大象传媒

Aran: Recipes and Stories from a Bakery in the Heart of Scotland by Flora Sheddon (published by Hardie Grant, October 2019) Photography © Laura Edwards

Listen to the Cook the Perfect podcast here

This is a Scottish cookbook. I was never going to limit myself to only one shortbread recipe. These two are from the best bakers I know – you can decide which one you prefer. The methods are much the same; however, the resulting texture and consistency is different. My granny’s recipe is more akin to a traditional shortbread, the sort that a lot of people will associate with their granny’s. Hers tends to be quite crisp and is normally cooked a little longer than Angus’. She also uses the back of a fork to scratch a ridged surface on the top, which forms perfect little divots for the sugar to fill and cling on to. Angus’ has a far softer texture and more melt-in-the mouth consistency. To be honest, it was much too difficult acall to pick between the two, so I will let you make that decision yourself.

GRANNY JOAN’S

140 g (5 oz/scant 2/3 cup) caster (superfine)
sugar, plus extra for dusting
280 g (10 oz) unsalted butter
425 g (15 oz/3½ cups) plain
(all-purpose) flour

ANGUS’

170 g (6 oz/¾ cup) caster (superfine)
sugar, plus extra for dusting
280 g (10 oz) unsalted butter
280 g (10 oz/2¼ cups) plain
(all-purpose) flour
170 g (6 oz/1¼ cups) cornflour (cornstarch)

Preheat your oven to 140ºC (280ºF/Gas 3). Grease and line a deep, 23 cm (9 in) square baking tin.

For the shortbread base, beat the sugar and butter until pale and well combined – I find a hand-held electric mixer works best for this, but if your butter is soft, you can do this with a wooden spoon. Once the sugar and butter mix is pale in colour, add the flour(s). Beat it again but only for a moment, until the mixture resembles sandy breadcrumbs. Tip the mixture into the lined tin, pressing down very lightly so it becomes level. Bake for 30–40 minutes, or until pale golden in colour and cooked through. Sprinkle with caster sugar immediately, then allow to cool for 15 minutes. Slice into your chosen shape, be it bars or squares, then cool completely before removing from the tin.