´óÏó´«Ã½

Explore the ´óÏó´«Ã½
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

15 October 2014
WW2 - People's War

´óÏó´«Ã½ Homepage
´óÏó´«Ã½ History
WW2 People's War Homepage Archive List Timeline About This Site

Contact Us

The Battle of Cassino 1943-44

by quickroughrider

Contributed byÌý
quickroughrider
People in story:Ìý
John Oswald
Location of story:Ìý
Cassino, Italy
Background to story:Ìý
Army
Article ID:Ìý
A3189305
Contributed on:Ìý
27 October 2004

THE BATTLE OF CASSINO

When you tell someone that you have had a week’s holiday in Italy, they will probably start thinking of sun, sand and warm seas, or museums and art galleries, or perhaps Roman and Etruscan ruins. But my wife, Eunice, and I recently went on an Italian holiday with a difference - a trip back sixty years.

Most ex-service people tend not to speak of their wartime experiences, and I suppose I am the same. But recently there has been a lot of talk of lottery grants for visits to the battlefields. As I had served in Italy for much of the 1943-45 campaign, I applied for one to visit Cassino, my first battle experience.

My recollection of that time is scanty. I was attached to the 56th (London) Division, the ‘Black Cats’, as Interrogation Officer, halfway through the Cassino battle, and most of my memories were of what others who were there had told me, and even of tales from some German soldiers we captured later on. I cannot vouch for any inaccuracies of detail, but have checked official records as carefully as I can. Opinions are not necessarily mine, but were those in general circulation at the time.

I little knew what an emotionally draining experience I was in for. Firstly, we had to find a means of getting to Cassino. After much research, we decided to go with Saga, who had a comfortable, conveniently placed hotel with an excursion to Cassino. I must give them full marks for their excellent support.

We first visited the newly rebuilt Montecassino Abbey, the mother church of the Benedictine Order. This was most impressive. It has been reconstructed as nearly as possible to the old building. From there, we were able to see the Polish Cemetery, and indeed, there were two coaches from Poland in the coach park as we left. Afterwards, we went down to the British and Commonwealth Cemetery, beautifully kept by the small group of gardeners. It holds some 4600 graves, and it was poignant to see that most of these appeared to be for fallen soldiers in their early twenties.

The visit to the cemetery brought back many memories of those days. I had heard of the approach our troops made to Cassino through sticky mud and minefields in that wet winter of 1943. I had been told tales of the many different types of mines sown by the Germans, and in particular of the much-feared ‘S’ mine, which jumped out of the ground and exploded in front of you. 56th Division, in the forefront of the attack, was all but wiped out in this approach.

I had also heard of the destruction of Montecassino Abbey, perched on a mountaintop some 1000 feet above the town. Whilst waiting for the final push, discussion was rife as to whether this had been necessary. The surrounding hills were just as effective observation points as the Abbey had been.

The devastating air attack by the USAF in March, during which our own troops became hidden inside a thick cloud of dust, only to be virtually destroyed by the second and third waves of bombing, was the origin of the unfortunate reputation the US forces still have for ‘friendly fire’ attacks second and third waves of bombing, was the origin of the unfortunate reputation the US forces still have for ‘friendly fire’ attacks

In the meantime, the Anzio bridgehead had been successfully held, but the US
General Lucas had not developed it as planned. Supplies to the Germans in Cassino, which should have been halted, continued to come in, prolonging the battle, and our troops’ misery, for months.

In the end, determined but costly attacks by our Indian Divisions and the two Polish
Divisions were able to put an end to this terrible slaughter. The Battle of Cassino had been going on for almost six terrible months.

Once again, the US forces let us down. Two divisions under General Mark Clark were to have carried out a quick ‘left hook’ and cut off the German retreat from Cassino, so that we could take them all prisoner. The General preferred to claim the glory of ‘liberating’ Rome, which had been declared an open city. The Germans were able to retreat in some semblance of order, to fall back on the ‘Gothic Line’ further back, once again prolonging the war by more months.

Memories, memories! The Battle of Cassino was overshadowed by the euphoria of the Normandy Landings. Someone at home, conveniently forgetting that a serviceman goes where he is sent and not where he would like to go, dubbed us the ‘D-Day Dodgers’.

On the coach taking us back to the hotel, I was asked by our courier to say a few words about the battle. I did this on the lines of the above article. There were a few other ex-servicemen in our party, as well as relatives of men who had been killed at Cassino. I hope my short talk was at least enlightening to them.

© Copyright of content contributed to this Archive rests with the author. Find out how you can use this.

Forum Archive

This forum is now closed

These messages were added to this story by site members between June 2003 and January 2006. It is no longer possible to leave messages here. Find out more about the site contributors.

Message 1 - Battle of Cassino 1943044

Posted on: 27 October 2004 by Trooper Tom Canning - WW2 Site Helper

John -
I always enjoy a rattling good tale when it is told sincerely as yours certainly is, and I am pleased that the Lottery Scheme worked in your favour - I was refused as living too far away in Western Canada.

One or two points in your story can give rise to great mis-understandings in the future particularly when researchers and historians are trying to make heads out of tails as it were.

Your 56th Division was certainly nearly wiped out - but at the preamble to the Cassino battles, as they and the 46th Div were part of Gen Mark Clarks 5th Army all the way from Salerno... when he forgot to include them in his plan to evacuate the beaches as the 8th Army had not rescued him in time !!! The 10th Corps as it was, certainly had a very difficult time in crossing the Garigliano River to such an extent that they took no further part in the main battles for Cassino.They reappeared much later at the latter stages of the Gothic Line.

The Monastery was bombed by both the USAAF and the RAF it should be noted
the decision for this action was taken by both Gens. Freyberg of New Zealand and Maj.Gen. Tuker of the 4th Indian Div during the second and third battles. An assist for this decision was by US Gen Hap Arnold who had been sent out by the joint Chiefs
to check Monty's story that the air forces were getting regular supplies for doing nothing whereas his divison were being "shorted". he then advised the Air Chiefs at Foggia to go and bomb something !!!

While the Polish forces were fully occupied in their famous right hook towards the Monastery, it should be noted that the Brit 78th Div and 4th Brit Div were doing a left hook and the 1st Guards bde were directly into Cassino Town. No Indian divisions were employed between 11th - 18th May '44.

During the final operation Diadem starting 20th May 2nd Polish corps were on the right along with 8th Indian and 4th Brit. Divs. The breakthrough occurred on the 5th Army front when the 2 & 4th Moroccans plus the 3rd Algerians charged through an undefended moutain top and threatened to encircle the German 14th Army. The US 88th and 85th Divs were occupied on the east coast.The 8th Army thrust was followed by the combined forces of 6th Brit Armed div; 1st Cdn Inf Div;25th Brit Tank bde;5th Cdn Armed Div;78th div and 8th Indian; later joined by 6th Sth African Armed div.near Valmontone.

meanwhile the US 5th Army were supposed to have broken out towards Valmontone from Anzio,to create an 'anvil' for 8th Army's 'hammer'.Instead US gen Mark Clark turned left and tried to take Rome but getting a bloody nose in the process from the Herman Goering Panzer Div. This allowed a combined task force of US and Cdn Commando's to "liberate " Rome !

Trust you will accept my corrections in the spirit in which they are written.

Message 1 - Battle of Cassino

Posted on: 13 May 2005 by Ron Goldstein

Hi John
How's this for coincidence of the year?
Last week I was at the British Cemetery and a young lady came over to speak to me.
She introduced herself as a Saga rep and said that the last time she conducted a party around Cassino she had this 'amazing character' in the group who was able to offer first hand memories of the battle.
The name John Oswald was mentioned and the penny dropped !
Small world. aint it ?
Ron

Archive List

This story has been placed in the following categories.

British Army Category
Monte Cassino 1944 Category
Italy Category
icon for Story with photoStory with photo

Most of the content on this site is created by our users, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the ´óÏó´«Ã½. The ´óÏó´«Ã½ is not responsible for the content of any external sites referenced. In the event that you consider anything on this page to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please click here. For any other comments, please Contact Us.



About the ´óÏó´«Ã½ | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy
Ìý