Are free schools really the answer?
In Acton, the west London home of journalist and author Toby Young, the choice of secondary school is very limited. 听With the eldest of his four children nearing the end of primary school, his solution to this problem has been to gather a group of concerned local parents to set up their own free school.听Their progress is tracked in the 大象传媒 Two programme Start your own School.
If I was at the point of sending my child to secondary school and could choose between a failing comprehensive and a free school along the proposed lines of the , then I would, almost certainly go with the free school. 听If it were your child鈥檚 education at stake, wouldn鈥檛 you?
In principle, however, I am very unsure about the academies and free schools being set up to 鈥榮olve鈥 an education system in crisis. 听I believe that every child, regardless of background, deserves an excellent education. Surely the local authorities rather than private enterprise should deal with lack of provision and failing schools? Couldn鈥檛 the academies and free schools budget, be better used to invest in state-funded building programmes and bringing in crisis management, in order to turn around existing schools in trouble?
Free schools are essentially independent schools with state funding, and won鈥檛 be accountable in the same way as local authority schools. 听When problems occur, it won鈥檛 be democratically elected politicians who will be under scrutiny, so how will complaints against these schools be registered and dealt with? 听And if the existing free schools are anything to go by, it鈥檚 not going to be plain sailing.
The American model for free schools, the , has ostensibly led to more division in local communities rather than providing equal opportunities. 听The is constantly cited as being exemplary, but there is data to suggest that attainment has dropped year on year since the free school scheme was widely adopted.听听This could be, amongst other reasons, due to .听
Michael Gove wants poorer students to get a better education, and be .听However it鈥檚 in no doubt those who David Cameron has dubbed the 鈥榮harp-elbowed鈥 middle classes, will find a way to , as they seem to have done with the more successful academies, leaving less resourceful families worse off. 听听
As John Humphrys beautifully illustrated in Unequal Opportunities,听there are state schools out there that are working for local communities; 听schools that were failing and have been turned around by inspirational heads and teaching staff. 听If we want all children, not just our own, to have equal educational opportunities, there must be a better way to do this than half-hearted free school and academy schemes. 听It will cost money, and involve real commitment on the part of the government 鈥 but are they willing to do it?
听