Main content
Sorry, this episode is not currently available

Episode 15

Rhodri Owen, Lucy Owen and Rachel Treadaway-Williams with consumer issues, including illegal cheap cigarettes, mobile phone business contracts and online shopping tips.

With the price of a pack of twenty cigarettes now around 拢8, the illegal market in cheap cigarettes is flourishing. X-Ray joins Cardiff Trading Standards as they raid shops across the city to track down the shops flouting the law. Back in October, the programme featured Tracey Coombe, who discovered she'd been sold a business contract when she bought a phone for her sixteen-year-old son, now Rachel hears from a number of other viewers who share the same experience. It is the peak of the online shopping season so Rhodri finds out what the pitfalls are and how to avoid them. Lucy meets Melissa Evans and hears how her brand new phone started to melt when she left it on to charge overnight.

30 minutes

Last on

Mon 2 Dec 2013 19:30

Illegal cigarettes raid

Illegal cigarettes raid

It鈥檚 early morning in the Welsh capital and X-Ray is on the road with Cardiff trading standards on the hunt for illegal cigarettes and tobacco. Officers have intelligence that fake, bootlegged and 鈥榠llicit white鈥 cigarettes are being sold to the public in certain shops.

Sniffer dogs will be sent in before the shopkeeper can move any illegal stash.

And almost immediately the dogs are onto something. In the first shop Ozzie 鈥 a three year old black Labrador - finds a selection of cigarettes and rolling tobacco, including a small quantity of illicit tobacco. Illicit whites are cigarettes made abroad exclusively for the smuggled market and sold cheaply in the UK.

Onto the second shop and this time it鈥檚 sniffer dog Indie on the trail. The Lab scratches at a concealed drawer under the tobacco gantry. Lead trading standards officer Mike Davies tells the shopkeeper: 鈥淥k, we clearly have a problem鈥. 鈥淵eah I know,鈥 he replies.

But Indie鈥檚 nose is twitching again and within minutes she鈥檚 sniffed out more.

Mike tells X-Ray reporter Rachel Treadaway-Williams these are fakes 鈥 made in back street factories to look like legal cigarettes.鈥淵ou just don鈥檛 know what you are smoking... The tobacco industry is regulated, whereas the people who are making these illicit cigarettes aren鈥檛 regulated at all so you don鈥檛 know what鈥檚 in them.鈥

As morning becomes afternoon the haul gets bigger. In another part of the city Ozzie locates a truly hidden stash - in a gap in the wall behind a mirror in the shop toilet. It has a street value of about 拢500.

And as the team heads to another shop Rachel asks Mike who he thinks is behind the smuggling.鈥淵ou鈥檙e looking at organised crime groups that are bringing in the goods across borders in a way that they may have done previously with drug smuggling,鈥 he says. 鈥淣ow they are turning their sights on tobacco because there are fewer penalties possibly.鈥

By 5 o鈥檆lock, nine retail premises have been raided and four seizures made. Mike and his fellow officers estimate they鈥檝e confiscated more than 26,000 cigarettes and 350g hand rolling tobacco, with a combined street value of around 拢4,000.

But Mike knows the fight against illegal cigarettes will go on: 鈥淗itting small shops will disrupt the trade 鈥 but the team here knows it won鈥檛 be stopped until there鈥檚 concerted action to tackle the tobacco gangs.鈥

Mobile phone misery

Mobile phone misery

When you sign up to a new mobile phone deal, you don鈥檛 expect to be put on a business contract unless you run a business. But that鈥檚 exactly what happened to four X-Ray viewers who used Welsh mobile phone retailer, Get Connected.

We first told you about the company in early November, when Tracey Coombe from Blackwood explained how she had taken out a mobile contract for her teenage son Tom. Tracey was expecting to pay 拢32 a month. But her first bill showed she was actually paying 拢43 - and she had been put on a business tariff. Tracey said: 鈥淚 was so annoyed when I had this. I thought, what have Get Connected done?鈥

After that broadcast we were contacted by more unhappy Get Connected customers.
And despite visiting different Get Connected shops across south Wales, they all had very similar complaints.

Rose Edwards took out a phone contract at the Abergavenny branch and later discovered she was paying more than she claims had been agreed in store. She was also set up as a business customer. Rose said: 鈥淲hen I was in the shop and I looked over the contract, it didn't mention anything about it being a business contract, or myself being a business owner.鈥

Aimee Bristow had a similar experience at the Haverfordwest branch of Get Connected. She was also set up as a business customer and was paying more than she says she had agreed. But there was an even more shocking revelation when she went back to the shop to complain.鈥淲hen I signed up there was just one sheet for me to sign,鈥 Aimee explained.鈥淵et when we went back to get a copy, they gave us two sheets which had a lot more information. They haven't asked me the information on this sheet (second sheet). I feel really annoyed that they probably filled this in after I'd left the shop.鈥

Customer number three, Amy Salter, told X-Ray about a similar experience at the Get Connected shop in Porthcawl.

Like the others, Amy had been signed up as a business customer - but it seemed the Get Connected salesman who sold the contract had gone one step further.鈥淭hey'd put that I owned my own mobile hairdressing business,鈥 said Amy. 鈥淚 don't even drive my own car and I've never studied hairdressing in my life.鈥

So that鈥檚 four people set up as business customers at different shops and all of them were paying more than they say they had agreed with Get Connected. So why had this happened?
鈥淭he main reason why an independent retailer would want to sell a business contract is that they can make more money off it,鈥 mobile phone journalist Graeme Neill told X-ray.鈥淲hat happen is that their suppliers could offer them one off preferential rates on specific deals, so if they sell more of these business contracts they'll make a lot more money for it.鈥

X-Ray also spoke to Monmouthshire Trading Standards, who told us they had been receiving complaints about Get Connected for the last few years. In September 2013 the company signed an agreement not to mislead customers, and could face a fine and a criminal investigation if their staff are caught doing that.

We also wrote to Get Connected.

Company boss Damian Cole denied his staff deliberately misled customers in order to make more money, adding that business contracts can be sold to non-business customers.听 But the company they sell phones for, Orange, seemed to disagree and suggested some retraining for Get Connected staff.

Mr Cole said the number of complaints against the company dropped since working with trading standards.

As for Rose, Aimee and Amy - Mr Cole said they all signed paperwork stating they were self-employed and were told VAT would be added to their monthly payments, although they tell us this was never made clear to them.

Phone charger burns

Phone charger burns

Last year almost 1.75 BILLION mobile phones were bought across the world and 94 percent of adults in the UK now own one.

Melissa Ellis from Newport totally relies on her mobile phone as she struggles to get around.
鈥淚f I go to my car I鈥檝e got to have my phone on me all the time鈥 She told us 鈥 I just need my phone just in case. At night I need it, I wake up in the night, I could be ill through the night so I need my phone close to me.鈥

Melissa bought a brand new Samsung S4 phone in June. She鈥檇 chosen it as it was easy to use with her disability. A few weeks later she put it onto charge overnight in the kitchen as normal. 鈥淚 put my phone on charge about 12 o clock at night, fell asleep for a few hours on my sofa 鈥 she said 鈥淚 woke up in pain, so I thought I鈥檇 get my phone and go on a game and also take some painkillers.鈥

But when Melissa touched the phone she found it was burning in the socket.

鈥淚 couldn鈥檛 believe it. I just dropped it automatically all I could think was oh my gosh if that had been a bit longer, God knows what would鈥檝e happened.鈥 She said.

Melissa had a small burn on her fingers and her brand new phone was ruined.

鈥淚t was horrifying.鈥 She told us 鈥淭he metal on the USB part was all burnt, you could see in the port that it was all burnt and to melt a phone, to get a scorch mark. I really think there would鈥檝e been a fire鈥

Every year eight thousand people are injured by electrical fires in the UK. Thankfully mobile phone fires are a tiny number of these, but they DO happen.

鈥淭here is a potential that a mobile phone charger is as dangerous as any other electrical appliance鈥 says Richard Hassett from South Wales Fire and Rescue 鈥淚n order to charge them safely you should only charge them when you鈥檙e there, you shouldn鈥檛 really charge them overnight.鈥 He said 鈥淟ike leaving your tumble drier or washing machine overnight, it shouldn鈥檛 be done because they aren鈥檛 designed to do it. When you鈥檙e charging it don鈥檛 leave it on a bed or a pillow either鈥 he said听 鈥淧ut it on a surface that is solid so that it won鈥檛 catch fire, because as you鈥檙e charging they can generate heat and if it鈥檚 a bed or a pillow it could be enough heat to catch fire. Also if you鈥檙e using an electrical adapter you should ensure the electrical adapter isn鈥檛 overloaded.鈥

Samsung say that they've always employed strict quality control and safety standards. They've now taken Melissa's phone back and听 they'll be conducting a thorough investigation to find out EXACTLY what happened. In the meantime they've sent her a brand new phone.


Credits

Role Contributor
Presenter Lucy Owen
Presenter Rhodri Owen
Reporter Rachel Treadaway-Williams
Series Producer Susie Phillips

Broadcast