´óÏó´«Ã½

´óÏó´«Ã½ BLOGS - Douglas Fraser's Ledger
« Previous | Main | Next »

Celtic connections

Douglas Fraser | 16:55 UK time, Tuesday, 15 February 2011

What is the purpose of a football club, particularly an Old Firm one?

To win the league, to have a good run in Europe, to keep fans happy?

Or could it be to speculate on the commodity of up-and-coming players - spotting them young, buying them cheap, bringing them on, and then selling them at a profit?

Celtic put out its six-monthly figures yesterday, and it's clear that player development has become an explicit part of the business model.

The numbers underlining the continuing headache the Old Firm have with unpredictable good and bad runs in Europe.

A good run can fund an expensive team. A dud one leaves your pay bill way out of kilter with income.

Celtic chairman John Reid - formerly Tony Blair's Cabinet enforcer - .

That's well under half of Rangers' debt, when it was last updated, and the Parkhead chairman sounds confident that transfer season transactions since the end of the reporting period should bring the debt substantially down by the time the full-year figures roll round.

But it's clear that the economic downturn is also taking its toll on income, and £1 in every eight - 12%, or nearly £4m - has had to be stripped out of costs, down to £27.5m.

However, turnover was down by far more, 21%.

It's only with player transactions that half-year profits look substantially better than they did this time last year, helped that way by the departure of McGeady, McManus, Boruc, Fortuné, Sheridan and Mizuno.

Other income took a tumble: football and stadium operations down £2.3m to £16.7m. Income from multimedia and other commercial opportunities fell from £7.3m to £4.4m.

Merchandising down from £9.8m to £8.3m.

Celtic is in a better financial position than many others, but Dr Reid sounds like the bitter economic and the winter chill are getting to him in the Parkhead directors' box.

The second half of the football year, he says, is looking even more challenging.

Comments

  • Comment number 1.

    Douglas,

    You do realise that Celtic and most clubs generate most of their yearly income in the 1st 6 months of the season, like selling season tickets, merchandise and revenue from european games?

    Costs generally increase in the 2nd half of the season with performance bonus payments being made to staff and less or no European games.

    This trend has been present in Celtic Interim & Annual reports for a long time now. This is what John Reid was talking about, he wasnt being pessimistic but actually pragmatic.

    Maybe you should do some more research before sniping at people.

  • Comment number 2.

    Douglas

    With reference to Jimmycrackcorn's post, welcome to the Celtic Conspiracy Camp (population: humanity - Celtic). You should have know that any remotely negative or downbeat remark is evidence of the universe's chip on its shoulder about all things Sellick.

  • Comment number 3.

    "It's only with player transactions that half-year profits look substantially better than they did this time last year"

    I think this negates any need for research. Its compared against the same accounting period and the same part of the previous season....or normal accountancy practice

    I do beleive that Dr Reid is being ptagmatic. He won't have any referees to offer up as straw men to hide the situation this time to he supporters. It doesnt take a long look at the accounts to know that not winning the league and not qualifying into the champions league group stages combined with an early europa league exit on top of falling season ticket sales means a big impact on spending power for the club..in fact a perfect storm....and the old solution of just running up a bank overdraft of double digit millions on the never never to cover high wage earners on long contracts is not a currently bank friendly option as rangers are finding out the hard way. Celtics strengths are they are not starting with the burden of the overdraft, but the pain will be the same and shall impact the budget that Lennon will have, win or lose the league this year.

  • Comment number 4.

    you are sad indeed sally if you cannot recognise the fact, that it begun some time ago, that is your clubs decline, which has been kept afloat with a combination of honest mistakes and a helping hand from the media and dare i say it, possibly, my own club? we all know that rangers need celtic and vice versa, so i did find it strange that when rangers where there for the taking, they did not give money to strachan that january? strange indeed! but surely, even the most backward of the ibroke colony can see the implosion that beckons, as for the white knight, that sits on the fence, pull the sheet off, you will find a vulture ready to pick at the bones and decay. your club is about to embark on the darkest days in its history. yes i think that is a good word, to end with!!

  • Comment number 5.

    So, let me get this right "naidive"....according to you:
    Even CELTIC are among those guilty in this vast universal conspiracy against Celtic.

    Of course! its so ridiculously unlikely, it MUST be true.
    Jeez, my mind is blown. Curtains are gettin closed as I type.

  • Comment number 6.

    I suppose its like an addiction of sorts! Especially at old firm level. Either those that take out, life season tickets, or buy the new merchandising annually, are either extremely frugal and great savers or have loads a money and safe employment, or as I really suspect that some families go short with huge mountains of debt! But if your looking for a cause of the decline of Scottish football, some will argue that its these institutions that are the main cause & effect! Not to mention the secondary disease that is still non-eradicated through much of this city, no matter what other captain of politics / industry might have you believe!

  • Comment number 7.

    No small wonder there is a cash flow problem, with J Reid at the helm it is inevitable. He was after all part of the most financially incompetent government this country has ever had, it obviously rubbed off.

  • Comment number 8.

    I think the OF have to be all of the things you mention Douglas - and perhaps more!

    Surprised that you didn't mention the UEFA inspired debt reduction measues due to kick in over the next few years. For some though that may be too far off, especially given the comments today about debt being the main problem affecting football league clubs in England.

    Celtic will continue to shed players over the summer period so the full year figures won't look that bad.

    The really interesting and possibly more nightmare scenario for Scottish football is the overall debt position at Ibrox and the problems they are experiencing with HMRC, which may put them a further £25m in debt.

    If the tax position goes against Rangers, then we really might see a 'perfect storm'.

Ìý

´óÏó´«Ã½ iD

´óÏó´«Ã½ navigation

´óÏó´«Ã½ © 2014 The ´óÏó´«Ã½ is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.