大象传媒

How to compare texts - EdexcelPlanning your ideas

Comparing involves directly linking texts through their similarities and differences. It is important to move equally between the two texts, and write about them together, not separately.

Part of English LanguageComparing texts

Planning your ideas

Using spider diagrams

Spider diagrams are useful for a quick recording of thoughts and ideas. When you are writing about one text, you may decide to use a spider diagram to jot down your ideas and then order them.

When writing about two texts you need to make links between the points you have identified about each of them. To do this, you could:

  • make separate spider diagrams for each text, and then look to link points between them
  • make one spider diagram showing each point you make about one text (for example 鈥榯he author directly addresses the audience鈥), and checking to see if it鈥檚 true of the other text too

Using tables

When you are practising how to compare texts, you might try using a table or to structure your ideas - in exam conditions this format would not be as practical.

Here鈥檚 an example using the two extracts from the previous page:

PointExample from extract 1Example from extract 2
Both show the challenges of swimming in the outdoorsBathing in the sea is a potentially hazardous activity - "鈥etter able to resist the shock鈥"The swimmer is determined to overcome the difficulties 鈥溾hey let me carry on.鈥
Different attitudes towards their subject matterHas an informative heading: "Sea-bathing"Has a more emotive title: "My Epic Thames swim"
PointBoth show the challenges of swimming in the outdoors
Example from extract 1Bathing in the sea is a potentially hazardous activity - "鈥etter able to resist the shock鈥"
Example from extract 2The swimmer is determined to overcome the difficulties 鈥溾hey let me carry on.鈥
PointDifferent attitudes towards their subject matter
Example from extract 1Has an informative heading: "Sea-bathing"
Example from extract 2Has a more emotive title: "My Epic Thames swim"