´óÏó´«Ã½

« Previous | Main | Next »

Scouting For Girls - 'This Ain't A Love Song'

Post categories:

Fraser McAlpine | 09:38 UK time, Tuesday, 23 March 2010

Scouting For Girls

Well this puts the cat among the scaredy-mice and no mistake. Scouting For Girls have decided to grow up a little bit, leave behind the helter-skelter tumbledown sillypop of 'She's So Lovely' and 'Elvis Ain't Dead' and add a little mature wisdom to their sound.

This will be good news to those of you who froth at the mouth at the very mention of the band's name, or at least, better news than you might've feared, but not quite the Band Disappear In Puff Of Smoke headline you might've wished for, Me, I'm unconvinced.

While we're on that point, another thing I'm not sure I get is where all the vitriol is coming from. I don't think anyone would claim that the Scouts are an IMPORTANT BAND in that kind of deadening, circular way people do when a new band sounds like an old band who probably were, given the benefit of hindsight, quite influential - on the new band at the very least.

They are - or were - a band whose songs could be played at children's discos and would guarantee to fill the floor. Apparently this is a bad thing.

Well now they sound like a matey Keane, is everyone happy now?

(. Despair in the departure lounge.)

OK, so that's not perhaps the biggest sonic departure the world has ever experienced, that honour goes to Paul Cattermole, the fella who left S Club 7 to form a nu-metal band, but it's still noticeable. It's all there in the 'Somewhere Only We Know' introduction, with the stately piano and the swelling orchestra and the overwhelming Keaney Keaneity of things.

Thankfully Roy's voice is still far too ripe and rude to slip into Tom Chaplin's choirboy innocence. There's a grain to it which - for me - always saved the most indefensibly silly bits of their songs from being a total wackyfest. Plus they always put a climactic breakdown in their best songs, like the "I don't know, I don't know" bit in 'She's So Lovely', which you wouldn't do if your only wish was to jolly the world up.

No chance of that here, of course. It's a breakup song, none of the lyrics are clever-clever and it is stately and dignified. All perfectly fine things in their own right, but I can't be the only person who thinks showing some personality is just as important as not being irritating, can I?

Three starsDownload: 28th March

´óÏó´«Ã½ Music page

(Fraser McAlpine)

Comments

  • Comment number 1.

    for me they've just lost the catchy aspect that made them bearable (at first) and now they're just boring. oh and one guy commented on the youtube video of the track saying that these guys were the best thing to come out of the uk 'after all this time'. -sigh-

  • Comment number 2.

    Well I quite like it. It's a fresh, unexpected sound with a slight maturity that I was quite impressed with. So four stars. So there.

  • Comment number 3.

    Okay, let's not beat about the bush. Scouting For Girls are hardly an influential band are they?
    Their songs were delightful little three-minute pop-ditties back in the days of 'She's So Lovely' and 'It's Not About You'. But, and this is a big but... the kind of but that detracts from the all-important listen-factor. ALL their songs sounded THE SAME.

    I mean, it's not a good choice to have every song from your debut album sounding similar; because you're as fairly new band with good but similar sounding songs, the public is going to wonder which song they're listening to at some state.

    This was a problem.

    But now it isn't. The songs have a much less bubble-gum pop sound to them and sound all grown up and growly (see the very last lines), with a hint of whiney falsetto coming from Roy's unmistakeable voice, especially noticeable in the bridge.

    I quite like this song, I'd imagine many other would as well. No it's not a milestone covered but if the music world has a place for the likes of Taio Cruz, Justin Bieber, will.i.am, N-Dubz, Jay-Sean etc... I think you'd have to be too pretentious to not like this song.

    4 stars. (:

  • Comment number 4.

    Sorry to break up the party but I don't like it. What Scouting For Girls had going for them before was that they were fun and didn't seem to be taking themselves seriously in anyway. I'm not saying that they're taking themselves seriously now but the new 'mature' doesn't work for them, the song ends up feeling lifeless and becomes dull once you realise that they're still using all the same tricks.
    2 STARS

  • Comment number 5.

    'It's not about you' is still an absolutely grade A, fantastic, pop song. It didn't get half as much attention as their next songs, 'She's so Lovely', 'Elvis..' and 'Heartbeat' but I' argue it's much better than any of them.

    Im do like SFG, in a fun not serious, attention grabbing, catchy way. The tracks I mention above are all good, 'It's not about you' abd 'Heartbeat' in particular I guess.

    This? Still as catchy, in fact I've been humming it all day, even before I read this. Any good? Nah. 3 stars, just pretty generic and catchy.

    SFG influential? Again nah.

    But nothing in the review or what I've just written isn't known to most people with a half serious interest in the charts! Apart from maybe my argument 'It's not about you' is an amazing song. Because I guess most people won't agree!!

  • Comment number 6.

    It's not about You was an absolutely fantastic debut single .

    The biggest quality this band have going for them , is that ALL their singles have at least 5 huge hooks in them , and this has served to galvanise immense interest in the band from lots of listeners .

    Roy Stride live , is a very professional , charismatic lead singer , who had the crowd , entranced from the word go , when I saw them live .

    She's so Lovely , despite being extremely annoying to many , had so many hooks that grabbed people in , and became the song that really put them in the limelight .

    2 further top 10 singles followed , that again were brimming with hooks , and this culminated in their debut album going double platinum .

    Scouting For Girls are certainly a "marmite " band , but in my view they do what they do extremely well , and you get more hooks per song than many other bands , so that's value for money.

    "This Ain't A Love Song " will be another top 20 hit , is again well crafted , has more hooks than a your local dry cleaners , but may lack an edge and dose of bad attitude that a lot of rock fans like .

    However , one must remember there is a big market for people who like songs they can singalong to. (Take That have sold over 5 million albums in UK in the last few years !) Some people like bands you could take home to meet your Mum.
    Roy and the boys are gentlemen, who would probably not throw your Mum's TV out of the window ,unlike other bands , you could think of!!

    And on that note , the album EVERYBODY WANTS TO BE ON TV is out on April 12th .

  • Comment number 7.

    Yeah , just heard the song again , and yes , I like it more ,each time I hear it . It's a great comeback single , that loads of their fans and casual listeners will like .
    And yes , there are are at least 8 catchy hooks in this song .
    A very professional return , I bet the record company love it !

  • Comment number 8.

    Spirit, I know hooks are important in a commercial pop song but shouldn't a little originality be required as well.

  • Comment number 9.

    It's nice , but not paramount . This Ain't A Love Song is not original , but it does what it does , extremely well , and will appeal to many people.
    I understand SFG polarize opinion , but it's an extremely well crafted and well produced song .
    It doesn't try to reinvent the wheel .

  • Comment number 10.

    Give spirit a cigar. Really hit the nail on the head with this band, they may not be influential and loved by all, but they do do their jobs far better than most UK bands.
    I'm sorry to say... where did The Killers go with 'Day & Age'? First single 'Human' - #3 in the charts, then the criminally underappreciated 'Spaceman' left them clinging on only just at #40. Then the last two singles charted somewhere between #80-#150, so your could say SFG have consistency, which is good.

  • Comment number 11.

    You've just opened a can of worms there Oddone. 'Spaceman' was a poor single choice in my opinion! So was 'Day and Age' which, off the top of my head, was the third single choice. See the review on 'Dustland Fairytale' for the massive debate that ensued about The Killers there!

    Wikipedia says the album 'Day and age' has sold 1,200,000+ copies. (Sam's town a similar ammount and 'Hot Fuss' 1,800,000+).

    I cant find the numbers for SFG's album. Bet it doesn't touch any of them.

    Interestingly SFG released 7 (!!!) singles from their debut album. The later ones, including the AWFUL one about James Bond did not chart so well!

  • Comment number 12.

    Yeah , the James Bond one was a very ham fisted effort , that in my opinion had more cheese than a ploughman's sandwich !

    Ham n cheese normally go together well , but not on this occasion .

    The SFG album has sold approx 750,000 copies in the UK, the last time I looked , which is a fantastic return for a debut album.

    The Killers singles from Day and Age were :
    Human
    Spaceman
    The World We Live In ( which contains the phrase Day and Age )
    And the rather sweepingly epic A Dustland Fairytale which told the story of Brandon's parents meeting romantically in the 60's .
    (This song has taken an even deeper meaning to Brandon and many Killer's fans as his Mother sadly passed away a few weeks ago , and in my mind , the song has been elevated to even greater heights , as the intense brooding power that it possessed , has been multiplied , due to these sad events . )

  • Comment number 13.

    Really Liam? I thought 'Spaceman' was really very good. But I thought the final two singles 'The World We Live In' and 'A Dustland Fairytale' were awful. This is just my opinion though, don't bite me. ;)

    Anyhoo, this song is yummy, and should chart nicely too. I figure #8 peak position. (wahey, look at me trying my hand at spirit's psychic stuff ;))

  • Comment number 14.

    Yeah , you go for it Odd One .

    Definitely top 20 , that's me covering myself , but it is well capable of going higher .

  • Comment number 15.

    Oddone thats two posts I've seen from you with outrageous claims now!

    Dustland Fairytale a awful?!?! Scroll back a year or so to the review . . .it's one of The Killer's best tracks ever. And Im a MASSIVE fan of all 3 albums. It's one of the highlights of their live set and should have been the second single.

    'Human' is a great track and a good first single though.

  • Comment number 16.

    Yeah Oddone , I encourage you to go back and listen to A Dustland Fairytale again , bearing in mind , Brandon is singing from the heart about his parents meeting in the 60's .Do give the song a second chance .

    I did , and the effort was worth it .

    Check You Tube out for The Killers performing it on David Letterman , it brought a tear to my eye , and is an absolute masterclass in performing a moving song backed by a sympathetic orchestra , that helps to elevate the song to an even more wonderful place .

    Brilliant !

  • Comment number 17.

    Lol, I hate it when I get proven wrong.
    I just re-listened to 'A Dustland Fairytale' and it's not brilliant. It's like Coldplay's 'Strawberry Swing' (best song on 'Viva la Vida or Death and All His Freinds' in my opinion) but with guitars; much better than my first impressions. I'd give if four stars now, but not five.

  • Comment number 18.

    EDIT: "I just re-listened to 'A Dustland Fairytale' and it's brilliant"

    ... is what I should've said. (:

  • Comment number 19.

    That's MORE like it buddy !

    Check out the version on David Letterman for even more pleasure .

  • Comment number 20.

    Going back to the review , it made me think of acts that generally use jolly sounding instrumentation , while lyrically and vocally the singer sings tales of sadness, pain and woe .

    Generalising I know , but I can think of songs by :

    THE SMITHS - (Johnny's jangly, happy , guitar , Morissey's suffering )
    E.G Heaven Knows I'm Miserable Now . The Boy With The Thorn In His Side .


    THE CURE - Happy keyboard and guitar motifs , Robert Smith's obsession with death.
    E,G Close to me , Just Like Heaven , Lullaby

    EMINEM - Upbeat fairground sounds , while Marshall spits out poison.
    e.g We Made You , The Real Slim Shady , Without ME )

    Interesting .

  • Comment number 21.

    Oasis have done it a bit. On the sleevenotes to The Masterplan, there's a bit about Fade Away doing it, and refers to it as "a classic Buzzcocks trick", so I guess they're known for it too.

  • Comment number 22.

    Oh, and I think this is a cut above Scouting For Girls' usual pap, but still nothing memorable. Three stars if I had to rate it.

  • Comment number 23.

    SFG again! Yeah! (I can't afford a sarcasm symbol). The title is a bit offputting, falling somewhere between PIL and Bon Jovi in my head. At least PIL didn't use contractions.

    Still, the opening is a bit bombastic, and the strings, who are they kidding? Cheeky popsters all the way, they are, not "arrangers", still, nice chorus,typical SFG break down re."bloody big mess inside", good chorus. Too much chorus really, I got bored about two minutes in, but three stars for effort!

  • Comment number 24.

    At 20, Gilbert O'Sullivan "Alone Again Naturally" certainly doesn't sound as dark as the lyrics actually are if you listen to them.

  • Comment number 25.

    While we're living, the dreams we have as children fade away...

  • Comment number 26.

    @ 20,

    It's a shame some people don't realise that technique is becoming one of Mika's most recognisable traits...

    Look at 'We Are Golden'...

    It takes the concept of growing up and how teenage years are some of the most lonely and stressful of most peoples' lives. ("Now I'm sitting alone, and I'm looking for help. Left here on my own, I'm gunna hurt myself") Whilst the mournfulness doesn't come out in his voice in this song (see "Dr. John") he shows it in his lyrical depth, which people seem to overlook because of the marmite melody.
    It's about being hated but not caring because you can just go home and have a good old hairbrush moment... now come ON, you CANNOT say you've never had one of those. Seriously, just no.

  • Comment number 27.

    Hairbrush moments... nope, not had any of them... (except the one I stole from Little Boots dressing room, of course. I don't think she'd want it back now... and my cloning experiment is well begun.)

  • Comment number 28.

    Shame it's awful though, eh OddOne?

    Hairbrush moments? Glee is like a giant one.

  • Comment number 29.

    With the greatest possible respect to anyone present who represents an exception to this, and no value judgement being made on my part whatsoever (hopefully that's enough qualification), I think that straight guys are in general less prone to good old hairbrush moments.

    Singing along to songs they love - yes.

    Singing/miming into a hairbrush in front of the mirror - notsomuch.

  • Comment number 30.

    I own a mirror but not a hairbrush. I sing along to songs. Not in front of the mirror though. Am I confused? :(

  • Comment number 31.

    Yeah Liam, 'We Are Golden' is REALLY grating after about the first listen, but it's pleasing to hear from time to time.

    But hairbrush moments ARE AMAZING. Nuff sed bruvvah.

  • Comment number 32.

    @ 29. I don't mean fully grown up people. I mean like 7 years to 11 years-ish old. And I'm straight. Was then too.

  • Comment number 33.

    Expect to see this in the top 10 next Sunday, top 20 doesn't seem high enough for a song with this many hooks.

    P.S: I still don't like it though

  • Comment number 34.

    Yeah , anyone who knows music , can hear that this is gonna be a big hit .
    Blanket radio play , a song with a plethora of hooks , this is a commercial monster .
    I said , last week that this fine lead single , would chart well .
    Now I am saying a definite top 10 , and it is possibly gonna knock on the door of the top 5 and beg to be let in . . .

  • Comment number 35.

    Yes but She's So Lovely was a great lead single too and look at all the stinkers that followed that. I like This Ain't A Love Song but I don't have much hope for the follow-ups.

  • Comment number 36.

    'It's Not About You' was their debut wasn't it? Oh my days I must check my facts, but the point is 'Heartbeat' was v good, and so was 'Elvis Ain't Dead'

  • Comment number 37.

    Nope, the first single was She's So Lovely. It's Not About You was their fourth single but I can see how you can get confused. Nah I didn't think much of Elvis Ain't Dead and I thought Heartbeat was a big pile of turd! Can't understand how it cracked the Top 10.

  • Comment number 38.

    Actually, 'It's Not About You' was their lead. It was their first song to get Radio play. Scott mIlls made it his record of the week. It just had a limited release, so didn't chart well.

    Also still their best track, I don't ever see that changing.

  • Comment number 39.

    I checked Wiki, the above post is correct. I should have mentioned the fact that they did re-release it as a single after others.

  • Comment number 40.

    Anyone who thought this weeks chart was a bit boring don't worry because we've got an interesting week ahead of us.

    The Chart Blog Chart Report*
    Scouting For Girls may be not just knocking on the door of the top 5 they could have a no.1 on their hands, that's if the Itunes Charts is anything to go by.

    Also in other news christian rock band *shudder* Delirious? are looking set to gate crash this weeks top 20 thanks to a facebook campaign to get their song History Makers in the charts for Easter - personally I prefer Facebook when it's getting RATM to christmas no.1 because that's much more entertaining.

    And finally expect another top 10 single for Plan B with She Said and a possible climb for Usher ft. Will.i.am with OMG.

    *got a nice ring to it, doesn't it

  • Comment number 41.

    Yeah , my comments at 6 look set to be justified .

    This will certainly go top 3 , and if it can outsell GaGa , IT WILL BE number 1 !

    Throw loads of memorable hooks into a lead single , get blanket radio and TV play , because of said hooks , and you are looking at a recipe for success .

    The boys will be promoting the song all week .
    Good luck .

  • Comment number 42.

    Nah, I'm sorry but I don't see this being #1, I think #5 at a push, it is possible by then that GaGa won't be #1 so what could it be? Now I think about it, there isn't much more chart rivalry in terms of single releases except for Plan B, Usher ft. will.i.am, and Alex Gardner.

    As sad as it seems I don't see Plan B making #1 :'(
    Nor do I see Usher making it, maybe just cracking the Top 10.
    And as for Alex Gardner, Top 20 probably.

    Maybe GaGa will be #1 for a third week? Because there doesn't seem to be anything new and amazing; the Top 10 hasn't really changed much over the last two weeks... ish.

    Mind you, if spirit's right and promotion shoves this single upchart, it could probably crack the Top 3.

  • Comment number 43.

    Spirit will be right, and you know it , OddOne :)

    Relax , don't fight it . lol

  • Comment number 44.

    Boringly I'm with Spirit on this one. Physical release today too.

  • Comment number 45.

    Hold the front page ! Is the magnificent Liam , actually agreeing with me ?

    As Kylie sang in the chorus of her top 5 hit :

    " WOW , WOW , WOW , WOW ! "

  • Comment number 46.

    It happens on the odd occasion :p

    To be fair I think we both agree what makes a commercial success, what makes a good song and what we both like often overlaps well... I just don't always agree with predictions ;)

  • Comment number 47.

    I don't think I've ever been so happy to be proven wrong, becasue if the midweeks are anything to go by I hold my hands up right now and own up to being a dang fool

    Midweeks as of Teusday say this:

    1) SFG - This Ain't A Love Song
    2) Plan B - She Said
    3) GaGa and Honey B - Telephone

    very nooooiiiicccee.

  • Comment number 48.

    Hmm... quite good but not brilliant
    Still, looks like a definate no. 1, just shows what a good marketing campaign can do, it's as if they haven't been away for 2 and a half years(i hope the record label in charge of The Hoosiers is taking note, they have a new album out soon, but people will have forgotten about them if there's not a big push)
    As for Killlers debate, Dustland Fairytale is very good, and excellent live, esp. the small pause halfway through...but Spaceman owns all, everything about it was perfect, but no airplay, grr)
    The World We Live In = terrible

  • Comment number 49.

    I know, Spaceman was so amazing even my dad loved it!

  • Comment number 50.

    I hope The Hoosier's marketing director is away or has swine flu around the time of their come back personally. Then I won't have to listen to them.

  • Comment number 51.

    Yeah , I hear that Ray , the bands marketing director , is indeed , very ill with swine flu .

    Can you imagine how the band feel about this ?

  • Comment number 52.

    I dunno .. something about cops and robbers... nah .. lost without you? No that's a similar band ..

    Noooo idea Spirit :(

  • Comment number 53.

    Scouting For Girls have the Easter number 1 .

    You write a commercial radio friendly hit with 5 strong hooks , that appeal to your fans and is strong enough to get blanket radio play and draw in casual listeners then you have a big hit on your hands .
    Wow , all my earlier posts here look awfully prophetic , but when you hear a song like this , with so many commercial strengths , it's quite easy to hear .

    Congrats on your first number 1 single , lads !

  • Comment number 54.

    -sigh-.. mankind fails once more...

  • Comment number 55.

    The fact Rhianna is still in the top 10, along with Bieber, worries me more I think.

  • Comment number 56.

    what about Usher climbing into the top 10 with a song that basically consists of an annoying football chant and recycled beats from The E.N.D!

  • Comment number 57.

    At least The E.N.D cast offs are better than 'Baby, baby, baby ohh'. I mean really. To be fair the Usher lyrics fall just behind that in terms of "worst lyrics ever". Clearly Usher needs to sort his life out, as he's responsible for both of these musical deformities.

  • Comment number 58.

    ^^^^Last sentence: greatest putdown ever^^^^

  • Comment number 59.

    Someone give Liam a cigar. Those lyrics are truly awful. At least 'This Ain't A Love Song's lyrics mean something.

    In addition, I was quite annoyed the whilst it has been #1 for two weeks, the midweeks showed that Plan B would be #2, and GaGa and Honey B would reside at #3. How annoying.

    There's always next week, eh chaps?

  • Comment number 60.

    I heard the next SFG single today. Dear God.

  • Comment number 61.

    You heard the next Scouting For Girls single , Dear God .

    WOW , if that is the song's title , WHY didn't they make THAT song , the Easter NUMBER 1 SINGLE ?????!!!


    :)

  • Comment number 62.

    I guess they decided that the Christian buying power wasn't going to be good enough (as demonstrated with 'History Maker') and instead went for the buying power of people who like poorly constructed, repetitive, blatently manufactured to be a hit, yet strangely catchy, soulless indiepop music.

    Clearly worked! Hats off.

  • Comment number 63.

    It clearly worked !

    Not only a number 1 single , but number 1 in the uk airplay chart for the last 2 weeks .
    If you like em , grreat , if you don't run for cover !

    And have you heard their song Radio ?
    It's made for radio !
    And their album is made up what sounds like 10 singles

    That Roy guy , knows how to write pop hooks.

  • Comment number 64.

    Liam , I have booked you on a 9 month holiday to the Moon , to escape this bunch.

    We can have you back , ready , for the release of the next Justin Bieber album .

    See you soon .

    :)

  • Comment number 65.

    Yay!

    I really don't this track, particuarly when Usher puts it into context. It's just a bit of the same old from them. I did really like some stuff off the first album.. but as a result I don't really feel like I need any more the same old in my life.

    I hope the next track's a grower..

Ìý

´óÏó´«Ã½ iD

´óÏó´«Ã½ navigation

´óÏó´«Ã½ © 2014 The ´óÏó´«Ã½ is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.