大象传媒


Explore the 大象传媒
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.
3 Oct 2014

大象传媒 Homepage
大象传媒 Radio
Home Truths - with John Peel 大象传媒 Radio 4

Radio 4

Home Truths
Listen Again
About John Peel

Help
Feedback
Like this page?
Mail it to a friend


Only Child

Are only children fortunate or to be pitied? Home Truths gathered a trio of "onlies" to see what they thought.

Anne Brown of Chatham, Andrea Rogers of Taunton and Mary McIlvenny of Northampton are only children and they describe their feelings and experiences of the subject.

Is there something instantly recognisable about an only child?
Anne - Only children are really part of a select club, members of which can always recognise each other instantly. I would imagine they wouldn鈥檛 be too gregarious. Andrea - they鈥檇 probably be self conscious as well and probably disappear into the background unless they鈥檇 had one too many and then they鈥檇 be over the top. Mary - They would be more reticent and one of the learning things is that you have to learn to overcome that with confidence ..you haven鈥檛 got any other support but yourself and it really is you against the world.

Why is it difficult being an only child?
Mary - I think because you don鈥檛 have the natural repartee at home...for me the greatest disadvantage is that you don鈥檛 learn to be witty and have instant rapport. You think it, but you don鈥檛 say it and maybe that sparring with others when you are young, seems to have a long lasting effect and because I didn鈥檛 do it, I therefore feel inadequate in crowds and I don鈥檛 push myself forward and I wait for others to seek me out. Andrea - never getting picked for school teams, so whenever that situation came up you鈥檇 be the last one.

What did you miss out on as an only child?
Andrea - I think I missed out on being ordinary. I was told I was very special as a child by her parents. They were wonderful parents and I was special to them and my poor mother has had 45 years of me saying why didn鈥檛 you have another child?

Did you have any imaginary friends?
Mary - I didn鈥檛 have imaginary friends. I used to image that I was other people and pretend I was like them and make it all wonderful for them and surround myself with other imaginary children.

Andrea - You get very good at people watching. I鈥檓 now a homeopath and I watch patients as well as speaking and listening to them and I鈥檓 sure that developed from kind of isolation of just watching and not being involved. Anne - I am very good at working people out , I don鈥檛 just look at the covering I look inside the book so to speak. I do judge people...I can鈥檛 help it I鈥檓 very judgemental. Mary - You do become very receptive to every single nuance. Andrea - You do become serious and you watch other people gadding about their lives and they seem so airy and you think I wish I could be like that too.

Mary - I think that as an only child there鈥檚 always something missing, that sort of solidarity, that missing link. Maybe people with families, are unaware that they see things through the same shade, and you don't. You see it through your own shade and no body shares that with you. Andrea - I see myself doing sibling rivalry now with my husband, my kids, my mates. And they say "hang on". It鈥檚 like I鈥檓 living that part of family life out now.

Anne - Do you regard your long standing friends as more siblings than friends?
Mary - your friendships are much deeper than other people鈥檚 relationships with their friends. You expect much more from them as well because you give them so much more. I wonder how much we鈥檙e indoctrinated into the "big family" as a sort of deity. It comes up at school even in the reading list. You start with something like Little Women, then you are on to Pride and Prejudice and you haven鈥檛 got any of this family stuff and it鈥檚 many years later when you realise just how dysfunctional this lot was. Anne - I find as I get older I鈥檓 grateful for the moulding it gave me. I鈥檓 a strong person now and the world can throw very little at me that I can鈥檛 cope with because I have to rely on me.

Mary - There鈥檚 one disadvantage that you can鈥檛 overcome. It happened to me about 20 years ago when my mother was very ill and I realised that her life was very much in my hands. The authorities came in and told me that she needed to be institutionalized. That was a very traumatic experience because there鈥檚 no one to discuss it with no-one to share the responsibility with.

Have they got more than one child? Anne - has three sons. I didn鈥檛 want them to go through what I鈥檇 experienced Mary - has two son. Andrea has one daughter and three sons.

How has being an only child affected you?
Do you have any regrets or was it a good experience?

Join the discussion on the Home Truths Message Board

Listen Again
Hear John Peel's Tribute Program

About the 大象传媒 | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy