´óÏó´«Ã½

´óÏó´«Ã½ BLOGS - The Devenport Diaries

Archives for September 2009

Life in the fast lane

Mark Devenport | 17:10 UK time, Monday, 28 September 2009

Comments

Ian Paisley Jr. has just sat down in the Stormont chamber after lobbying for farmers who may be hit unexpectedly by inheritance tax on land left to them under the conacre scheme. Media observers may feel he was damaged by the controversy over police training for Libya. But perhaps a bigger dent was made on him by one of the go karts at The North Antrim MLA was racing the Environment minister Edwin Poots when he took a spill and suffered some badly bruised ribs. There is no truth to the rumour that the DUP racing team manager P. Robinson ordered him to crash.

A Hard Sell

Mark Devenport | 18:58 UK time, Thursday, 24 September 2009

Comments

As promised the Clinton Global Initiative turned out to be a hard sell of the benefits of Northern Ireland as a place to do business. The First and Deputy First spent a lot of time telling their audience how much cheaoer office space was in Belfast than either Dublin or London. To be inclusive Peter Robinson added that you could get even more of a discount in Londonderry, to which Martin McGuinness responded that it cost even less again in Derry.

Both men seem impressed by the new US envoy Declan Kelly, who pulled together their appearance within a matter of days. There is talk of him getting US business figures to meet on a monthly basis to review their commitments to economic progress in Northern Ireland, and a possible investment announcement within the next fortnight.

Mr Kelly, according to Shaun Woodward, could sell ice to eskimos. But some of his rhetoric (NI "an economic miracle") might go down better with an American audience than back at home, given our local debates about budgetary black holes.

Martin McGuinness reckons the financial aspects of devolving justice could be resolved in time for next week's meeting with Gordon Brown in Brighton. But it appears the negotiations have been complicated by many of the projected sums changing half way through, with the agencies involved revising their own estimates of likely costs.

Should Peter Robinson's talk of driving forward and selling the the transfer of justice powers be seen as the harbinger of a move in the near future? Or is he shifting the blame to the British government if they don't come up with the cash?

I see has noted the $20,000 subscription required to be part of Bill Clinton's CGI. I don't know whether Gerry Adams and other such politicians pay this or get it gratis. What I did find from this my first CGI meeting was that though some of the staff were helpful there were an enormous number of jobsworths about, who insisted on shepherding us hacks everywhere lest we importune a VIP with an unwanted question. It wasn't very egalitarian for such a right-on institution. So I didn't get to ask Martin Scorcese whether he wants to film in the Belfast painthall (Martin McGuinness said he had noted how big the facility is).

No room at the Manhattan Inn

Mark Devenport | 03:18 UK time, Wednesday, 23 September 2009

Comments

It's tough getting a place to stay in Manhattan during UN General Assembly week. As the news of our First and Deputy First Minister's trip to Bill Clinton's only broke on Friday, making arrangements to cover the visit was far from easy. I couldn't find a hotel in Manhattan, so had to avail of the generous hospitality of some friends in New York.

But as James Bone reports in I am not alone, as none other than Colonel Muammar al-Gaddafi has had problems finding somewhere to rest his head. Having been refused permission to pitch his tent in Central Park, he is now having to hang out at the Libyan UN mission headquarters.

Lockerbie victims' families are planning to protest against the Colonel's presence in New York, and they will be joined by Willie Frazer and Michelle Williamson of FAIR, who are campaigning in the USA on behalf of IRA victims.

The UN is on the East Side of Manhattan but over on the West Side Messrs Robinson and McGuinness will be getting together with Bill Clinton and his VIP friends. I tried to get into the opening session of the Global Initiative earlier today but after joining a very long queue I found myself squeezed out by hordes of reporters. So eventually I had to watch the proceedings from the press centre in the basement.

The media interest had been stimulated by the appearance of Barack Obama, Bill Clinton and Matt Damon. I could see Gerry Adams and Ben Stiller amongst the assorted VIPs in the audience. I have an inkling that the crush won't be quite as bad for tomorrow's special Northern Ireland session.

Straight answers

Mark Devenport | 03:05 UK time, Wednesday, 23 September 2009

Comments

After Mark Durkan's confirmation on Inside Politics that he planned to step down as SDLP leader, some critics attacked him as naive, claiming he had made himself a "lame duck". The implication was that, even though he had already told colleagues of his plans, he should have palmed me off with a holding line.

Having been criticised by Gerry Adams for asking "stupid questions" and then been faced with spin bordering on disinformation at the time of Ian Paisley's departure, I have to say that I found it refreshing to get a straight answer to a straight question. Who knows, it might just catch on.

Mark Durkan to step down

Mark Devenport | 14:14 UK time, Sunday, 20 September 2009

Comments

I'm just off air with Inside Politics and an impromptu appearance on Stormont Live. I'd heard in recent days that Mark Durkan had been briefing colleagues that he intended to stand aside as SDLP leader after next year's Westminster election, so I took the opportunity to clarify this on the record. Mark told me that he never intended to remain as party leader after his 50th birthday, which is due in June next year. So if all goes according to his plan he will defend his Foyle seat, then step down from both the Assembly and the leadership.

Who might take over after Mark Durkan's eight years at the helm? Perhaps his deputy Alasdair McDonnell (although he will face similar dillemmas about whether to concentrate on Stormont or Westminster). Perhaps the party's only minister, Margaret Ritchie. Although there is no vacancy right now that won't stop the tongues wagging about who the future leader should be.

The Big Apple and a Slice of Salami

Mark Devenport | 16:52 UK time, Friday, 18 September 2009

Comments

Next week Gordon Brown will meet Peter Robinson and Martin McGuinness in Downing Street for another push on the devolution of justice. Given the bad blood between the DUP and Sinn Fein at the start of the Assembly term you could be forgiven for thinking this exercise is akin to rolling a very large stone up a very steep hill.

however intensive discussions are due to continue over the weekend and some of the officials involved claim the sides are getting nearer to closing the gaps on outstanding financial issues like hearing loss claims from retired police officers or police pensions. One senior source wouldn't talk figures but insisted that a "vehicle" could be found to resolve such difficulties.

After coming out of Downing Street the First and Deputy First Ministers will be getting on planes to New York to attend a session of Talk to the DUP and they say this session, the brainchild of the new US Economic Envoy Declan Kelly, is purely about business - there will be many US CEOs there and this is seen as an opportunity to press upon them the advantages of investing in Northern Ireland. But talk to Sin Fein, and whilst they are happy about the economic aspect of the gathering they will also tell you that it's about creating a space in which the former US President can bring whatever influence he has to bear to try to move the political process on.

"America wants to help Northern Ireland" my senior source says, "but the administration finds it difficult to persuade people to come here, make substantial investment and create jobs if the political climate is not stable. Americans find it difficult to explain why it is not possible to get agreement on policing and justice."

So as Bill used to say "it's the economy, stupid" but maybe with a bit of politics thrown in for good measure.

Either way the politicians think the gathering is important enough to postpone next week's scheduled Executive meeting.

Whilst US interest and investment may be dangled as a carrot, the stick in the current negotiations on devolving justice is that the UK government's finances will be much tighter after the next election. So why not do a deal now?

Certainly Peter Robinson's speech yesterday in which he acknowledged that Northern Ireland would not be exempt from any future cuts has opened up a debate about how the executive might cope. The Executive is already experiencing difficulties with the loss of revenue from potential property sales and planning application fees as well as its deferral of water charges and freezing of the regional rate. But if a future Conservative government demanded a 10% cut across the board it could be looking at trying to find an extra £900 million in savings.

Although Peter Robinson's suggested cull of quangoes, MLAs and the number of departments might be popular it would hardly generate the kind of savings required.

Privately some ministers believe we should be thinking radically - for instance might water charges or the privatisation of the water service prove inevitable? But the very nature of the government means that if one minister suggests a deep incision in one area, their colleagues will denounce them and defend their patch.

Given the propensity to deadlock in the Stormont system one can imagine any radical plan provoking a veto. At which point the only option may be to salami slice each department's budget by the requisite percentage, sharing the pain, but maybe not making the right decisions.

I'm off to Stormont to prepare for a broadcast. I'll be back on Sunday with Inside Politics. My main guest will be the former Finance Minister and SDLP leader Mark Durkan.

SF's Dundonald Connection

Mark Devenport | 18:14 UK time, Thursday, 17 September 2009

Comments

Today's follows Mary Lou McDonald on the Lisbon referendum campaign trail. It records that a female voter upbraided the former MEP for printing her party leaflets north of the border and that "Mary Lou and company gaze sheepishly at the Dundonald address on their literature". Dundonald? Forget about potential SF supporters south of the border, has anyone told their voters in the west of the city?

The Gerry Mander Way

Mark Devenport | 17:52 UK time, Thursday, 17 September 2009

Comments

The Environment Minister Edwin Poots proudly launched the new route of the Ulster Way this week together with an accompanying

But Sinn Fein's Paul Maskey was not impressed pointing out that "instead of expanding and enhancing the Ulster Way to bring in three extremely picturesque counties of Ulster, namely Donegal, Cavan and Monaghan, anyone lifting a map of the Ulster Way will see that the route actually walks along the borders of these counties and not once does it enter them."

Ah, that old chestnut. Edwin and Paul should get together, pull on some thick socks and sturdy boots, and chew that one over whilst munching on a cheese sandwich somewhere near the top of Slieve Donard.

Flare Up At Cohesion Corner

Mark Devenport | 13:03 UK time, Thursday, 17 September 2009

Comments

It's getting ugly at the Stormont interface. Maybe it's the sunny weather (always good for recreational rioting) but all you can see are gangs of surly looking young political advisors, hanging around on every corner. "Who started it?" an exhausted flak jacketed Community Relations Council officer responded to my question with a shrug "I don't know, but I'm not sure we can hold the line between them much longer."

One gang tossed a 43 page document entitled over the peace wall. The other responded with a 75 page draft called

"They may look harmless when you just open them up on your computer as a PDF file" the CRC DMSU officer explained "but put that in a ring binder and toss it over a 12 foot high wall and it can give you a very nasty cut".

All CRC leave has been cancelled whilst officers try to bring the violence under control. "I thought the months of stand off between them were bad enough" one CRC officer said whilst readjusting his riot gear in preparation to return to the front line "but that was nothing compared to this."

Victims and Black Holes

Mark Devenport | 15:21 UK time, Tuesday, 15 September 2009

Comments

I started the day at the La Mon Hotel attending a DUP briefing on their new private member's bill which will seek to change the definition of a victim to rule out the perpetrators of violence. The bill looks a bit like a pre-emptive strike on the new Victims Forum, which was holding a residential meeting today at an Edinburgh hotel and which is meant to be advising on the definition. Of course, the Victims Forum includes a former IRA prisoner who unionists would not regard as a victim.

The DUP is launching a consultation on how they should deal with grey areas - what about a paramilitary who renounced violence but was later injured in an entirely unconnected attack? Jeffrey Donaldson argued that the proposal might stand a chance of success if the SDLP can be persuaded to give it a fair wind.

However the SDLP's Alex Attwood kicked the bill to touch, insisting that his party wouldn't back it. He argued that the Victims Forum should be given space to develop a new definition. Predictably the Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness also promised to block any attempt to rewrite the current definition.

Apart from La Mon and Stormont, I also got to Newtownards today where the TUV leader Jim Allister was welcoming two independent unionists to his party. Both George Ennis and Terry Williams have been openly sympathetic to the TUV for the past couple of years but their formal move into the party gave Jim Allister the chance to boast that they wouldn't be the last to rally to his standard.

Both the SDLP and Sinn Fein argue that the DUP's move on victims is evidence that the party is looking over its shoulder at the TUV. No doubt the DUP would deny that, but certainly the mood music between the DUP and Sinn Fein isn't good.

Most of those I have spoken to around Stormont seem sceptical about the chances of justice being devolved before Christmas. Peter Robinson and Martin McGuinness are off to see Gordon Brown in London tomorrow about the financing of policing. At the DUP breakfast, the message appeared to be that the Heywood committee which has been examining funding possibilities for the government had not got anywhere near the figures which local politicians are talking about.

Talking of figures, the Ulster Unionist David McNarry became the 2nd politician in two days to estimate the black hole in the Executuve budget at £2 billion. Declan O'Loan came up with the same figure yesterday. I'm afraid I missed the UUP news conference on this point but Mr McNarry and Sammy Wilson had a rumbustious exchange on "Stormont Live" over the accuracy of the sums. As someone who struggled over one of those recent sample transfer test papers, I am not going to try to put either of them right.

Open Day

Mark Devenport | 16:40 UK time, Friday, 11 September 2009

Comments

if you want to see where it all happens (or given the recent focus on vetoes and deadlock, where it all doesn't happen) you can pay a visit this weekend to Stormont Castle, which is one of the buildings open to the public as part of an architectural heritage weekend. Apparently 1600 people traipsed through last time this happened.

If you want to hear more about how the DUP thinks the way the Castle handles business should be reformed, then tune in to "Inside Politics" after the One O'Clock News on ´óÏó´«Ã½ Radio Ulster on Saturday. My main interviewee is the DUP Deputy Leader Nigel Dodds.

How not to deny a story

Mark Devenport | 13:30 UK time, Friday, 11 September 2009

Comments

There have been rumours in political circles for a few days that UCUNF might be considering running a bright young man involved in PR with political connections in North Down. Then this morning the Daily Mirror reported that Alliance's recent European candidate Ian Parsley might be about to join the Ulster Unionists and take up a job at a David Cameron backed think tank.

Mr Parsley responded on his blog As a fellow blogger Ian is obviously computer savvy, but he really should have had a word with Declan O'Loan about the perils of not deleting material on the end of your message before you press the send button.

Because an e-mail emphasising his blog message also contained information from a Conservative party official, who appeared to be keeping prospective parliamentary candidates informed on the continuing selection process.

The potential MPs (including one Ian Parsley) were updated on a sample campaign plan from North East Somerset, a letter from David Cameron, a survey used by the Tories in Norwich North, and a Conservative "Lifestyle Magazine".

All of which leaves me looking forward to Ian's clarification this afternoon, and even more to getting my copy of the "Lifestyle Magazine" in mid November. I am hoping it's got at least one article about Ian and maybe another about his other half Paula Bradshaw who is thought to be interested in standing for the Ulster Unionists in South Belfast.

UPDATE: At 3pm on Friday Ian Parsley confirmed that he was leaving the Aliiance "with a heavy heart" and joining the Conservatives. He made the announcement at the office in Weavers Court in Belfast which, ironically enough, the Conservatives rent from the veteran Alliance councillor Tom Eykyn.

U turn if U want to

Mark Devenport | 16:42 UK time, Wednesday, 9 September 2009

Comments

There were a couple of good examples of apparent U turns during Committee hearings today.

This morning the SDLP's Declan O'Loan took Sammy Wilson to task about how much he was really saving by cutting back on bonuses for senior civil servants. Sammy protested that his policy would save taxpayers more than £1 million. Declan responded that this was small beer within the context of an overall budget for the bonuses of £530 million.

After a quick bit of mental arithmetic, Sammy responded that there were around 250 civil servants concerned and if Declan's figures were accurate they would be getting bonuses of around £2 million each, which was impossible.

Mr O'Loan replied that he was relying on the minister's own information and started reading from a document, only to get half way through before admitting "I'm sorry, I was misquoting the minister".

Laughter all around, followed by Mr O'Loan's admission that "if you're ina hole you've got to know when to stop digging".

Then this afternoon there was another screech of brakes. This time the OFMDFM Chair Danny Kennedy appeared to have his seat belt on and be taxi-ing towards the runway as he noted his Committee's plan to fly out to the USA. However Sinn Fein's Martina Anderson quickly cut across him with an announcement that she wouldn't be going on any transatlantic trip.

At the end of the Committee meeting Mr Kennedy explained that the US trip had been envisaged as part of the Committee's brief for looking after international affairs. They would be able to examine the work of the Executive's Northern Ireland Bureau in Washington.

But Martina Anderson, Jimmy Spratt and Naomi Long all sounded far from convinced. In the light of the current economic conditions and the heavy workload envisaged this autumn, they weren't happy about Committee members jetting off for a trip.

The Chair and any members who might have been looking forward to the US trip quickly got the message and agreed to "long finger" the outing, although it seems another journey, maybe to Europe, could still be in the offing.

Stormont: the Heath Robinson connection

Mark Devenport | 11:31 UK time, Wednesday, 9 September 2009

Comments

All this talk of the flawed structures at Stormont in recent days may have made Martin McGuinness think of Disneyland and Peter Robinson's recent trip to Florida.

But it made me recall a conversation I had a few years ago with Bob McCartney, who argued that once the Good Friday Agreement altered the workings of democracy it created a machine as complicated as the devices drawn up by the cartoonist Heath Robinson. Whenever the contraption ran into difficulties, the former MLA contended, extra bits would be added on to overcome the obstacle, leading to yet more complications further down the line. He would no doubt see the latest Justice Bill, with its provision for the cross community election of a minister, as a case in point.

No doubt a nationalist would counter that the fundamental alteration with the workings of democracy came about with partition and the drawing of the border line.

But whichever side of that old argument you come down on, I hope that a glance at some of W. Heath Robinson's gives you an idea of where Bob McCartney was coming from.

Double Jobbing and the PUP

Mark Devenport | 11:05 UK time, Wednesday, 9 September 2009

Comments

Dawn Purvis says she has been working for the past 10 months on a private members' bill to outlaw double jobbing at Stormont. She is seeking on her ideas before tabling the measure at Stormont. I see from her form that apart from banning double jobbing she appears to be seeking to abolish council by-elections, instead giving parties the right to replace councillors who step down. This seems in line with the co-option proposal, although is the PUP looking at this as a permanent change rather than a temporary measure to smooth the transition to the new super councils? If so, it might raise eyebrows on the part of those who regard the co-option policy as anti-democratic? And if an independent councillor dies or stands down, how should they be replaced?

Rewriting the Agreement 2

Mark Devenport | 17:44 UK time, Tuesday, 8 September 2009

Comments

Martina Purdy has just recorded an interview with Martin McGuinness which once again vividly illustrates the difficulties within Stormont Castle. The Deputy First Minister suggests that the First Minister, having just returned from Florida, must be suffering from sun stroke.

He goes on to make clear that Sinn Fein will veto the DUP's suggestion for a system which might end the vetoes. So we have deadlock over resolving deadlocks.

It's also understood that the speech the First Minister delivered at the Ulster Hall differed from the one cleared by the Deputy First Minister's office last week.

Interesting Interests

Mark Devenport | 15:36 UK time, Tuesday, 8 September 2009

Comments

The latest register of MPs' interests has been posted up on the Some of our double jobbing MPs have tried to estimate how many hours their Stormont duties take - for example, the DUP's Jeffrey Donaldson reckons his MLA work takes him on average "30 hours per week plus constituency work", whilst his Lisburn Council duties take "5-10 hours per week plus constituency work".

The First Minister Peter Robinson gives a monthly breakdown of "132 hours worked exclusively on ministerial work in July 2009" in relation to being First Minister and against being an MLA "33 hours worked in July 2009, including some additional work as First Minister. In addition, 82 hours worked as Assembly Member in July 2009, including some work as Member of Parliament." Confused, well so am I?

Other MPs haven't bothered to give any estimate of how much time they spend on other jobs, something which may provoke a complaint to the Commons authorities. Gerry Adams, for example registers being an MLA but gives no salary or time allowance for that job. He does, however, declare £800 paid in July for blogging and writing columns for the Andersonstown News and the Irish Echo in New York, something which took him 18 hours.

Alasdair McDonnell also hasn't tried to estimate how many hours he works as an MLA - he also registers, without any other detail, that he works part time as a GP.

We've long known that Willie McCrea earns a few country and western dollars from his gospel singing for "Daybreak Recording". But this is the first time I've seen his salary as as Minister of the Calvary Free Presbyterian Church spelled out. He gets £460 for a 12 hour week, plus a £225 allowance towards rent, phone and heating the Magherafelt Manse.


Rewriting the Agreement

Mark Devenport | 15:06 UK time, Tuesday, 8 September 2009

Comments

I'm just back from the Ulster Hall where the First Minister made a speech to the new group, which suggested not so much an evolution more a revolution in the way matters are handled at Stormont.

Picking up on the concern about deadlocks and mutual vetoes which dominated the "Beyond Westminster" report broadcast at the weekend on Radio 4, Peter Robinson is calling for an end to the designation system and a move towards a 65% weighted majority vote. That has always been implicit in the DUP's preference for a voluntary coalition, but the DUP leader has just made it a bit more explicit now.

If my maths are right (and it never was my best subject) 65% of the current 108 member assembly equals just over 70. So you would need 71 MLAs to agree an initiative. Under the current numbers this would remove Sinn Fein's veto and also (unless they took a couple of defections) the DUP's veto.

This kind of rewriting of the Good Friday Agreement isn't going to happen overnight. The Robinson speech didn't say such a change was a precondition for devolving justice, but he did say he thought it was equally important.

In the shorter term he is proposing a shift in how business is done in the Executive, suggesting that SDLP and Ulster Unionist ministers will be briefed at an earlier stage and even that some decisions in the future should be unanimous.

There were no nationalist ministers at the Evolve event, but Sir Reg Empey (perhaps somewhat disgruntled about a few barbs thrown at his Tory UUP experiment) described the Robinson speech as "a cry for help". Sir Reg is sympathetic to the talk of reforming the system but thinks the First Minister might be trying to spread responsibility within the Executive just to ensure he isn't the only one whohas to answer for difficult decisions about policing and justice.

Beyond Westminster Update

Mark Devenport | 18:02 UK time, Monday, 7 September 2009

Comments

Further to my recent blog on the Beyond Westminster programme, I wrote an accompanying piece for the main ´óÏó´«Ã½ news website which you can find Assiduous listeners might notice that in my article I quote Sir Reg Empey and Newton Emerson, but neither of them appeared in the version broadcast on Radio 4. Apologies to both of them and to the SDLP's Alasdair McDonnell - my fault for gathering far more material than I could get on air. In the spirit of "the Director's Cut", I shall put a transcript of some of the bits whcih never made it on to the air in the extended entry.

Read the rest of this entry

Beyond Westminster

Mark Devenport | 16:27 UK time, Friday, 4 September 2009

Comments

I have been off my usual news beat over the last week recording an extended report for Radio 4's "Beyond Westminster". The programme looks at the state of devolution here and questions whether the system designed by the Good Friday Agreement is a recipe for bad government.

We talk to a mother frustrated by the deadlock over academic selection and residents of the Spring Farm mixed estate in Antrim who are annoyed about the delays in bringing forward a strategy for more sharing and integration. Harry Holland's sister Geraldine McAteer tells me why she believes a devolved justice system might have proved more responsive to her family's concerns than the current arrangement.

You can catch the programme on Radio 4 tomorrow at 11pm, or if you miss it you can listen again via the ´óÏó´«Ã½ I Player.

Smallest News Conference Award

Mark Devenport | 16:06 UK time, Friday, 4 September 2009

Comments

On Friday morning I found myself almost on my own (so far as hacks were concerned) at a Socialist party news conference. They were announcing the defection from Sinn Fein of Fermanagh councillor Domhnall O'Cobthaigh. He objects to what he regards as Sinn Fein's right wing drift in implementing, along with the other Stormont parties, cuts, job losses and the privatisation of services. He made it clear that he wants to build cross community left wing politics and has no truck with republican dissidents who want a return to the troubles.

Mr O'Cobthaigh is setting an example to others by not just resigning from Sinn Fein but also giving up his council seat. Since he only got the seat as the result of a co-option he felt it wasn't right to hold on to his place. He thinks a by-election is unlikely given Sinn Fein's strength in his ward.

On the topic of co-options, the Environment Minister Edwin Poots told my colleague Martina Purdy that the legislation required for a mass co-option of councillors could run in to trouble at Westminster because some MPs weren't convinced it was democratic. Assuming the major parties won't risk a rash of by-elections this could mean that many of the MLAs and ministers who had intended to stand down to clear the way for future "super councillors" will instead by trapped as "double jobbers" for some time to come.

Noone as American as....

Mark Devenport | 15:59 UK time, Friday, 4 September 2009

Comments

Sean O'bama. My sources tell me that with another series of "Folks on the Hill" coming up on ´óÏó´«Ã½ Radio Ulster resident impressionist Sean Crummey is working hard to capture the intonation of the new US President. I am sure Sean will get that high flown rhetoric off to tee.

Naming the Names

Mark Devenport | 16:03 UK time, Tuesday, 1 September 2009

Comments

The Transition Committee looking after our new South Eastern Super Council has invited local school children to come up with a snappier name than its working title which is a bit of a mouthful, "Newry City, Mourne and Down District Council".

Here's a map of the new due to take over our local government in two years' time. Ignore the existing names, concentrate on the coloured areas and give me any catchy names which come to mind.

An Emergency Fund?

Mark Devenport | 15:37 UK time, Tuesday, 1 September 2009

Comments

During the coverage of the Roma families moving out of their homes near the Village, attention was focussed on the legal anomaly concerning migrants from the so called A2 states, Romania and Bulgaria. Since their home countries joined the European Union, people from the A2 states can travel and live here, but they are meant to register to work and cannot claim welfare benefits. That's why the Housing Executive didn't step in to provide accommodation for the families, beyond temporary emergency shelter.

Today the Human Rights Commission called on the government to revisit this policy in a report entitled The key conclusion of the Commission is that "the Government's approach in this area should mirror international human rights standards. Therefore, the Commission recommends
that, regardless of nationality or immigration status, everyone within the territory of the
UK should have access to an adequate standard of living sufficient for that person
and their dependents. It further recommends that public authorities should take all appropriate measures, including legislative measures, to the maximum of their available resources, with a view to achieving progressively the full realisation of this right. In particular, no one should be allowed to fall into destitution. For the purpose of ensuring these recommendations, the Government should ensure that everyone has access to
appropriate emergency accommodation."

Sinn Fein's Jennifer McCann has welcomed the report calling for the creation of an emergency fund to "help people who have come to live in Ireland and through a bad turn of circumstance face being homeless, take sick or are left vulnerable and who cannot access those services through normal channels due to their immigration status."

So far none of the other parties have dropped their thoughts into my in box, but perhaps, notwithstanding the arguments of an NIHRC spokeswoman on Good Morning Ulster this morning, they fear that the financial implications of opening the welfare system to people "regardless of nationality or immigration status" may be too onerous to contemplate.

Eating my words

Mark Devenport | 15:33 UK time, Tuesday, 1 September 2009

Comments

Last week I suggested local politicians may have left it too late to seek compensation from Libya. Today reports from Tripoli that there may be some movement on the matter. If so I shall be more than happy to eat my words.

´óÏó´«Ã½ iD

´óÏó´«Ã½ navigation

´óÏó´«Ã½ © 2014 The ´óÏó´«Ã½ is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.