大象传媒

Explore the 大象传媒
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

15 October 2014
WW2 - People's War

大象传媒 Homepage
大象传媒 History
WW2 People's War Homepage Archive List Timeline About This Site

Contact Us

The Arts in Rome: 1944-1945icon for Recommended story

by Sgt Len Scott RAPC

Contributed by听
Sgt Len Scott RAPC
People in story:听
Sgt Len Scott RAPC
Location of story:听
Rome
Background to story:听
Army
Article ID:听
A3936873
Contributed on:听
22 April 2005

The ordinary Roman might have been hungry and cold in the winter of 1944-45 (snow fell in January for the first time in living memory) but his soul was richly fed. When I arrived in November 1944 I was knocked sideway at the Royal Opera's programme for the winter season: Lucia di Lammermoor, Francesca da Rimini, La Boheme, L'Elisir d'Amore, Turandot, Mefistofele, Il Piccolo Marat, Le Nozze di Figaro, Madama Butterfly, Suor Angelica, Mignon, Tosca. More. When summer came we were promised spectaculars in the Baths of Caracalla - Aida, Pagliacci, La Gioconda and Faust.

Nor was this all. Ballet would proliferate: Verdi's 'Four Seasons', Respighi's 'Oiseaux', Don Juan (Strauss), Ravel's Bolero, Petroushka (Stravinsky) , La Boutique Fantastique (Respighi/Rossini) and the Polovitsian Dances from Prince Igor (Borodin.). There would be orchestral concerts - some in the Forum and everything... everything was so low-priced that even we soldiers could become musical dilettantes. Many of us had never been to an opera. Some became opera-lovers for life. Some things we had to learn. In the Royal Opera there was a tendency to sell us seats which would find us sitting behind a pillar, our heads bobbing to and fro pendulum-wise. Wise we became to these particular seat-numbers.

My first Roman opera was Lucia di Lammermoor. It was an enlightening experience. The Roman audience had a tremendous critical faculty. When Lucia (Gianna Perea Labia) muffed a famous aria there was an outburst of hooting, booing and whistling. She froze. Then without loss of dignity she spoke to the conductor, Ottavia Zino. He silenced his orchestra. The aria was recommenced and when the last note was heard there came such a storm of clapping and cheering that my eyes dimmed. These people KNEW their music. Where, I thought, in music-starved Britain would such a scene have been possible? I had attended Sadler's Wells and (once) Covent Garden and had heard performances of excruciating awfulness applauded to the zenith.

The other side must be told. I wrote to my wife: 'The opera is, I believe, taken from a book by Walter Scott and it was amusing to see such typical Italians stalking about in tartan plaids. When a Highland fling was called for in the banqueting hall scene, I thought I saw tall, sandy-headed fellows in battle-dress staggering towards the exits uttering strange Gaelic oaths.'

The names and abilities of most of the Roman singers became familiar to me: Maria Caniglia took the lead in Aida, Mefistofele, Francesca da Rimini and many another. Soprano Maria was reported to demand half a kilo of fillet steak before each performance. The result justified the expense. I began marking my programmes - ticks against those singers who pleased me; crosses against those who did not. Among the winners - Giulio Neri, a tremendous bass who revelled in Mefistofele and similar roles, Marcella Covoni, Tito Schipa, Francesco Albanese, a lyric tenor, Olga Bellarosa and Iole Gavino, who was so beautiful that my critical faculties went into free-fall.

I put a cross against Renato Gigli. Her father Beniamino Gigli was the Pavorotti of his day but had hesitated to re-appear when the Allies took Rome. He had sung for the Nazis and had, perhaps, been a little too friendly with them. He must have wondered how he might be received. He appeared on stage one evening - not to sing, but to introduce Renato. Gigli was loudly cheered and thenceforward sang regularly. Renato vanished.

When the company moved into the Baths of Caracalla - that magnificent pile of ruins which could form a background for almost everything - I became aware that opera was a family outing and social gathering for the Romans. They crowded the terraces with their children, their picnic-baskets and bottles of Chianti. They knew the singers like we moderns know pop-idols and soccer-stars but the Romans retained their acute critical faculties. I saw 'Aida' there with 20 trumpeters perched atop the ruins to blaze forth in the Grand March, followed by a magnificent procession of warriors, slaves and animals (borrowed, I suspect, from Rome's Zoo). By contrast Pagliacci, which I had always considered more of a chamber opera, was presented in panoramic style with the now acceptable Gigli in the role of Canio.

To our credit the British were not behindhand in promoting music. British Army Education and Welfare staged an evening of ballet in which Rome 's prima ballerina, Attilla Radice, made a sensational appearance as Salome in Strauss's 'Dance of the Seven Veils' from his one-act opera. Ballet had never been my' 'thing' but I was left gaping - as were most of my comrades. I detected a murmur of 'Cor!' I did not enlarge on this performance when I wrote home: 'Coppelia, L'Apres midi d'un Faune, Salome, and the Prince Igor Dances in a single programme costing me 50 lire (about half-a-crown). One of the girls fainted and the prima ballerina nearly lost her floppy hat during a pas seul in 'Coppelia'. Otherwise the performance was superb.'

British Army Education and Welfare organised an orchestral concert which moved me to lyricism in a letter home: 'I came away dazed by one item in particular - the final scene from Tristan. Do you remember the orchestral synthesis on two records which James lent us? This was performed with even greater sensitivity than that lovely recording. I was completely lost to everything but the waves of sound which seemed to reach out at me, to submerge me beneath a flood of deepest emotion. I am living at concert-pitch in every direction save one that is needed to co-ordinate all the rest - you, my dear.'

The other arts were not neglected. I have before me a thin catalogue: 'An Exhibition of Masterpieces of European Painting - 15th to 18th centuries in the Palazzo Venezia, Rome, 1944'. The introduction: 'In response to the many requests of Allied troops to visit museums in Rome which are, of necessity, closed, the Division of Fine Arts, Region IV Allied Military Government has organised the present exhibition. Here are assembled many of the best known and celebrated paintings of the greatest period of Italian art. It is intended that proceeds of the exhibition will form a fund to be used in furthering the restoration of national monuments of Italy damaged by war.'

There were just 46 paintings to be seen. The Palazzo Venezia has many rooms. Some rooms contained just one work, some two - never more. The impact was unbelievable. I was accustomed to galleries where paintings filled the rooms from floor to ceiling. The impact of these solitary canvases was unbelievable. Here, unlike at home, there was no place for the eye to stray but towards the work displayed: Masolino, Masaccio (whom I had enjoyed in Florence), Piero della Francesca, Botticelli, Mantegna, Carpaccio, Giorgione, Lorenzo Lotto, Corregio, Raphael, Bronzino, Tintoretto and Titian. But the final coup d'oeil was reserved for my emergence from the final room. There at the end of a long corridor was hung the portrait of that terrifying, glowering, red-garbed Pope by Velasquez ... Pope Innocent (!) the Tenth. His cold eye surveyed me and I felt that I was immediately condemned to Hell.

First impressions are interesting. I sent the catalogue home and now I see I had pencilled: 'This was about the first exhibition to be arranged in Rome after the Allies entered - one or two pictures to each room. Tremendous! It opened my eyes wide to the world of painting.'

Later there was another exhibition in the Villa Borghese which drew upon the galleries of Naples, Urbino, Milan and Venice. This was more comprehensive but that first show stays in my mind to the exclusion, even, of the Vatican Museum. Vatican City, confident in its status as a neutral State within a State had not stashed away its treasures as had the rest of Italy. But here, as in our own National Gallery, the quantity tended to overwhelm.

One exception: Unlike the modern tourist, whisked in and out, I was able to sit for as long as I liked in the Sistine Chapel studying Michelangelo 's frescoes in detail. I wonder if the 115 Cardinals recently assembled to elect Pope Benedict XVI bothered to look at them?

Copyright of content contributed to this Archive rests with the author. Find out how you can use this.

Forum Archive

This forum is now closed

These messages were added to this story by site members between June 2003 and January 2006. It is no longer possible to leave messages here. Find out more about the site contributors.

Message 1 - Arts in Rome 1944-45

Posted on: 22 April 2005 by Trooper Tom Canning - WW2 Site Helper

Sgt Scott -
once again I have to abhor your cynicism of all things catholic which does not enhance your tremendous and fascinating report of the glories of the Roman Art scene in those troubled days of war. As a frequent vistor, after my recovery from wounds, I can appreciate your coments on various artistes performing in Rome in those days but must castigate you on your comments apropos the great Beniamino
Gigli as - earlier than your arrival in Italy he gave our Brigade - 21st Tank Bde. a two hour concert of many operatic arias and Neapolitan songs, accompanied on the piano with one of his daughters - Gina I think. There was no hesitation in his performance, or our appreciation as it was understood that he would have given the same performance to the enemy before we arrived. Goes without saying really.
Your report on the various artistes
failed to mention that great houswife from Ancona who claimed - whilst washing the dishes and listening to some opera that - " she could sing better than that lot" - Renata Tebaldi managed to keep La Divina from the starring roles for many years until she retired. Maria Callas THEN became prominent world wide !
Pity you didn't leave the confines of Rome to journey to the very Catholic Assisi to view the 700 year old masterpieces of Giotti... too late they were destroyed in an earthquake ... some would say as a chastisement for allowing various other sects to display e.g a Golden Buddha atop the tabernacle of St. Clare's bascilica, and other heresies.
You may still see these works but on a movie type VHS show ! Or you probably also missed the works of Fra Angelico in the Orvieto cathedral... you missed a great show there - you can still see them as well as many of Coselli's works- Italy is full of great stuff - not only in Rome - try Padua at the entrance of the cathedral - there are two - this one has St.Anthony's tomb and see the mosaic of the martyr of WW2 concentration camps - St Maxmilian
Kolbe by Annigoni - yes the car designer ! All great stuff !
cheers
tom canning

Message 2 - Arts in Rome 1944-45

Posted on: 26 April 2005 by Sgt Len Scott RAPC

Hi Tom Canning

Thank you for your comments. I am delighted that you found my remarks on the Roman Art scene of interest. Rome together with Florence (see Florence 1945: Ruin and Rebirth) made a lifelong impression upon me. As for my 'cynicism of all things Catholic' I insist that everything I have contributed to the web-site is a factual description of what I saw sixty years ago and WHAT I THOUGHT AT THAT TIME (italics). I had been a trained journalist and if I had had to report to my paper on the scene in St. Peter's I would not have changed a word. There was no exaggeration or 'colouring'.

I must add that I was then an apostate Catholic. I am now a practising Catholic but that does not mean that I would now write a dishonest report about a similar incident. Most of what I have contributed to the site has been taken from my letters home at that time. This, I think, is its purpose. I had every reason to be bitter at that time. My marriage to a divorced woman was being threatened by a zealous young Catholic priest.

Gigli. I saw him introduce his daughter and then leave the stage. I was told that this was his first appearance on a PUBLIC stage since the Allies took Rome. The first time I saw his name on a programme (and I have kept all mine) was in Pagliacci in the Baths of Caracalla. I would be interested to hear if he indeed made earlier public (italics) appearances.

I went to Assisi in he 1970s with my wife, Minna, and we enjoyed the Giottos. I photographed them all and my colour slides are a joy to me. So sad that others will never see them as we did. I did not see the Fra Angelicos in Orvieto but saw the wonderful array in Florence - both in 1945 and twice later when I journeyed there with my wife. Finally I can never be grateful enough that the pot-luck of wartime postings brought me to Italy.

Cheers. Len Scott

Message 3 - Arts in Rome 1944-45

Posted on: 26 April 2005 by Trooper Tom Canning - WW2 Site Helper

My dear Len -
I have just finished writing to your son Allan, who has straightened me out on a few things, which I accept, as a traditional catholic.

I did however, enjoy your sojourn through the Roman Art scene as when I was based at Rieti awaiting posting to the 6th Armoured div.. I too haunted the church scene particularly in Rome at every opportunity and filled my self with the beauty of the craftsmen of yesterday.

The Gesu is a particular favourite with the massive content of Fra Angelico as well as the St Maria in Semphora, which I now understand is the Roman home of Cormac Card. Murphy O'Conner.
Your comment on snow in Rome in January for the first time reminded me of the column of snow which appeared in August in Rome to mark the spot where the St. Mary Major was to be built!
One of my youthful delights in that great city was to climb up the whole way and into the golden ball at the top of the spireof St Peter's. This "ball" held eight of us soldiers, which astonished us as we had been told by one of the custodians that it was big enough for at least six of us...so what better than to prove it ! Mind you - it was a long climb ...but what the heck - we were 20 year olds !
I am so pleased that you have a collection of the Giotto's from Assisi - my daughter will be extrememely envious .. as I am !
Florence I never visited as we were engaged on the Adriatic side most of the way after Cassino and so missed out on all their offerings, and have not had the opportunity since to go there.
Just last year I managed a short trip to Riccione to visit the cemetery which holds most of our Tank Brigades dead, and was struck by the beauty of the region and the maintenance of the graves, mainly by the local schoolchildren assisting the eight gardeners !
Enough of this - if you can , read my posting on the "First Allied Papal Audience" or have Alan read it to you - it may be of interest !

with my best regards
tom Canning

Archive List

This story has been placed in the following categories.

British Army Category
Italy Category
icon for Story with photoStory with photo

Most of the content on this site is created by our users, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the 大象传媒. The 大象传媒 is not responsible for the content of any external sites referenced. In the event that you consider anything on this page to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please click here. For any other comments, please Contact Us.



About the 大象传媒 | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy