´óÏó´«Ã½

Listen to Bryan's shows on the iPlayer
« Previous | Main | Next »

The ones that you don't get...

Bryan Burnett | 20:09 UK time, Thursday, 18 August 2011

What a fantastic response to tonight's theme of 'songs you remember from car journeys'. The stories were even more enjoyable than the songs and in case you missed them there are plenty to see on our Facebook page as well as here on the blog. Tomorrow night, I want you to make a selfless gesture and request the song you don't like but everyone else does. Who are the artists that make you exclaim, "I just don't get it?" My list would be topped by The Beach Boys, Belle and Sebastian and I'm sorry to say it bloggers, but Pink Floyd. They are not artists I particularly dislike, it's just that I don't get why everyone else thinks they are the best thing since sliced bread. So, who does it for you?

Comments

  • Comment number 1.

    Locomotive Breath / Jethro Tull

    What's that all about?

    Jeez!

  • Comment number 2.

    Shall I get it all out of my system now?

  • Comment number 3.

    My favourite live recording as I might have mentioned once or thrice is Thunder Road / Springsteen which has, to be fair, had an airing or four on GIO. However I don't get the studio version. It lacks all the drama and emotion of the live recording and quite frankly I think it's mince. Norrie likes it and I have no idea why.

  • Comment number 4.

    #2 as long as you keep your dignity.

  • Comment number 5.

    Julie...hard to read 'long posts on mobile phone' alert!

    Henri tirade comin at ya in five four three two........

  • Comment number 6.

    I'm with Paolo @ #1

    Locomotive Breath ~ Jethro Tull or Helloween's cover

    A song about the pain of seeing ones life go tits up.. who'd appreciate that????




















    Who said fans of Morrissey?

  • Comment number 7.

    Nine Inch Nails are one of my pet abominations, them and Rufus Wainwright. And Paul McCartney. I don't like these artists enough to know of any songs suitable for teatime listening, but if anyone else wants to help out with suggestions..

  • Comment number 8.

    David Bowie's not been on my playlist since Rebel Rebel. I can't imagine why anyone would want to listen to a track like

    Thursday's Child - David Bowie ( Hours)

  • Comment number 9.

    Mary Had A Little Lamb ~ Wings "Macca"

    Why would you want to put a nursery rhyme to music? The idea was so woolly it must have been Linda's!

  • Comment number 10.

    See that silly Ian Anderson standing on the one leg and playing the flute - baffling really. He's got a pretty good guitarist, but who ever notices him with such an exhibitionist out front. I'll definitely not be wanting to listen to

    Locomotive Breath - Jethro Tull

  • Comment number 11.

    Can't stand blokes in mascara & therefore I'm relieved the Snr Producer has resisted playin' Semi Precious Weapons Magnetic Babies!

  • Comment number 12.

    #7 What a darling you are, gaie!! I would really love to hear some Nine Inch Nails other than Hurt, but ... being a realist, Mr Reznor always uses profanities or near the knuckle lyrics somewhere, thus ensuring less airplay. The stuff that passes the censors is mostly instrumental, which hasn't a hope here. So, much as I love his music, even I can't manipulate him into this. Massive pity - he's a very gifted musician and songwriter. Could we settle on Jarvis instead?!! ;o)
    Meanwhile - I've never gotten what the fuss was with that Tom Petty guy. I've heard he's quite good, but I'm yet to be convinced.

  • Comment number 13.

    Okay here goes...

    Dignity - Deacon Blue

    Ironically, this is a really good tune. I've never been especially keen on Rikki's singing voice, though I really like him as an interviewer.

    However, the Soviet Politbureau (propaganda division) would be struggling to match the sentiment of the truly pathetic story line in which a council refuse collector has dedicated his life to picking up rubbish for routine wages and saving for his retirement, when he will purchase a dinghy and sail up and down the coast. This story is narrated by a man in a reflective reverie, sipping raki on a greek island whilst studying John Maynard Keynes, though we are left to wonder why this is significant.Implausibly,this dinghy will be called 'Dignity', thus undermining the basic precept of the story, since no one with any dignity would do such a thing.

    Apart from that, it's great.

    Flower Of Scotland - The Corrie

    Is there another nation on earth with a national anthem about a battle with their neighbours? Worse, it's a battle that was ultimately lost, when we joined the union. On the one hand, it says, none of this matters, it's in the past (why sing about it) but promises a new round of trouble sometime in the future (but we can still rise now, and be a nation again) if we feel like it. Make up your mind.

    An unmelodic dirge, dark and brooding with small minded resentment, it offers us nothing to aim for except, perhaps, if we're up for it, another round of hassle with our neighbours.

    I wish we had a national ANTHEM, not a narrow minded folk song.That's the trouble with folk (and blues to a lesser extent) is that it's always looking backwards to it's roots.

    It's always about having something to die for. I couldn't give a monkee's about 'roots' - I'd rather have a national anthem that suggested a Scotland that was worth living for.

    I'm convinced that 'I Was Born With A Smile On My Face' would change the country's fortunes forever in a good way.

    Other insufferable examples

    Anything by Boney M

    Any faux Burns... Loch Lomond etc ..matter of fact.... O never mind, that'll do.

    regardez youse

    henri

  • Comment number 14.

    How dare Jack Bruce express his opinion of Led Zepp by saying, "You've always been crap and you'll never be anything else. Cream is 10 times the band that Led Zeppelin is."

    I've never got Smiles and Grins by Jack!

  • Comment number 15.

    I forgot to say - re Belle and Sebastian. One of my colleagues is big buddies with one of them. He got him to wear a t-shirt with our company logo on it years ago on some TOTP show, or something. Hasn't, to my knowledge, raised theirs nor our status any higher. But. Will defend one of their songs that stands out amongst the too twee and eh?
    I Want The World To Stop
    A delightful surprise.

  • Comment number 16.

    This theme is a set-up. Bryan knows how much we all hate Morrissszzzzzzzzz.....




    Yawn............

  • Comment number 17.

    #13 lets hope you get the normal amount of luck associated with this number :-)

    BTW what did we lose when we went into the union?

  • Comment number 18.

    I've never understood all the fuss over Bruce Springsteen. He just yells WAAHHH or WOHHHHH and everyone thinks it's brill.

  • Comment number 19.

    Henri, if they play Flower of Scotland by even half the Corries I'll throw the tranny oot the windae. It's on the hate list with One Day at a Time, The Old Rugged Cross and Highland Cathedral.

    DON'T EVEN THINK ABOUT IT!!!

    Mary-doll - The Best of Everything would convince you, I'm convinced of it :0)

    Depeche Mode - so eighties, all that electronic stuff

    Blasphemous Rumours - Depeche Mode

  • Comment number 20.

    I don't "get":
    Rap "music"
    Black Eyed Peas
    Brubo Mars
    Lady Gaga
    Madonna
    Phil Collins
    Paul McCartney
    Status Quo
    and most of all: Bob Dylan as a performer.

    Joe
    Linlithgow

  • Comment number 21.

    I've never got Cliff Richard, for similar reasons to those outlined by Henri for Deacon Blue......however I do recognise the important role he had in British music, it's just that most of his good stuff occurred before I was old enough to appreciate it.

    By the time I was paying attention he was doing this kind of thing, which I have a sort of sentimental attachment to.....

    Visions - Cliff Richard


    .....and it pretty much went downhill from there


    Paul from Ayr

  • Comment number 22.

    i can't stand the fleet foxes.
    i think they are way too contrived.
    pop should have the feeling of being easy to do, lighthearted with simple catchy tunes.by all means a storyline but not some pseudo ph.d dissertation ( are yez listenin' belle and sebastian......oh they're a different band? who wouldave thought)
    they just sound ridiculously pretentious.
    in fact they sound ridiculous..............even when they're trying to badly crib from others....get real you guys lighten up and sing some decent songs.

    they are so bad i don't even know the name of any of their songs.........there is one about blood in the snow or something.....oh c'mon boys that is mince.

    yeah , play that one . the one about ice snow and blood ( i might be wrong about that title LOL).

    or just play

    'big thumbs down'...................the fleet foxes (oill give'em knott)


    #13 @ ya henri................i think there is serious significance about maynard keynes.....it anchors the road sweeper very firmly on the political spectrum....left of centre social democratic labour party.a whole generation will know exactly where the sweeper is coming from.
    (hint hint....play it!!! g i onnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn)

    cheers frae the dale

  • Comment number 23.

    #18 he's only written about 2 songs, mixing the waahhhs and woohhs around to make it sound like more.

    Norrie, do you still like us?

    Joni Mitchell - This Flight Tonight

    all that up and down warbling and tedious guitar strumming - beats me, but I daresay some folks like it.....

  • Comment number 24.

    although i like some of their stuff i think the stones have pulled the wool over too many eyes for too many years.
    on the rare occasions these days that i have the tv on i usually have the sound down and just watch the pictures.........i prefer body language to talky language.
    anyway...........one night here was 'keef' being interviewed about his new book so i put the sound upp just to get a flavour of the 'rock 'n roll' life .then he opened his mouth...........OMG.....POSH BOY.

    cheers frae the dale

  • Comment number 25.

    I hate Chirpy Chirpy Cheep Cheep - Middle of the Road

    Even the group are mis-named.


    I condemn it to the house







    DC (out tomorrow but nevertheless dedicate this to my fellow bloggers)

  • Comment number 26.

    Gaie, you seem to have an aversion to everything I like........except for birds and that Woodenbox of fivers outfit :-)

  • Comment number 27.

    #22

    Fleet Foxes - check
    Belle and Sebastian - check

    I've never liked the meandering pretentiousness of Morrissey or the tortured whining of Cerys Matthews.

    I've also taken an instant dislike to the aural cruelty that is Admiral Fallow.

    Through this programme I have grown to hate Deacon Blue, The Eurythmics and the Edinburgh Terror Twins.

    For non-musical reasons I cannot stand Paul Hewson, Gordon Sumner CBE and John Winston Ono Lennon (MBE returned).

    The strangled tunelessness of The Associates is also beginning to annoy me.

  • Comment number 28.

    And if he can hear me through the triple-glazed windows of his luxury mansion, "You are terminally boring, Billy Bragg."

  • Comment number 29.

    #27, 28 looking forward to your suggestion eric :-)

  • Comment number 30.

    #26 just trying to work the system, Paul!

  • Comment number 31.

    They're an eclectic fusion of dub, reggae, techno, folk and rock.. B.A.D. to the core ;-)

    Way too many influences to handle... I just can't get it... American Dread ~ Dreadzone

  • Comment number 32.

    FRIDAY


    This is why I dread Scottish theme nights...

    Scottish and Proud - The Real McKenzies

    Pure riddy, by the way. Nae wunner Hadrian had thon wa' built.

  • Comment number 33.

    what's to like about 'genesis' i hear you ask, people.

    nuffin would suffice.

    this wee useless piece got to number 'a hunner an' seventy' in the charts.
    if i was in the band that was number 171 i'de be feelin' pretty miffed.

    'in limbo'.....................genesis ( aye, and yez shouldave styed there)

    cheers frae the dale

  • Comment number 34.

    #3 #8 Great suggestions, I neam terrible suggestions. Or do I? I'm not sure....

  • Comment number 35.

    Tom Petty whine whine whine through his nose. Whats that all about.

    Tom Petty - Even The Losers

    yeah yeah whatever

  • Comment number 36.

    I failed to understand why a band that had a sound that which a fusion of synthesiser / New Wave music would develop a spaghetti western soundtrack style of Ennio Morricone with their own!

    Call Of The West ~ Wall of Voodoo... I just don't get it!

  • Comment number 37.

    Jazz music? Let me know when they have finished their orchestral warm-up and are about to start the tune

    DC

  • Comment number 38.

    Wonder what Mozz tune you will all have to suffer ha ha! Julie and I both like Throwing My Arms Around Paris.

    Sing along now:

    Im throwing my arms around
    Around Paris because
    Only stone and steel accept my love

    tra la la la etc.

  • Comment number 39.

    'the divine comedy'......................are too clever by half.
    there is too much effort put into the lyrics for them to resonate emotionally.
    take for example a comparison with 'national express' and say 'ferry cross the mersey'.two songs about transport.
    one song leaves me cold (maybe its the tea-break at newport pagnell), the other a warm glow.
    one song full of smart 'in the know' comment the other full of heartfelt sentiment.
    but anyways feel free to play

    'national express'.........divine comedy but in my head i'll be humming along to gerry.

    cheers frae the dale

  • Comment number 40.

    re 11

    know what u mean MMac ... blokey mascara was best left in the 70's (+ eighties come to think of it)
    I guess (sigh) it'll have to be 'Magnetic Baby' by Semi Precious Weapons, with Justin Tranter fronting as only he can!

  • Comment number 41.

    40 ...

    spooky that - my friend Gob Beldof (reverse phsycologist by proxy) offers his endorsement also

    reckon that means it'll reluctantly have to be Magnetic Baby -- Semi Precious Weapons
    (please?)

  • Comment number 42.

    I don't think i have laughed so much for a long time the comments on the blog are keeping me going...thank you all so much...body is shakin with laughter and mind is unable to concentrate on dislikes at the moment ,so much so i am unable to think of anyone i would not like to hear... when i have control of my body and mind i will get back with a please not that one.......

  • Comment number 43.

    CAPTION COMP..........

    ........'nd he originally asked for a plate o' beans thon high but i said it'll spoil yer nice tie, who u txtn btw?

    if there is no cash i will aceept a lot o' they wee bottles o' sparkin' pelligrino......just the job.but make it snappy.

    cheers frae the dale.

  • Comment number 44.

    #22

    Hmmm... I don't think the Maynard Keynes reference tells us much about the values of the refuse collector.

    It tells us something about the values the narrator would like to project onto the refuse collector, which is why it's so bloody irritating.

    Perhaps Maynard Keynes had a boat, he certainly would have travelled first class on lots of ships - so maybe that's it.

    John Maynard Keynes came from a privileged background, his father was a Cambridge lecturer, his mother was intellectually gifted. He was brought up with servants, went to Eton and Cambridge and had he been about today would doubtless have been in the Bullingdon Club with Boris and Dave.

    He work centered on wealth creation, rather than re-distribution and he is acknowledged for having pointed out that state spending can be a lever to aid wealth creation, which is an apolitical economic theory.It is the extent of the pull on the lever, the length of time it's pulled and the depth of the pull and what to do with the proceeds of economic stimulus that is political.Keynes was a natural liberal.

    If what you are suggesting is that the inclusion of the Maynard Keynes reference is to somehow to endorse the pigeon holing of the refuse collector as a tireless work ant and that that is a triumph for the dignity of 'the worker' and the left then I'm not sure it succeeds.

    Saving up and owning a boat and sailing is not a uniquely working class aspiration: moreover the evidence presented suggests the refuse collector is completely unaware of his role in championing the left - he's got other things on his mind: he doesn't indicate that he sees see anything dignified in his circumstances, wants to buy a boat and bugger off out of the society he finds himself in.

    Ironically, these are broadly the cornerstones of Thatcherite philosophy and sentiments as espoused by auld Maggie: hard work, thrift, progress through self reliance and self interest.

    The hard working,ambitious and self reliant were not of great concern to Keynes, it was the involuntary unemployed, and putting their talent and labour to wealth creation that dominated his work.

    So,I still don't see the tie up, though the song was written, I think, when auld Maggie was quite prolific and I've always found it surprising that Rikki would write a homage to an old Etonian and auld Maggie's sentiments, but there you have it:-))

    Having said that I would perhaps like to withdraw my shout for Dignity I had forgotten that Rikki comes on after Bryan so I don't think it's fair to have one of his played tonight -unless Bryan thinks it's okay. I don't care for the song,but I like Rikki and don't want to appear unkind. I do like the tune, I just don't get the lyric.

    regardez- youse

    henri

  • Comment number 45.

    #38

    You sing to a Mozz song? I thought he snored!



    #44

    "Saving up and owning a boat and sailing is not a uniquely working class aspiration".

    If you are middle class, you can purchase a boat without saving. If you are upper class, you can have someone purchase a boat on your behalf and watch them sail it from the comfort of your palace on the shore whilst supping G&Ts

  • Comment number 46.

    #42 Ronasgirl the blog is funnier when our dear friend Glen Miller is posting, but he seems to have taken a sabbatical. I hope he will return soon.

  • Comment number 47.

    What I dont get are themes like these.
    We are expected to ask for music we don't like??

    I didnt get it the last time we had this as a theme and I still dont.

  • Comment number 48.

    #45 @ ya DC

    A chance shurely - for Mr Git to request his most detested Lyle Lovett number

    'If I Had Boat' - dedicated to bin men the world over.

    Miss Babs is still away, so it's in with a chance!

    regardez youse

    henri

  • Comment number 49.

    #47

    What you do, Adam, is request

    American Dread - Dreadzone

    huge 2nd for madmac for this mish- mash shambles of styles and old cinema soundtracks.

    regardez youse

    henri

  • Comment number 50.

    #47 Adam, tell us what it is you'd really like to hear on "the show where you choose the music" and one of us will place the shout. We'll qualify it by sayin' "I just don't get it" & like magic the team will park all their prejudices and produce the most eclectic show ever!

  • Comment number 51.

    #50

    Hmmmmmm. Dont think thats going to work MM.

  • Comment number 52.

    I don't get Pink Floyd played enough on Get It On

    DC

  • Comment number 53.

    A friend of mine has passed many a first-rate listening tip along and is certainly responsible for my first hearing Bob Seger, Frankie Miller, Stevie Ray Vaughan - the list goes on. But why he wears a Frank Zappa T-shirt is beyond me.

    how about the appropriately named

    Zomby Woof - Frank Zappa

  • Comment number 54.

    How could I have forgotten?

    A Lifetime Achievement Award for Ellie Goulding for the seemingly impossible feat of removing every last trace of musicality from Elton John's Your Song.

  • Comment number 55.

    #53

    I you like Stevie Ray Vaughan you'll love

  • Comment number 56.

    i have now regained some control...tho there are some that would say i never do... the expression used is " you just can't help yourself can you?....but here goes anyway....celine dion..or as i call her cilly the squealer..dictionary says squeal "is to give forth a loud shirll cry"...yep that will be the sound. don't know any thing she squeals so can't name one...but that is GREAT!!!! cause means you can't play what i don't suggest !!!

  • Comment number 57.

    #55 true

  • Comment number 58.

    #51

    I get it!

    First past the post, I can't wait until we get U2.

  • Comment number 59.

    Springsteen - what's that all about. Complete mince.

  • Comment number 60.

    #54 Ellie Goulding was selected to sing at this years Royal Wedding as a favourite of the royal couple.

    I fear the aristocracy is doomed.

    What about ELO?

  • Comment number 61.

    Relax Paul, your prayers are about to answered;-(

  • Comment number 62.

    Ask for stuff you don't like and get the same old same old. Ha ha!

  • Comment number 63.

    #30, lol Gaie, if other peeps are doing this too then it's working......i'm liking more stuff tonite than in a "normal" programme......and we still have Broooss to go :-)

  • Comment number 64.

    I'm with Paul one of my favourite shows in a while....

  • Comment number 65.

    Ìý















    Ìý

  • Comment number 66.

    44 @ ya henri.

    phew!!

    that man definitely deserved to have the toon M. Keynes named after him

    cheers frae the dale

  • Comment number 67.

    #64

    You like every show.

    It must be costing the NHS a fortune in anti-depressants.

  • Comment number 68.

    #63 there you go, Paul it worked.


    If I may help someone as I pass this way.......

  • Comment number 69.

    what's Monday's theme? - my sore head made me turn the radio off

  • Comment number 70.

    Songs about being the Boss.

  • Comment number 71.

    #68 thanks Gaie and no need to switch off either..... Blood on the Tracks.........

    :-)

  • Comment number 72.

    Hope you feel better soon Gaie. Hope it's not a hangover you have!

  • Comment number 73.

    That'll be Bryan then, he chooses the music.

  • Comment number 74.

    Norrie, it was Joni (and others) wot done it. But thank you.

  • Comment number 75.

    Muse. People seem to go into raptures about them, I've even had the live experience but still it just sounds like all the worst prog, metal and histrionic theatrical rock, chewed up and spat out. I get nothing from them at all, there's no emotional connection on any level, there's no soul, you can't even glean 'fun' from them.

Ìý

´óÏó´«Ã½ iD

´óÏó´«Ã½ navigation

´óÏó´«Ã½ © 2014 The ´óÏó´«Ã½ is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.