Main content
Sorry, this episode is not currently available

The Other Place

From Dante to Dickens, Samira Ahmed explores ideas about what happens after death.

The mystery of what happens after we die has long been the subject of writers, artists and thinkers. Don Paterson writes that "Man is probably unique amongst the mammals in that he has conscious foreknowledge of his own death".

One of the most powerful cultural influences on how we think about this subject is the poetry of Dante, whose epic poem The Divine Comedy imagined Hell as a physical place of torments nicely matched to the sins of its inhabitants.

One of the most troubling ideas found in Dante's afterlife is Limbo, a place of nothingness at the very edge of Hell for the unbaptised. It is an idea that has had a devastating impact on parents of stillborn babies in Roman Catholic countries like Ireland, where thousands of infants and stillborn babies were not allowed to be buried in holy ground and parents were taught to believe their dead children now dwelt out of the sight of God. It wasn't until 2007 that the Roman Catholic church offered hope that God would indeed save these unbaptised babies. A documentary broadcast on Radio 4 around that time included the powerful stories of anguished parents and we hear some of them in this programme.

Despite the enduring popular ideas about Heaven and Hell, it is hard to find precise depictions in the Old and New Testament. Samira talks to Rabbi Jonathan Romain about Jewish ideas of Sheol.

There are poems and writing by Don Paterson and Charles Dickens, as well as versions of Dante by Clive James and John Agard and music by Monteverdi and the Unthanks, among others.

The readers are Peter Marinker and Emily Taaffe.

Producer: Natalie Steed
A Whistledown production for 大象传媒 Radio 4

The picture used for this programme shows Dante and his guide, Virgil, being rowed across the Styx (image courtesy of the British Library).

30 minutes

Last on

Sun 20 Sep 2015 23:30

Music Played

  • Claudio Monteverdi

    Possente Spirito

    • Orfeo.
    • DG Archiv.
  • Giuseppe Tartini

    Sonata For Violin In G Minor "Devil's Trill"

    • Vivaldi: Four Seasons; Tartini: Devil鈥檚 Trill/Bell.
    • Sony Classical Essential Classics.
  • Leos Jan谩膷ek

    String Quartet #1 鈥淜reutzer Sonata鈥

    • String Quartets 1- 2.
    • Calliope.
  • Rachel Unthank & the Winterset

    Newcastle Lullaby

    • The Bairns.
    • Rabble Rouser Records / Real World Records.
  • Henry Purcell

    In Guilty Night [Saul and the Witch of Endor]

    Performer: Taverner Choir.
    • PURCELL: Choral and Chamber Works.
    • Virgin.
  • Talking Heads

    Heaven

    • Fear of Music.
    • Sire.
  • Florence + The Machine

    Leave My Body

    • Ceremonials.
    • Island.

Readings

Title: The Dead

Author: Don Paterson

Publisher: Faber & Faber

Title: Words above the entrance to the Underworld, from The Divine Comedy, The Inferno, Canto III

Author: Dante Alighieri (translated by Clive James)

Publisher: Picador

Title: The Damned, from Inferno Canto V

Author: Dante Alighieri (translated by Paul Batchelor)

Publisher: Winner of the 2009 Stephen Spender Award for Translation

Title: Canto VII, The Young Inferno

Author: John Agard

Publisher: Frances Lincoln Children's Books

Title: From A Christmas Carol

Author: Charles Dickens

Publisher: Penguin Classics

Broadcasts

  • Sun 20 Sep 2015 06:05
  • Sun 20 Sep 2015 23:30