大象传媒

Essay-writing tips: Points for and against

Mr Birling acts inconsiderately towards Eric

You could include some of the following points in your essay:

  • Mr Birling dismisses Eric鈥檚 concerns about war, 鈥淵ou鈥檝e a lot to learn yet鈥
  • both he and Gerald tease Eric before lecturing him about what 鈥渟ome of these boys ... nowadays鈥 get up to
  • he speaks sharply to Eric and tried to silence him in front of the Inspector, 鈥淛ust keep quiet鈥
  • he speaks angrily to Eric when Eric questions his dismissal of Eva
  • he takes no responsibility for Eric鈥檚 actions as a parent and he reacts bitterly to Eric鈥檚 drinking and behaviour
  • he appears unapproachable as a parent, calling Eric a 鈥渄amned fool"
  • he calls Eric 鈥渟辫辞颈濒迟鈥, a product of the 鈥減ublic-school-and-Varsity life鈥 - however, he has paid for this education.
  • he blames Eric for everything that has happened
  • he threatens to throw Eric out of the house, 鈥淎nd I say 鈥 either stop shouting or get out鈥
  • Eric says, 鈥測ou鈥檙e not the kind of father a chap could go to when he鈥檚 in trouble鈥

Mr Birling acts inconsiderately towards Sheila

You could include some of the following points in your essay:

  • his speech on the engagement of Sheila and Gerald concentrates more on 鈥渂耻蝉颈苍别蝉蝉鈥 than on the happiness of his daughter
  • his tone is patronising, 鈥淣othing to do with you, Sheila. Run along鈥
  • he does not know how to communicate with Sheila and asks his wife, 鈥淲hat鈥檚 the matter with that child?鈥
  • he attempts to stop her hearing about Gerald and Eva, because their engagement is important to his business
  • he tries make excuses for Gerald鈥檚 affair with Eva, 鈥測ou must understand that a lot of young men - 鈥
  • when Sheila tries to get her parents to take responsibility for their actions towards Eva he reacts angrily and tells her to 鈥淏e quiet鈥

Mr Birling does not act inconsiderately

You could include some of the following points in your essay:

  • Mr Birling shows pride in his daughter鈥檚 engagement, 鈥淚鈥檓 delighted about this engagement鈥
  • he appears generous when he offers Eric more port
  • he gives Eric advice about women; 鈥測ou鈥檝e got to remember, my boy, that clothes mean something quite different to a woman鈥
  • he tries to protect Sheila from the 鈥渦npleasant business鈥 by getting her to leave the room
  • he wants to prevent the Inspector interviewing either of his children, 鈥淣ow, Inspector, perhaps you and I had better go and talk this over quietly in a corner鈥
  • he is concerned for Sheila when she becomes upset.
  • he exchanges a 鈥渇rightened look鈥 with his wife when they realise what Eric has done
  • he tries to pay the Inspector off after Eric鈥檚 part in Eva鈥檚 death is revealed