Main content
Sorry, this episode is not currently available

Saint-Sa毛ns's Carnival of the Animals in Building a Library with Sarah Devonald and Andrew McGregor

Sarah Devonald joins Andrew McGregor to compare recordings of Saint-Sa毛ns's Carnival of the Animals.

Andrew McGregor with the best new recordings of classical music

9.30 am
Composer William Mival joins Andrew with the new releases which have grabbed his attention this week, and shares the track that is especially dear to him, that which he has "On Repeat". Send us your "On Repeat" recommendations at recordreview@bbc.co.uk or tweet us @大象传媒Radio3

10.30 am
Sarah Devonald compares recordings of Saint-Sa毛ns's Carnival of the Animals and picks her favourite (rpt)

11.20 am
Record of the Week
Andrew's pick of the best of the best this week

2 hours, 47 minutes

Music Played

  • Th茅odore Dubois

    Xaviere, Act II: Air. "Au clair matin" (Landry)

    Singer: Cyrille Dubois. Orchestra: Orchestre national de Lille. Conductor: Pierre Dumoussaud.
    • So Romantique!.
    • Alpha.
    • 11.
  • Sergey Prokofiev

    Symphony No 1 in D major, Op 25 'Classical': IV. Finale. Molto vivace

    Orchestra: London Symphony Orchestra. Conductor: Gianandrea Noseda.
    • Prokofiev: Symphony No. 1.
    • LSO Live.
    • 4.
  • Ludwig van Beethoven

    String Quartet No 13 in B-Flat major, Op 130: V. Cavatina (Adagio molto espressivo)

    Ensemble: Calidore Quartet.
    • Beethoven Quartets, Vol. 1: Late String Quartets.
    • Signum Classics.
    • 305.
  • Richard Strauss

    Vier letzte Lieder: 2. September

    Singer: Rachel Willis-Sorensen. Orchestra: Gewandhausorchester Leipzig. Conductor: Andris Nelsons.
    • Strauss: Four Last Songs.
    • Sony.
    • 2.
  • Camille Saint鈥怱a毛ns

    Violin Sonata No 1 in D Minor, Op 75, R 123: IIb. Allegro molto

    Performer: Cecilia Zilliacus. Performer: Christian Ihle Hadland.
    • Saint-Sa毛ns: Violin Works.
    • BIS.
    • 104.
  • Ludwig van Beethoven

    Symphony 5: 1st Movement

    Music Arranger: Johann Nepomuk Hummel. Ensemble: Ensemble1800Berlin.
    • MDG.
  • Frederic Rzewski

    Dreams: Part 2 no. 8 'Wake up'

    Performer: Bobby Mitchell.
    • Naxos.
  • Erich Wolfgang Korngold

    String Quartet no.3: Scherzo

    Ensemble: Tippett Quartet.
    • Naxos.
  • Gy枚rgy Ligeti

    Drei Phantasien nach Holderlin: "Wenn aus der Ferne "

    Choir: SWR Vocal Ensemble, Stuttgart. Conductor: Yuval Weinberg.
    • Hanssler.
  • Matthew Locke

    Suite V In G Minor - Fantazie

    Ensemble: Le Concert des Nations. Conductor: Jordi Savall.
    • Matthew Locke: The Consort Of Fower Parts (Suites I To Vi).
    • Alia Vox.
    • 17.
  • Steve Reich

    Vermont Counterpoint

    Performer: Ransom Wilson.
    • 100 Best American Classics.
    • EMI.
    • 4.
  • Ede Remenyi

    Friss

    Performer: Ferenc Szecs艖di.
    • Brahms: Hungarian Dances & the Hungarian Tradition.
    • Naxos.
    • 123.
  • Johannes Brahms

    Hungarian Dance No 7 in A major

    Performer: Istv谩n Kassai. Performer: Szilvia Elek.
    • Brahms: Hungarian Dances & the Hungarian Tradition.
    • Naxos.
    • 2401.
  • Ign谩c Frank

    Lujza cs谩rd谩s (Louise Cs谩rd谩s)

    Performer: Istv谩n Kassai.
    • Brahms: Hungarian Dances & the Hungarian Tradition.
    • Naxos.
    • 125.
  • Carlo Gesualdo

    Madrigali libro sesto, 1611: Se la mia morte brami - Quando ridente, e bella

    Ensemble: Les Arts Florissants. Conductor: Paul Agnew.
    • Gesualdo: Madrigali, Libri Quinto & Sesto.
    • Harmonia Mundi.
    • 1.
  • Joseph Marchand

    Premiere Suite in A Major: VIII. Air gay

    Ensemble: {oh!} trio.
    • Joseph Marchand: Suites.
    • Aparte.
    • 8.
  • Ludwig van Beethoven

    Violin Concerto in D major, Op 61: III. Rondo. Allegro (cadenza by J枚rg Widmann)

    Performer: Veronika Eberle. Orchestra: London Symphony Orchestra. Conductor: Sir Simon Rattle.
    • Beethoven: Violin Concerto.
    • LSO Live.
    • 3.
  • C茅cile Chaminade

    Six Pieces romantiques:

    Ensemble: Roberto Prosseda. Ensemble: Alessandra Ammara.
    • Compositrices: New Light on French Romantic Women Composers.
    • Bru Zane.
    • 1.
  • Rita Strohl

    Grande Fantaisie-Quintette: II. Scherzo. Allegro moderato

    Performer: Isma毛l Margain. Ensemble: Quatuor Hanson.
    • Compositrices: New Light on French Romantic Women Composers.
    • Bru Zane.
    • 8.
  • Charlotte Sohy

    Symphony in C-Sharp Minor: I. Lent - Vif

    Orchestra: Orchestre national de France. Conductor: Debora Waldman.
    • Compositrices: New Light on French Romantic Women Composers.
    • Bru Zane.
    • 11.

Record Review

The link below each recording takes you directly to the label鈥檚 website. Please be aware that non-UK labels may be cheaper via a record store or an online retailer.

9.00am

So Romantique! 鈥 music by Gounod, Bizet, Dubois, etc.

Cyrille Dubois (tenor)

Orchestre National de Lille

Pierre Dumoussaud

Alpha听 ALPHA924

Prokofiev: Symphony No. 1

London Symphony Orchestra

Gianandrea Noseda

LSO Live 听LSO0363D (download only)

Beethoven: The Late Quartets

Calidore String Quartet

Signum听 SIGCD733 (3 CDs)

Strauss: Four Last Songs

Rachel Willis-S酶rensen (soprano)

Sebastian Pilgrim (baritone)

Gewandhausorchester Leipzig

Andris Nelsons

Sony 听G0100046038977

Saint-Sa毛ns: Violin Works

Cecilia Zilliacus (violin)

Christian Ihle Hadland (piano)

Stephen Fitzpatrick (harp)

BIS 听BIS2489 (Hybrid SACD)

09.30am 鈥 William Mival: New Releases

Beethoven: Symphony No. 2 & Symphony No. 5

Ensemble1800berlin

MDG 听MDG9272276 (Hybrid SACD)

Frederic Rzewski: Dreams; War Songs; Winter Nights; Saints and Sinners

Bobby Mitchell (piano)

Naxos听 8.559928

Korngold: String Quartets Nos. 1-3

Tippett Quartet

Naxos听 8.574428

Gy枚rgy Ligeti: Complete Works For A Cappella Choir

SWR Vokalensemble

Tomoko Hemmi

Yuval Weinberg

SWR Music 听SWR19128CD (2 CDs)

William Mival: On Repeat

Locke: Consort of Fower Parts

Jordi Savall

Alia Vox听 ADE011

Listener On Repeat

Adams: Grand Pianola Music & Reich: Vermont Counterpoint & Eight Lines

Ransom Wilson (flute)

EMI 听3315345 (download only)

Also available on:

100 Best American Classics 鈥 music by Sousa, Gershwin, Reich, etc.

Ransom Wilson (flute / piccolo)

and others

Warner Classics听 9728002 (6 CDs)

10.10am 鈥 New Releases

Johannes Brahms: Hungarian Dances and the Hungarian Tradition

Adrienn Miksch

J谩nos B谩ndi

Ferenc Szecs艖di

Szilvia Elek

Istv谩n Kassai

Naxos 8.574424-25 (2 CDs)

Gesualdo: Madrigali, Libri Quinto & Sesto

Les Arts Florissants

Paul Agnew

Harmonia Mundi听 HAF890531112 (2 CDs)

10.30am 鈥 Building a Library: Sarah Devonald on Saint-Sa毛ns's Carnival of the Animals (repeated from 25th September 2021)

Recommended recording:

Renaud Capu莽on (violin)

Gautier Capu莽on (cello)

Frank Braley & Michel Dalberto (piano)

Emmanuel Pahud (flute)

Paul Meyer (clarinet)

David Guerrier (trumpet)

Marie-Pierre Langlamet (harp)

B茅atrice Muthelet (viola)

Esther Hoppe (violin)

Janne Saksala (double bass)

Florent Jodelet (percussion)

Erato听 5456032

Other recommendations:

Bela Siki & G茅za Anda (piano)

Philharmonia Orchestra

Igor Markevitch

Diapason听 43636听 (download only)

Henri Demarquette (cello)

Boris Berezovsky & Brigitte Engerer (pianos)

Ensemble Orchestral de Paris

Joseph Swensen

Mirare听 MIR108

11:15 am

Joseph Marchand: Suites

{oh!} Trio

Apart茅听 AP301

Beethoven: Violin Concerto

Veronika Eberle (violin)

London Symphony Orchestra

Sir Simon Rattle

LSO听 LSO5094 (Hybrid SACD)

11.25am 鈥 Record of the Week

Compositrices: New Light on French Romantic Women Composers 鈥 music by Chaminade, Strohl, Sohy, etc.

Roberto Prosseda and Alessandra Ammara (piano, four hands)

Isma毛l Margain (piano)

Quatuor Hanson

Orchestre National de France

D茅bora Waldman

and others

Bru Zane 听BZ2006 (8 CDs)

Broadcast

  • Sat 11 Mar 2023 09:00

Composers A to Z

Composers A to Z

Visit the extensive Radio 3 audio archive of programmes about composers and their works.

Browse previous episodes of the Record Review Podcast

Browse previous episodes of the Record Review Podcast

All episodes since 2010, listed alphabetically by composer surname.

Why the music we love as teens stays with us for life

Cognitive neuropyschology can explain why we return to old favourites again and again.