大象传媒

Soft engineering strategies - advantages and disadvantages

does not involve building artificial structures, but takes a more sustainable and natural approach to managing the coast. Each strategy has its advantages and disadvantages for use.

Beach nourishment

Sand is pumped onto an existing beach to build it up.

A photo of beach nourishment in practice.
Image caption,
Bulldozers moving sand during beach nourishment

Advantages

  • Blends in with the existing beach.
  • Larger beaches appeal to tourists.

Disadvantages

  • Needs to be constantly replaced.
  • The sand has to be brought in from elsewhere.

Reprofiling

The sediment is redistributed from the lower part of the beach to the upper part of the beach.

A photo showing reprofiling in practice.
Image caption,
A bulldozer moves sand up the beach

Advantages

  • Cheap and simple.
  • Reduces the energy of the waves.

Disadvantages

  • Only works when wave energy is low.
  • Needs to be repeated continuously.

Dune nourishment

planted on sand dunes stabilises the dunes and helps to trap sand to build them up.

A photo showing dune nourishment.

Advantages

  • Relatively cheap.
  • Maintains a natural-looking coastline.

Disadvantages

  • Can be damaged by storm waves.
  • Areas have to be zoned off from the public, which is unpopular.