´óÏó´«Ã½

Explore the ´óÏó´«Ã½
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.


Accessibility help
Text only
´óÏó´«Ã½ Homepage
´óÏó´«Ã½ Radio
Today´óÏó´«Ã½ Radio 4

Today
Listen Again
Latest Reports
Interview of the Week
About Today
Today at 50
Contact Today

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

Ìý
Weekdays 6-9am and Saturdays 7-9am How to listen to Today
Latest Reports

RAIL SAFETY

PRINT VERSION


Roger HarrabinByÌýRoger Harrabin

A new report says train passengers won't feel totally safe until rail bosses show they are fully competent to run the network.


LISTEN
Do we spending enough (or too much) on rail safety? Tony Taig is author of the report and Maureen Kavanagh is Chair of Safe Trains Action Group.
Train Protection Warning System

Train Protection Warning System
USEFUL LINKS

The Report Railway Safety Statistics



The Slower Speeds Initiative



The ´óÏó´«Ã½ is not responsible for the content of external websites

Clearing up the carnage after the Selby crash

Clearing up the carnage after the Selby crash
car crash

Far more people die on the roads....
train ticket

How much - the cost of safety?
The authors of the report for the Rail Safety and Standards Board say train managers are working under a false assumption that ever-increasing investment in safety gadgets will satisfy the public.

They say people want to feel confident in management competence. But they might prefer to see taxpayers' money invested in road safety where a life can be saved for one hundredth of the cost of a life that will be saved by the new train safety system TPWS.

The main author, risk consultant Tony Taig, says the rail industry should ask the public how taxpayers’ money should be spent on transport safety.

The authors believe the media has hyped train crashes so most people think trains are riskier than they really are. They are urging rail bosses to inform the public about the true likelihood of being involved in a crash on a train.

They point out that the incidence of fatal train crashes has been going down steadily from 8.8 a year in the 1940s (see chart) to 1 a year so far this century. Contrary to popular opinion, they say, fewer people have died in the 9 years since rail privatisation (97) compared with the nine years before privatisation (127).

The authors say that if the public are engaged in a rational debate, most accept a trade-off between safety and cost. Rail travellers approached by the Today Programme at Hampstead Heath station in London were shocked to hear that the £10 million cost of preventing a fatality through the TPWS system will be funded by taxpayers. (This was the cheaper safety system on offer to the rail industry.)

The report says train bosses have an ethical duty to inform people about their safety decisions, in order to be confident that their policies will be supported by the public.

This is the approach, the authors say, that has been adopted by the health body NICE that decides which drugs should be publicly funded, and by the Food Standards Agency.

They believe that if consulted, most people would prefer to spend public money on making the roads safer for children. They say local authorities claim a life can be saved with £100,000 invested in traffic calming measures like road humps, road narrowing or safety cameras. This is much less than the notional value of £1.14 million that the government puts on the value of a life lost on the roads. But councils complain that although the government has increased the amount of cash available for capital spending on road safety projects, councils do not have the staff available to spend the money in accordance with people’s wishes.

- CLICK HERE TO READ YOUR EMAILS AND HAVE YOUR SAY -


Back to Reports Homepage

Latest Reports

Back to Latest Reports Homepage

Audio Archive
Missed a programme? Or would you like to listen again?
Try last 7 days below or visit the Audio Archive page:

Saturday
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday

Today | Listen Again | Latest Reports | Interview of the Week | About Today | Today at 50 | Have Your Say | Contact Today



About the ´óÏó´«Ã½ | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy
Ìý