大象传媒

Advantages and disadvantages of technology

Technology brings benefits to sport, but it also brings disadvantages. Sometimes the technology needs to be embedded and improved before it is fully effective, often the problems only emerge after time.

These tables highlight some of the advantages and disadvantages of technology in sport.

For athletes

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Better performance 鈥 marginal gains make the differenceInvades privacy
Better medical care results in fewer injuries or faster recovery from injuryBlurs lines between personal and professional time
Feedback from coaches is more focused, objective and helpfulAvailability and cost 鈥 makes sport and success exclusive to wealthy people and countries
Improved kit is more comfortable, more efficient and saferTempts athletes and coaches into cheating or unfair practices
Part of a team, not isolatedPuts the sole focus on winning not athletic endeavour
AdvantagesBetter performance 鈥 marginal gains make the difference
DisadvantagesInvades privacy
AdvantagesBetter medical care results in fewer injuries or faster recovery from injury
DisadvantagesBlurs lines between personal and professional time
AdvantagesFeedback from coaches is more focused, objective and helpful
DisadvantagesAvailability and cost 鈥 makes sport and success exclusive to wealthy people and countries
AdvantagesImproved kit is more comfortable, more efficient and safer
DisadvantagesTempts athletes and coaches into cheating or unfair practices
AdvantagesPart of a team, not isolated
DisadvantagesPuts the sole focus on winning not athletic endeavour

For officials

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Supports team approach so there is less pressure on individualsSlows the game
Information can be shared easily and quickly and stored over timeNot available at all levels of competition
Decisions and scoring are more reliable and accurateNo longer trust people's decisions
There is increased confidence and trust in officialsUndermines respect for officials' knowledge and expertise
Undermines honesty, integrity and the spirit of fair play
AdvantagesSupports team approach so there is less pressure on individuals
DisadvantagesSlows the game
AdvantagesInformation can be shared easily and quickly and stored over time
DisadvantagesNot available at all levels of competition
AdvantagesDecisions and scoring are more reliable and accurate
DisadvantagesNo longer trust people's decisions
AdvantagesThere is increased confidence and trust in officials
DisadvantagesUndermines respect for officials' knowledge and expertise
Advantages
DisadvantagesUndermines honesty, integrity and the spirit of fair play

For spectators

AdvantagesDisadvantages
More engaged in the sportDetracts from actual play
More informed about rules, players etcReduces the atmosphere at live events
Have a direct link to athletesReduces interest in grass roots events that aren't supported by technology
Increases spectator/broadcaster costs
Enables trolls to attack individual athletes
AdvantagesMore engaged in the sport
DisadvantagesDetracts from actual play
AdvantagesMore informed about rules, players etc
DisadvantagesReduces the atmosphere at live events
AdvantagesHave a direct link to athletes
DisadvantagesReduces interest in grass roots events that aren't supported by technology
Advantages
DisadvantagesIncreases spectator/broadcaster costs
Advantages
DisadvantagesEnables trolls to attack individual athletes

For sport generally

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Increases participationDetracts from intensity of physical activity
Promotes new and alternative opportunitiesReduces emotional wellbeing that comes from escaping digital pressures/routines
Supports less-wealthy sports to promote themselvesIncreases costs to sports and participants
Leads to more coverage and revenueSponsors more interested in technology than sport or athletes
Adds glamour
Improves safety
AdvantagesIncreases participation
DisadvantagesDetracts from intensity of physical activity
AdvantagesPromotes new and alternative opportunities
DisadvantagesReduces emotional wellbeing that comes from escaping digital pressures/routines
AdvantagesSupports less-wealthy sports to promote themselves
DisadvantagesIncreases costs to sports and participants
AdvantagesLeads to more coverage and revenue
DisadvantagesSponsors more interested in technology than sport or athletes
AdvantagesAdds glamour
Disadvantages
AdvantagesImproves safety
Disadvantages

Impact of technology on coaches

A coach will need to have access to high end technology in order to help their sports people to train and perform at their highest level. This means coaches will need to stay up to date with current technology and be able to afford the required equipment. This means that coaches working with organisations that have a lot of money are going to be able to help to support their athletes to get to higher performance levels compared to coaches working with organisations with lower incomes which have less money to spend on technology.

Question

Identify one benefit and one problem of using technology to support disabled performers in sport.