大象传媒

In the third edition of the latest series of Leader Conference, Andrew Rawnsley was joined by Mary Riddell of the Daily Telegraph; Paddy Smyth of the Irish Times;听Mary Ann Sieghart; Aditya Chakrabortty of the Guardian; and David Williamson of the Western Mail.听

We debated: Google and 鈥渢he right to be forgotten鈥�; India鈥檚 democracy; and the legacy of Stephen Sutton.

听

A right that鈥檚 wrong听

The decision by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in Luxembourg this week that EU citizens could demand that the Google search engine delete links to embarrassing personal information online is a ruling with profound implications for freedom of speech.

听

The judges of the ECJ had to determine whether an individual鈥檚 wish to leave behind unpleasant personal history trumped the public鈥檚 right to know. These are not absolute rights; they have to be balanced against each other. But the way in which the judges ruled concerns us. They decided that a newspaper can lawfully publish information about an individual鈥檚 tax problems, but Google is not entitled to provide links to it if the individual objects. Unlike the newspaper, Google is not fulfilling journalistic purposes but processing data which, the court ruled, could endanger the right to privacy, simply as a result of Google鈥檚 vast distributional power.

听

The lack of precision in the court鈥檚 ruling is troubling. We have several concerns about its likely effects. First, the rich and powerful could varnish their past online in a way that might not be open to the less well-off. Secondly, even if Google deletes links, the troublesome information could remain on individual websites and be stored on others. Thirdly, Google may have to create extensive new procedures to handle deletion requests. Who will pay? Fourthly, the decision does not apply to jurisdictions outside the EU, potentially resulting in different standards of knowledge in the US and Europe. This elevates privacy too high and is not in the public interest. We prefer a simpler, less bureaucratic and onerous regime: social networks which accumulate private information should be required to notify users annually of the information held on them and asked if they object to its retention. 听

听

Finally, the so-called 鈥渞ight to be forgotten鈥� 鈥� which was cited in this case 鈥� is not a right but a claim. We worry about its misuse. It could threaten freedom of speech and of the press, especially where information is true. Privacy should not extend as far as rewriting history. 听听

听

听

Modi under the microscope

To democrats India remains a shining beacon as it prepares to declare later this week the results of its general election. Set against the apathy which besets British democracy, a turnout of more than 550 million people 鈥� 66% of the electorate 鈥� over the six-week cycle of voting is humbling. But truly to stand tallest among Asian nations, India鈥檚 new rulers will need to honour the people鈥檚 faith in democracy.听 听

听

Exit polls forecast a humiliating defeat for the ruling coalition led by the Congress party. If so, we shall not mourn their losses. In recent times it has behaved less like a democratic party and more like a syndicate seeking and dispensing favours. Corruption and nepotism are endemic. Economic growth has slowed dramatically.

听

It seems likely that the Hindu nationalist BJP, now led by Narendra Modi, will return to power on a wave of revulsion against Congress. But to be a truly national leader, Mr Modi needs to reform himself, notably on human rights. We recall that in 2002, more than a thousand people, mostly Muslims, were killed in religious riots in the state of Gujarat shortly after Mr Modi became its chief minister. He did little to stop those disturbances and spoke callously about the loss of life. For all the recent polishing up of his image as a consensual figure, we remain sceptical and want to see true leadership.听听听听

听

India鈥檚 economy also requires his attention. Freer trade and more open markets can help boost growth and improve lives across the country. The stock market has already risen sharply, anticipating a BJP win. But a more business-friendly environment should not mean rewards for the BJP鈥檚 commercial backers. To match China鈥檚 growth rates, India needs economically bolder, less stridently nationalist and more inclusive policies from Delhi and from Mr Modi than the BJP has espoused in the past.听听听

听

So much so young 听听听

Stephen Sutton, the Staffordshire teenager who valiantly fought bowel cancer for four years and encouraged more than 拢3 million in donations to the Teenage Cancer Trust, captured the public imagination. Individual effort, enriched with collective support 鈥� harnessing the power for good which social media can offer 鈥� can be transformative. But his story has lessons too for the way in which the media presents the lives of those with life-limiting illnesses. Following his diagnosis, Stephen showed what he believed: that life lived as an adventure confers joy and meaning not only on the person directly affected but on countless others by unlocking the power of human generosity. His legacy is simple, poignant and a lesson to us all.