origin stories

Chocolate chip cookies, crisps and Caesar salad all have legendary histories, but are they true?

Myth-busting food origin stories