Watch out Jen! Here's my Marley & Me review...
Marley & Me is so sugary and sweet that tickets should come with free toothpaste. It's also a film where nothing really happens. It's just a lot of...stuff.
The pic is based on newspaper columns by author John Grogan - columns about the everyday events of his life - and this is a film obsessed with the humdrum minutiae. Dog eats 'phone book; dog goes for a swim; dog takes a dump - like, big wow. It's a film version of someone saying 'Hey, a really HILARIOUS thing happened to me the other day' and you just switch off coz actually it's really dull. If Marley & Me is attempting to be zen-like in its minimalism then it fails by being so narcissistically obsessed with its own cuteness. I'm guessing it isn't though.
Owen Wilson and Jennier Aniston star. Their 'loveable kookiness' levels turned up to 11, but without any real impact. That's a real shock for Owen, so often awesome with his bewitching weirdness. Here he's just like Marley after visiting the vet's - without any testicles.
Occasionally the film hints that John (Owen) might be jealous of his wife's journalistic success and sad that his bachelor years are behind him. Those moments quickly pass, racing to a final 20 minutes that are so horribly schmaltzy, no manipulative sob story too low, they're perhaps the worst in cinema this year. Much of Marley & Me isn't really about anything but that finale rams home a vom-inducing message about All American, white, middle-class, two point four kids cosiness that should be consigned to hokey greetings card rather than polluting our multiplexes.
I left the cinema choking on a niceness overload, suffocated by what's basically 'Andrex Puppy: The Movie'.Ìý1 star.
Comment number 1.
At 11th Mar 2009, craig-maclellan wrote:Hey James
Completely agree with you. I've not actually seen the film, but it's clear from the (awful) trailer that this is what the film is about.
Loving the written review. I never miss the Friday reviews, but sometimes a review can be all the more brutal when written.
And Jennifer Aniston in a rom-com? She's really stretching herself and is definately trying to shrug off that 'Rachel from Friends' tag, isn't she.
If anyone's after other written masterpieces, follow the link (selfless self promotion over):
Complain about this comment (Comment number 1)
Comment number 2.
At 12th Mar 2009, geoffowen23 wrote:According to Empire this isn't even a comedy. I find the idea of a film with Aniston, Wilson and a dog that is not even a comedy a terrifying thought.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 2)
Comment number 3.
At 13th Mar 2009, bad_scally_ally wrote:I went to see Marley & Me last night and i thought that it could possibly be the worst bit of cinema of the whole year (even though we are only in march). Some people were leaving the cinema in tears but they obviously couldnt see through the spineless lack of storyline and general "throw up in my popcorn" moments towards the end.
I think 1 star is even generous
scally
Complain about this comment (Comment number 3)