Everybody needs some football assistance
At this time of year it seems everyone is searching for a good assistant to help them.
For most, this will be in the confines of a shop as they look to pick the perfect gift and if the role of an assistant is important in this sense, is it of any less significance in the football world?
I actually began to consider this as I listened to a Motherwell director being probed on the possible identity of their next manager.
Within his answers he pointed that there were of course two positions vacant, as the departure of Archie Knox along with Craig Brown meant they were also seeking a new assistant manager.
This of course is usually the case when a managerial vacancy becomes available, but it is unusual to have the two roles defined separately as was done in this interview because it is taken for granted that a new manager will choose his own right hand man.
For many reasons this is probably the most sensible approach as there should then be the necessary trust and chemistry between a boss and his assistant that makes them work as a partnership.
However, in an era where financial constraints are becoming ever-greater could it be that there will be more scenarios whereby a club can only afford to pay compensation for a termination of employment to a manager only, and therefore require the new incumbent to accept inheriting a backroom team?
Furthermore, could it be that amidst all the talk of revolution in the game that clubs will choose to interview candidates separately and consequently trust their own judgement in terms of selecting their management team?
I believe that the current economic climate may see more examples of the first possibility, and as much it would not be a manager's preferred choice of assistant, the need for managers to return to the game would see them accept the situation and be keen to make the best of it.
With regards to the second scenario, it is more unlikely although it could be that a club appoints a manager with the condition that part of his coaching staff is made up from an individual who has spent many years at the club as a player and/or coach and is thought to have a great understanding of the club as a whole.
Such a decision would almost echo other businesses where by a senior appointment may require outside application but the supporting roles are capable of and best suited to being filled from within the company.
Of course, all this deliberation over assistants is only appropriate if you believe that they have an important role within a club.
My own opinion would be that they most certainly do; the days of some coaches only being there to hand out bibs and lay out cones are in the past and indeed most assistants now take as much of training as the manager and in some cases the vast majority of sessions.
I am be very fortunate to have worked under some very good assistant managers with Brian Rice at Falkirk being exceptional in terms of training routines and his ability to keep them interesting and of a high tempo.
At St Mirren Andy Millen combined his skills as a coach with an ability to remain enthusiastic and upbeat at all times and was able to relate to and communicate with players even through bad form or spells out of the side.
The two coaches I have mentioned have never been managers in their own right and whether they would like to tackle this more senior role would be for them to disclose.
It does appear however that there are those in the game who are either better suited to being assistants or simply prefer such a role.
In some cases it is only when they opt to test themselves as a manager that they realise that they are more comfortable in the increasingly significant and skilled role of an assistant-and to wearing the club training gear rather than the sharp suit in the dugout.
Finally, can I take the opportunity to wish those who take the time to follow my blog a very Merry Christmas.
Comment number 1.
At 20th Dec 2010, PabloPiatti wrote:Slightly off the point but you mention that 'financial constraints are becoming ever-greater'... a lot of the top clubs in Britain are now looking at moving grounds due to financial pressures! Is this having an effect on club performance? Have a read of
Complain about this comment (Comment number 1)
Comment number 2.
At 21st Dec 2010, wellboy1 wrote:I remember when Mark McGhee joined Motherwell that a condition of it was that he accepted Scott Leitch as his assistant
Complain about this comment (Comment number 2)
Comment number 3.
At 21st Dec 2010, wellboy1 wrote:Perhaps they will do the same with Craigan this time?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 3)
Comment number 4.
At 21st Dec 2010, TheSaints1981t wrote:The manager of any football team should always have the right to choose there assistant. As a fan a key desision from Gus Mcpherson was bringing in Andy Millen from Clyde. For me this guy was a unsung hero. Bells cup, Promotion, SPL safety year after, Scottish cup semi final, Cis cup final speaks volumes. Managers need a assistant they can trust and respect, so its a no brainer for me.
Have you ever thought about getting into mangement yourself Jack? And if so would you work with the previous assistant at the club or would you insist on bringing your own guy in?
Merry Xmas and all the best for 2011.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 4)
Comment number 5.
At 21st Dec 2010, Jack Ross - ´óÏó´«Ã½ Sport wrote:TheSaints1981t, I would love the opportunity to go into management. Hopefully I will get a chance in the future to test myself within this type of role. My own preference would be to choose my own assistant, however if the role was filled by someone who I knew then it would make things a little easier. I must add that trying to break into management would mean that I would not reject a job simply because an assistant was already in place.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 5)
Comment number 6.
At 21st Dec 2010, HotdogSalesman wrote:Some interestng points Jack.
And a very Merry Christmas to you too.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 6)
Comment number 7.
At 22nd Dec 2010, Frustrated_Buddie wrote:I think it's important that a manager has the right to choose his own assistant. The manager will have certain tasks and duties that he will want from him and especially on the training ground, i feel they must agree on what techniques they want to use. it's important that they have similar ideas.
In relation to transfers i think it's important too. The assistant is more likely to be involved with the team on the training field so the manager would perhaps need his input when choosing a particular type of footballer in terms of ability and personality etc. There must be a trust between both parties aswell plus you could be assured that nobody had their own agenda. I'm sure there are assistants out there and their only goal is to get the managers job as soon as they can but will stop at nothing to get it.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 7)
Comment number 8.
At 22nd Dec 2010, JoC wrote:Great blog Jack...why is it always tucked away??
Interesting to hear about your own managerial aspirations. How would you like your side to play? Horses for courses ie. suiting the level their playing at or would you try to get them to bring the ball down and pass it? Financial constraints often mean a side is often composed of a few journeymen or cloggers who wield a lot of power in the dressing room.
Do you think a coach at the lower level even has the time to teach his players serious tactics and technical play and would it be better for any assistant to do the admin and leave you to the football 'hands-on' role?
Merry Xmas :)
Complain about this comment (Comment number 8)