大象传媒

Is there - sometimes - a case for torture?

Former US President George W Bush has defended waterboarding suspected terrorists, in his memoir. He says it saved British and American lives.

Is he right?

If it saves innocent lives - is torture sometimes OK?

If certain individuals are prepared to kill innocent people in their droves - do they deserve any human rights?

In a passionate debate, Nicky Campbell hears from Stacy Hilliard, the vice chair of Republicans Abroad, and Major General Tim Cross, the most senior British officer responsible for post-war planning for the Iraq War and deployed to the country immediately after the invasion in 2003.