´óÏó´«Ã½

Explore the ´óÏó´«Ã½
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

15 October 2014
WW2 - People's War

´óÏó´«Ã½ Homepage
´óÏó´«Ã½ History
WW2 People's War Homepage Archive List Timeline About This Site

Contact Us

Family (Political) Friction in Nazi Germanyicon for Recommended story

by Lothar Bildat

You are browsing in:

Archive List > World > Germany

Contributed byÌý
Lothar Bildat
Article ID:Ìý
A1142254
Contributed on:Ìý
12 August 2003

My last story dealt with my grandad's struggle to get his family out of the danger of Allied bombing raids. As I mentioned before, he was a clear Nazi opponent. But of course it would be a lie to say that all members of my mum's (or dad's) family had been opponents of Hitler - no, there were strong supporters as well. As in many German families there was friction within the family, with supporters, political foes and non-political people, who did not care about anything but survival.

My grandma's father, a member of the 'Reichsbahn' (railway authorities), was a strong supporter of his 'Führer und Reichskanzler'. A huge picture of Hitler hung in his living room and he was proud of the early successes of the German army. So you can easily imagine that sooner or later there would be arguments with his son-in-law, my grandfather. Actually they tried to avoid each other as far as possible. Of course this was a difficult thing to do, because they lived in the same house in different flats.

The conflict between the two came to a head in 1944, when the tide had long turned against the German forces, and the menace of the unavoidable defeat became more and more visible. My grandad — and especially my grandmother — used to listen to a British broadcasting service which gave information about the next targets of air raids in the Reich. Our sector was called Otto Richard and Richard Paula (coordinates of the Reich: O—R and R—P). It was strictly forbidden by the authorities to listen to the 'Feindsender' (enemy radio station), although the knowledge of the new targets undoubtedly saved loads of civilian lives.

Anyway, one day in 1944 my grandpa and the father of his wife had such an extraordinary quarrel that the latter decided to do something against my grandpa. He wrote a letter to the authorities, accusing my grandpa of having insulted his beloved Führer and having offended the honour of the German army.

It is important to say that my grandad had served his country in 1917-18 as a very young soldier in Romania (as an early radio service man). My grandad obviously had a very clear understanding of the military situation and he did not believe in the effectiveness of all the 'Wunderwaffen' (V1, V2, Me262 and the like).

He knew that the Russians under no circumstances were 'erledigt' (done for), as Hitler trumpeted arrogantly in late summer 1942 (when he announced that he would take his time to conquer Stalingrad to avoid a 'second Verdun'). In fact, this city became the graveyard of about 250,000 German, Italian and Romanian soldiers, not to forget hundreds of thousands of Russian soldiers and civilians.

My grandfather had fought against them and he knew that they had one thing at least: masses of soldiers, huge armies in which the German Landsers sooner or later would drown. He knew the vastness of the land by stories of friends who served in Hitler's army, he knew that they were no underdogs — 'Untermenschen' - but brave fighters with good skills and reasonable equipment defending their Mother Russia.

Anyway, my grandpa honestly would have got into the biggest and deadliest trouble if the letter had reached its destination. But fortunately one of my grandpa's brothers (a 'soft' Nazi and half-hearted supporter of Hitler) was supposed to take the letter of denunciation to the post office. He 'smelled' the danger - so to speak - and he carefully opened it over a steaming kettle, read it and threw it — appalled - into the oven. In the same year my grandma's father died, still firmly believing in a glorious victory for our troops.

Germany's family stories are probably packed with such histories — or even much worse. And - what is important as well — these stories continued within the new GDR, German Democratic Republic, after the end of WW2 (communists, old Nazis, etc). So it is still an interesting question for us: tell me, grandad, what did YOU do during the war?

Maybe the question arises what my dad's father had done during the war. He was a mechanic serving the Luftwaffe on an airfield near Duesseldorf. He mended together what was left of all the Me109ers and 110ers after their meetings with Allied fighters. He was one of the above-mentioned non-political soldiers, he left the war unharmed and he never had to fire a single shot. He never spoke about his (more or less boring) job with me, and when he died, he took the secrets of his thoughts into his grave.

© Copyright of content contributed to this Archive rests with the author. Find out how you can use this.

Forum Archive

This forum is now closed

These messages were added to this story by site members between June 2003 and January 2006. It is no longer possible to leave messages here. Find out more about the site contributors.

Message 1 - Family friction

Posted on: 21 November 2003 by Frank Mee Researcher 241911

Hello Lothar,
I have discovered your site this evening and find it very interesting to hear things from the other side.
I was a boy of ten and a half when the war started, sixteen when it finished, those being my formative years the war regulated my loves hates and forward thinking for a very long while.
After a period of my own Army service and the small untold wars we were in plus service in Germany I decided to read the subject in as many ways as I could and have had my eyes opened.
We had German POW's in our area and I met some of them as they came out of the camp to work locally and three of them worked for my friends Father a coal merchant. They became accepted as family members almost but of course me as a bloodthirsty young lad was somewhat disgusted, having been brought up on daring do books like Beau Geste and Biggles I thought prisoners should do everything in their power to escape. Those boys appeared very happy doing what they did and to be out of the war.
Years later in Egypt we had to guard a POW camp, no not keeping the Germans in but keeping them safe so our guns pointed out and I sat on guard with a couple of German soldiers who had cleaned my weapons loaded my magazines and sat there with pick axe handles talking to me. I gave them their orders, if attacked take my weapon and hold them off while I ran over the desert to Cairo (around 150 miles)and bring help. We had some good laughs and as a pianist some good singsongs to. They were waiting to go home in 1948 but some lived in the East so were waiting for a place in the West.
As the war had progressed and the bombing went on night after night I hated the Germans. I had visited relatives in London and seen the carnage. I lived on the North Eastern coast and the bombers came in over us to bomb the inland city's then flew back out dropping any spares as they went or machine gunning the streets, I got caught un in one of those incidents and it was not fun.
When with those German soldiers talking as only soldiers can, we were all in agreement that soldiers are really pacifists who are at the beck and call of politicians. We came to an agreement over a few Stella beers to let them get on with it in future and we would watch.
I did duty in Germany, the Luneburg FallingBostal area. It all made me think it through, they were the same as I, they had not been born with horns so why should I hate the people.
Being a Boy Scout then an Army Cadet during the war made me wonder if I would have flown to the Uniform if born German and I know I would have done so. Young children can be very gullable, we believed avidly the propaganda churned out by our own government as did the German youth.
Now as my grandchildren talk about joining the forces and asking questions of me, I find I do not really tell them how it was just skate over the surface or tell them the funny bits hoping they will never know. I think I do them no favours as they are now reading the Peoples War site and beginning to realise how things were. If it keeps them out of war well that is alright by me.
Keep telling the story's as they can make people think.
Frank Mee.

Archive List

This story has been placed in the following categories.

Germany Category
icon for Story with photoStory with photo

Most of the content on this site is created by our users, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the ´óÏó´«Ã½. The ´óÏó´«Ã½ is not responsible for the content of any external sites referenced. In the event that you consider anything on this page to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please click here. For any other comments, please Contact Us.



About the ´óÏó´«Ã½ | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy
Ìý