Main content
Sorry, this episode is not currently available

Rocks that Fail

Mark Tully asks what happens when the things or people we rely on to be strong, to be there, to be with us, turn out to be fragile, absent, or against us.

Mark Tully asks what happens when the things or people we rely on to be strong, to be there, to be with us, turn out to be fragile, absent, or against us.

From Peter's denial of Jesus, to the failure of financial institutions in times of economic depression, Mark suggests that a crack in a rock need not necessarily be a fatal fault line. From one of the great medieval love stories, he draws from the letters of Heloise castigating her lover Abelard for failing her, while insisting that still only he can be her rock. And he finds a metaphor for our very human tendency to mask our inner weakness with a show of outward strength in the extraordinary phenomenon that is a Prince Rupert's Drop - a tear-shaped drop of glass that can withstand the blows of a hammer to its bulbous end, but will explode into fragments at the slightest twist of its tail.

The programme features the song Anthem by Leonard Cohen, which includes the lyrics, "There is a crack in everything, that's how the light gets in". Mark considers if it is ever possible to find perfection or whether, paradoxically, we should use the flaws we come across to strengthen our faith in the people and institutions on which we build our lives.

The readers are Brian Cox, Frank Stirling and Fiona Shaw.

Producer: Adam Fowler
A Unique production for 大象传媒 Radio 4

28 minutes

Last on

Sun 23 May 2021 23:30

Music Played

  • Benjamin Britten

    Hymn to St Peter

    Performer: The Choir of St John聮s College.
    • Britten: A ceremony of Carols, ETC..
    • The Decca Record Company Limited.
  • Oscar and Lucinda by Peter Carey

    Peter Carey explores the image of a 聭Prince Rupert聮s Drop聮, the immensely strong glass drop that explodes if its tail is damaged.

  • Leonard Cohen

    Anthem

    • The Future.
    • Columbia.
  • 聭Late Lamented Fame of the City of New York聮 by Bertolt Brecht

    In this poem, Brecht explores the 1929 Wall Street Crash and the impact of the banking crisis that followed.

  • The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck

    Steinbeck describes the sorry condition of California during the Great Depression.

  • Dick Van Dyke

    Fidelity Fiduciary Bank

    • Mary Poppins 聳 Film Soudtrack / SHE RMAN.
    • Walt Disney Records.
  • 聭Oh Captain, My Captain by Walt Whitman

    This poem mourns the death of Abraham Lincoln.

  • Count Basie

    Solid as a Rock

    • Best of the Big Bands Vol. 2: Count Basie.
    • Supreme Media.
  • The letters of Abelard and Heloise, translated by Betty Radice

    Heloise bemoans the loss of Abelard as her husband and partner in life.

  • Othello by William Shakespeare

    Othello considers how much damage his lack of faith in Desdemona has done.

  • Samuel Coleridge-Taylor

    Military March from Othello Suite

    Performer: RTE Concert Orchestra, cond. Adrian Leaper.
    • Coleridge-Taylor: Othello Suite, 4 Characteristic suites, ETC - Various.
    • Pavilion Records LTD.
  • 聭The god that failed聮 by Richard Wright

    Wright describes his loss of faith in the communist party.

  • Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina

    Tu Es Petrus

    Performer: Stephen Cleobury: Choir Of King's College Cambridge.
    • Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina.
    • Decca (UMO).

Broadcasts

  • Sun 13 Jul 2014 06:05
  • Sun 13 Jul 2014 23:30
  • Sun 23 May 2021 06:05
  • Sun 23 May 2021 23:30