´óÏó´«Ã½

Explore the ´óÏó´«Ã½
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

16 October 2014

Island Threads


´óÏó´«Ã½ Homepage
Scotland
»Island Blogging
Western Isles

Baleshare
Barra
Benbecula
Bernera
Berneray
Canna
Eigg
Eriskay
Grimsay
Harris
Lewis
Muck
North Uist
Raasay
Rum
Scalpay
Skye
Soay
South Uist
Vatersay

Argyll & Clyde Islands
Northern Isles

Contribute
House Rules

From the ´óÏó´«Ã½
I.B.H.Q.
Ìý

Contact Us

nature


the programme, Monday evening ´óÏó´«Ã½ radio 4, this week was about Lewis, the proposed wind factory and the RSPB, if you want to hear it, it is available on line until next Monday via the listen again link,

*21:00

19 March 2007
A controversial wind farm on the Outer Hebridean island of Lewis has split the local community, despite winning the approval of the Council for the Western Isles. Conservation groups including the RSPB are concerned that the 181 proposed turbines and their associated infrastructure will harm populations of rare breeding birds and damage peatland habitats. But with renewable energy at a premium and a welcome injection of jobs for the island, the scheme is an attractive economic proposition. Brett Westwood explores the difficult decisions to be made in shaping the future of Lewis's landscape and prosperity.*
from the beeb web pages,

I know this is a nature programme so that perhaps explains why it tended to concentrate on the effect of the wind factory on the birds, no where did I hear the ‘T’ word, Tourism, they spoke of jobs created but again no mention of jobs lost in the tourist industry, if Lewis wants to keep it’s women then it needs to keep it’s tourist industry because tourism employs a large female workforce, the jobs created were only during the building stage, there was mention of the surveys done, I’d like to know who does give their opinion in these surveys because I have never met one person who has been asked their opinion, the migrating Whooper Swans were mentioned, someone claims to have looked for them and said they couldn’t find many so do not see how it can be a problem, well they obviously didn’t look at the loch between Galson and Dell because they were there again as I have seen them every year since I moved to Ness, there was no mention of the carbon released when they dig up the peat beds,

they mentioned that land is owned by the community but they did not say that the Galson estate has only just come into the ownership of the local community, a community that does not want the wind factory but the go ahead was given by the previous private owners of the Galson estate,

I used to be pro wind energy but since I learnt that the main reason for wind factories is to sell green units to companies that do not intend to clean up their act, I am against them,

as for all those greenies who protested loudly about Mrs Tiggywinkles being killed, I haven’t heard one single word of protest at the disruption of wildlife habitat and deaths of hundreds of birds and small creatures, but I expect that’s because they are the very people this electric is going to on the mainland,

can you tell I was not impressed at the way the programme portrayed Lewis,

I can't quiet believe it but the radio has just played Joni Mitchell's 'they paved paradise' and the line I think is most appropriate is
'you don't know what you have till it's gone'


Posted on Island Threads at 20:59

Comments

nice pics where are they going to put up the parking lot?

carol feeling sad for you from france


Will listen to that programme on-line, thanks for the heads-up. Am not surprised to hear the slant they've taken, bearing in mind the general attitude towards the island south of the Watford Gap.

Arnish Lighthouse from Stornoway


I often wonder where they get there information from as well....maybe it's from councellors here who claim they have never heard one word of protest...WHATEVER!! It's a shame cllr Nicolson hasn't caused as much of a media frenzy over this as he has over the fact that a car company decided to re-use Stornoway grey as a car colour(apparently the colour used to be used for Astin Martin) How can he claim to be concerned that the use of a colour name will damage the islands tourist industry?? Does he think that wind turbines will be a lure and therefore not worth the petitions he will create over the importance of a car colour??

tanith from point


www.hebrides.biz reckons that villagers in Gravir in Lewis are up in arms as the subsea cable (plus a large substation and transmission network) to export the giant wind parks electricity from Lewis is proposed to come ashore in their village at Gravir, a small village next to the Pairc and Eishken windfarms. Incidentally, the previous private owners of Galson are ordinary working people (one an undertaker, the other an education officer) who have always lived on Lewis (in Stornoway and Point).

Jack from Lewis


Is that your garden? Because, if it is, I'd be interested to know how much, if any, shelter the conifers on the right get. And what else grows there..

Flying Cat from trug&trowel


Listening to the Lewis report, Radio 4, right now. Thanks, Island Threads. The ´óÏó´«Ã½ Radio Player (internet) brings the program in very clearly.

mjc from NM,USA


If Island Threads is not careful, a wind turbine might grow there.

mjc from NM,USA


Fence/posts: did Na Hearadh come and help you put them up. He has been strangely silent these past days. Maybe one of those Highland quadrupeds thought he was a would be toreador and ended his pole setting career?

mjc from NM,USA


Jack, thanks for the info about the previous owners of the Galson estate, I know of Gravir and know that there are many communities both on island and off that do not like this wind factory, please do not say park as parks are happy places,

island threads from lewis


carol and mjc, the moor in the photo is exactly where the wind turbines are going, I heard a story that most houses on the westside will be able to see approximately 50 from their homes, but my main concern is the tourist industry, lots of families make a living from mixing work in more than one small industry, fishing, crofting, tourism, etc.

island threads from lewis


yes front is my garden the other side of the fence is a field, the trees were planted about 25 years ago (so I am told) the only shelter is that the garden is down the hill, I have planted trees all around the plot and some are growing some are not, I think you just have to try things and see what goes, some plants die other are like thugs and bullies trying to take over, go for it eff cee,

island threads from lewis


I have some good friends in Gravir too ... They are very well-informed there ... It was from them I got the views that I expressed on one of Arnish Lighthouses previous posts, about how the setting up of the infrastructure for the raising of the turbines is going to be the stumbling block for all of this, and how mainland authorities in high places are absolutely amazed that such a piece of costly and ill-informed tomfoolery is being allowed to run unchallenged for so very very long ...

soaplady from reiteration point


Thanks for the link to the programme.

Annie B from the usual


carol and mjc, the moor in the photo is exactly where the wind turbines are going, I heard a story that most houses on the westside will be able to see approximately 50 from their homes, but my main concern is the tourist industry, lots of families make a living from mixing work in more than one small industry, fishing, crofting, tourism, etc.

island threads from lewis


yes front is my garden the other side of the fence is a field, the trees were planted about 25 years ago (so I am told) the only shelter is that the garden is down the hill, I have planted trees all around the plot and some are growing some are not, I think you just have to try things and see what goes, some plants die other are like thugs and bullies trying to take over, go for it eff cee,

island threads from lewis


Sorry, off topic: I stayed with the Macaskills near Gravir 30 years ago, does anyone here perhaps remember exactly where they lived? The mother was 80 and blind and she had 2 sons, one was with CalMac Ferries. They lived at the end of a road that her husband had built years ago, the 'shop' van came round once a week. Thank you, if anyone does respond.

Stuart from South Africa


Stuart, Can you remember anything more about the MacAskills you stayed with in Gravir? I'm from that part of the world originally, so can dig up some info for you. There was a few MacAskill families in the village, all related. Did they live at the head of the loch, or was it in a part of the village not over looking the sea? I don't think there are many MacAskills left in the village now - mostly white settlers there.

ex-pat from europe




This blog is now closed and we are no longer accepting new posts.



About the ´óÏó´«Ã½ | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy
Ìý