大象传媒

In the Snack-barStanza three

In this poem, Morgan uses his acute skills of observation to describe the plight of a blind, infirm elderly man to make a social comment about how people treat those less fortunate than themselves.

Part of EnglishEdwin Morgan

Stanza three

The final stanza is devoted to a reflection upon the man鈥檚 situation. The opening lines state, in frank terms, the man鈥檚 dependence on others for simple tasks.

The man鈥檚 appearance is a particular focus for the speaker who describes his hands as wet leaves/stuck to the half-white stick. The simile compares the man鈥檚 hands to limp, wet leaves emphasising his feebleness and lack of strength. Once again, this is an image that reinforces the man鈥檚 infirmity as he clutches the cane which guides his movements.

The choice of the verb evade to describe the reactions of many who see the man allows us to appreciate his helplessness. This suggests a calculated effort by those around the man to avoid him, to deliberately and wilfully ignore his need for help.

The choice of this word suggests a pessimistic view of society where helping others in need is something which people find difficult. We get an impression that, while the speaker helped the man, we could not be certain that others would. Worse still, many people would actively avoid having to help.

The poem ends with a nihilistic howl of despair as the speaker finally releases his emotions. The anguished appeal to Dear Christ is loaded with irony, since the teachings of Christ are founded on showing kindness and compassion to those most in need. The tone is almost accusatory, as though the speaker is angry that anyone should be born into an existence such as this.

The final line, then, conveys not only the speaker鈥檚 frustration and pity for the old man, but also his anger and disgust for a society which can so easily ignore the most vulnerable and weak in our communities. In doing so, he exposes this unpalatable truth and forces us to confront our own attitudes and responsibilities to people in similar situations.

Themes

Helplessness and suffering are central concerns in the poem. Although the poem focuses on just one individual, the old man becomes representative of everyone in society who must rely on the assistance of others just to function at the most basic level. This single incident is merely a snapshot of the man鈥檚 life and serves to illustrate the indignity and humiliation of such an existence. However, although his plight elicits sympathy from the reader, he also inspires admiration through his tenacity and determination.