大象传媒

Courage and cowardice in Journey's End

Journey鈥檚 End is at heart about how men deal with almost certain death, constant fear, sudden and intense horror, attack and maiming.

The play touched the hearts and minds of audiences watching only a decade after the war had been fought.

The men all deal with the horrors of war differently and Sheriff uses each character to show the various things soldiers did to cope.

We are immediately made aware of Stanhope鈥檚 drinking problem in the opening dialogue between Osborne and Hardy, who asks if Stanhope is 鈥渄rinking like a fish as usual?鈥

It becomes clear throughout the play that Stanhope is a brave soldier and a courageous leader. However, he uses alcohol to give him 鈥楧utch courage鈥 - a term believed to have originated in a much earlier war because of soldiers鈥 reliance on Dutch gin to prepare them for the horrors of battle.

Stanhope himself admits that after 鈥渢hat awful affair on Vimy Ridge 鈥 There were only two ways of breaking the strain. One was pretending I was ill 鈥 and going home; the other was this.鈥

The stage directions tell us he 鈥渉olds up his glass鈥 as he says this. Is Sheriff suggesting that remaining courageous in the face of unbelievable fear and horror always comes at a cost?

Raleigh鈥檚 boyish patriotic myth of the hero as some kind of knight in shining armour - and his 鈥渉ero-worship鈥 of Stanhope - introduces us to the concept of heroism.

Supporting the war effort and fighting for one鈥檚 country was glorified by propaganda and poets such as Jesse Pope, who painted a romantic picture of the heroes doing their duty for England. This led to soldiers and officers being pressurised to live up to the expectation of heroism.

We see that Stanhope鈥檚 real fear is that his reputation back home as a 'hero' will be ruined if anyone finds out about his alcoholism.

This is shown in the desperate way he "clutches Raleigh鈥檚 wrist and tears the letter from his hand" 鈥 a letter which could reveal the truth about his drinking to his girlfriend, Madge.

His really heroic acts - like volunteering for the raid - are juxtaposed with his alcoholism to show the cost of true bravery.

Juxtaposed with Stanhope鈥檚 brave attitude to his duty is Hibbert, who decides to attempt what Stanhope says is the other alternative to 鈥渂reak the strain鈥. Hibbert chooses 鈥減retending to be ill鈥.

His situation shows us what focusing on death can do to the nerves and health.

Stanhope however refuses to believe Hibbert and talks him round to staying, at one stage threatening him with execution for desertion.

Stanhope鈥檚 opinions of Hibbert range from 鈥渁rtful little swine鈥 to 鈥渞epulsive little mind鈥.

It is never made clear if Hibbert is just a coward or if he has a real mental illness, but his fear is shown through his dialogue and the stage directions. Here Sherriff uses verbs such as 鈥渜uivering鈥 and 鈥渢rembling鈥, as well as 鈥渢imidly鈥 to describe him.

Osborne bravely accepts his fate when told he is to join the raid. But his advice to na茂ve Raleigh to 鈥淭hink of it all as - as romantic. It helps鈥 suggests he too realises Raleigh would do well to continue glorifying the war, as the reality can be too much to bear.

Osborne himself seems to use similar tactics when he reads a childhood book - Alice in Wonderland - for comfort while waiting for the raid to start. In showing the tactics men employ to stay strong and courageous, Sheriff subtly conveys the fear they try not to show.

Sherriff also uses contrasts in physical descriptions to build up the audience鈥檚 perception of heroic characters. For example, when the tall and slim Stanhope first appears on set he is with chubby red-faced Trotter.

This emphasises the heroic physical attributes of Stanhope and helps us to understand the boyish love Raleigh has for him.

Hibbert鈥檚 desire to leave and his pretence of illness is contrasted with the heroic perseverance of Stanhope who has 鈥渘ever had a rest鈥 according to Osborne.

However, Sherriff also uses these contrasts to show how the men suffer to stay brave - the contrast of Trotter鈥檚 addiction to food with Stanhope鈥檚 addiction to alcohol is used to show how everyone uses crutches to deal with the horrors of war.

They may choose different things to help them cope, but in the end everyone finds their own way of 鈥渂reaking the strain鈥.

Stanhope - like Sherriff himself - has been awarded a for bravery and so has received the official hero鈥檚 reward.

The Colonel promises Raleigh an MC for taking part in the raid. The fact that he dies in battle a short while later shows the futility of such medals.

However, we can look at the deaths of men like Raleigh and Osborne as futile in one way, but agree that doing what they thought was their duty - voluntarily in Osborne鈥檚 case because of his age - was heroic.

Their superiors may have orchestrated the battles and riots, but it was the brave officers who put their lives in danger and died.

Trotter portrays another version of a hero. He is a working class officer who copes with the strain by eating too much and talking of down to earth pleasures such as his garden.

Despite his lower class status, he is made second in command after the death of Osborne.

This shows Stanhope鈥檚 trust in his ability and loyalty. The last we see of Trotter is when he 鈥渄isappears into the dark鈥 as the battle commences.

Then Stanhope receives a message from him in the closing scene, summoning him to 鈥渃ome at once鈥. We assume that he is killed.

Trotter may not be the conventional ex- pupil that we have come to understand as heroic, but his bravery helps us to question our own perception of just what a hero is.

Related links