Reporting Scotland (6.30pm), 大象传媒 One Scotland, 8 March 2021

Complaint

A viewer objected to the presenter鈥檚 reference to Glasgow Rangers FC鈥檚 鈥渏ourney from financial collapse and relegation back to the top of the Scottish game鈥 on the basis that the club had not been relegated in the course of this process.聽 The ECU considered the complaint in relation to the 大象传媒鈥檚 editorial standards of due accuracy.


Outcome

In 2012 Rangers FC, under new ownership, had its application to join the Scottish Premier League rejected and had to apply to join what was then the Scottish Football League, resulting in the offer of a place in the Third Division.聽 This differs from relegation, which is the transfer of a club from one division of a league to a lower one.聽 In the context of the club鈥檚 recent history, the difference is a material one, and the ECU judged that the reference to relegation fell short of the 大象传媒鈥檚 standards of due accuracy in news programming of this kind.聽 However, it noted that the situation had been accurately summarised in the report which followed the presenter鈥檚 introduction, and that 大象传媒 Scotland had acknowledged the inaccuracy in correspondence with the complainant.聽 In the light of these factors, the ECU considered the issue of complaint to have been resolved.

Resolved