大象传媒

Explore the 大象传媒
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

15 October 2014
WW2 - People's War

大象传媒 Homepage
大象传媒 History
WW2 People's War Homepage Archive List Timeline About This Site

Contact Us

Germ Warfare: Clare Hall Hospital

by Michael McEnhill

Contributed by听
Michael McEnhill
People in story:听
Susan McGinley
Location of story:听
England and Ireland
Article ID:听
A2081756
Contributed on:听
26 November 2003

Germ Warfare.

"And some are sung and that was yesterday
And some unsung,and that may tomorrow be".
Francis Thompson (1859-1907)

"Stop there!" A harsh voice came out of the darkening night.Susan McGinley brought her bicycle to an abrupt stop at the very top of the steep Black Lion Hill, Shenley.
Preventing her from going any further and shining his torch directly into her dazzled eyes, the village policeman surveyed his "catch!" Close up, he took in the firm set face with blue rebellious eyes. Perched on her head was a navy blue cap which matched her coat,of such length it draped her knees, outlining the sheen of fine, strong legs.
He pressed her with questions. "What was she about at this time of night with a war on? Where to? Where from?"
After giving her name, she told him that she lodged at the base of the hill with her married sister, but that she was originally from Altaneerin, in Donegal, if he would know where that was. She was going to her place of work until he had stopped her. She had still three more miles to travel to Clare Hall Hospital in South Mimms. She was a qualified State-Enrolled nurse in an urgent hurry to get to her work in time, war or no war, and attend to desparately ill patients.
The policeman showed no inclination to be rid of her or to listen to her entreaties as to the plight of her patients or her own personal position. Rather, on this cold night in the latter part of January 1941, the policeman officiously pounced on the fact that her rear light was not functioning, to which Susan McGinley weakly exclaimed that she had tried reviving her battery on the kitchen range, but it must be "whacked" and that she would have to purchase a new one.That was not good enough for the policeman who summoned her to appear before the Magistrates Court at Barnet.She would have to push her bicycle the remainder of the way to the hospital where she worked.
She struggled along the lane,fearful, solitary and weary.At times a rake of searchlights sent up pillars of light into the black sky to laser back and forth.At ground level anti-aircraft emplacements were ready to puncture the night air, the banter of the crews reaching her across the leafless hedges.
The Matron,Mrs Spaley, gave her a severe talking to when she arrived late. However,it was not until a few weeks later when Susan McGinley was fined ten shillings by the Court and her case had made the columns of the Daily Express that the indignant Matron gave full vent to her feelings."I admire your fine words which have found their ways into the paper, - 'as a nurse it was my duty to relieve the sick and suffering'. However,I take grave exception to the fact that you made the location of this hospital thoroughly well known to Mr Hitler and his cronies, and I, myself, and all my staff, will be forever up and down to the air-raid shelter from this time on.I've a good mind to sack you!"
She discussed this proposal with the Medical Superintendant, Dr Simmonds, who opined that it was for her only to decide. Fortunately Dr.Laird the surgeon of the hospital came to her support declaring that she was an excellent nurse and should continue to be employed by the hospital.
Thereafter, she lost herself in her work, putting her patients before herself.'Self' in those days was a luxury one could not afford, one's patients were always at the forefront of one's thoughts. The hospital at Clare Hall had moved from Clerkenwell and was originally devoted to the treatment of small-pox diseases and has a history of over two hundred years, being situated here in 1896. The incidence of small-pox was high in 1901, and the surrounding village suffered for which the hospital was blamed for the contagiousness of disease.
At that time nurses were recruited from the old Nurses' Co-operative Society at three guineas a week, a sum regarded as a high reward, for only the best nurses were to have charge of such a serious disease.
It was in May 1911, that Clare Hall Hospital treated patients with tuberculosis. It was used for treating advanced tuberculosis patients so there was an air of gloom and despondency about the place in 1935: 39% of the patients were discharged by death; with better investigation and treatment results were more cheerful and patients were happier. Although the known causation of the disease at this time had been isolated as Koch's Bacillus, it was still maintained by medical practitioners that one could not cure a fool of tuberculosis owing to the treatment being long and troublesome.
With the diminution of small-pox cases medical forces were directed against this more prevalent scourge and it took all the resources of the medical and nursing staff, both mental and physical, to forestall its ravages of the population.
USA Army Surgeon-General Bushnell's famous remark lies at the base of all treatment: "For tuberculosis we prescribe not medicine but a mode of life".
This is where Clare Hall Hospital and its nursing staff came into their own. As the disease was highly infectious the patients had to be isolated. Endless steadfastness, courage, self-discipline and self-denial were required of them. They were housed in a hutted sanatorium which was part of the Emergency Medical Service. The 'huts' were of brick construction with asbestos sheeted roofs.At the onset of the war it was adapted as a general hospital to meet the needs of the civilian casualties, acting as a base hospital receiving local and transferred air-raid casualties from London.
However, very soon the need for a special effort to combat tubercullosis under war conditions meant that all the beds were occupied with tubercullosis patients by December 1942, a total of 540 beds.
Surgical methods of radical character only began just before the war.
Susan McGinley worked throughout the war.There were several hundred nursing staff employed at the hospital during this time.Nurse McGinley tells me that at least half the nursing staff were from Ireland, 'from the four corners, as they say'; she herself enthuses that they indeed were a credit to their country.While others were fighting a mighty battle in Europe and in the desert sands of Africa and even further afield, she and her colleagues were fighting the furious tuberculosis disease, with no let up,in the sanatorium in South Mimms.
The nursing regime was arduous for the disease requires very skilled treatment, the esentials of which are: rest, both of mind and body, fresh air and sunlight, routine and discipline, and correct feeding. By its very nature of confinement, owing to the disease being highly infectious, the disease was doubly trying and the barrier nursing required scrupulous attention to the rules of hygiene. Patients were confined to to bed at night for ten to twelve hours, necessitating more blanket baths, more bed linen changes, and all this with very difficult and demanding patients.
Along with the tremendous bouts of coughing, pain and all round debilitating ill-health, the patients exhibited what was known as a TB temperament when they would be very irritable and show extremes of temper to the nurses or for that matter anyone else who happened unfortuantely to cross their firing line.
Nurses would suffer and be expected to take many a 'tongue-lashing!'At such times the patients could also 'act-up' when smuggled cigarretes would be secretly smoked under the sheets in their beds. They would also abscond by donning a flying jacket or army greatcoat or such like over their pyjamas and make haste for the 'Old Guinea Pub' a few hundred yards from the main gate with, invariably some nurses in hot pursuit. They would be read the riot act and threatened with immediate expulsion from the hospital.No doubt within a few days they would be welcomed back into the folds of tender and loving care again.
Dr. Simmonds, in a Medical History of Clare Hall Hospital says: 'With the decline in the incidence and mortality of tuberculosis the hospital should be used for pulmonary, cardiac and other chest conditions. Tuberculosis had been largely beaten at that time and the nursing staff deserve to be honoured for relieving the suffering of many thousands of patients and making known to people not only the essential cure of the disease but also the socio-economic origins in poor housing, environment, diet and life styles".
Now, there is nothing left to tell the tale, just the sycamore tree with fresh new branches, where the nurses used to sit many years ago.
There is a worthy adendum or supplementary history to this story surrounding Susan McGinley's exploits during World War 11.
The people of America alerted by 'The Philadelphia Inquirer' as to her predicament in being dragged before the courts at Barnet were outraged that this should happen to a valuable night-nurse during the blitzkrieg, of London.
About to enter the war themselves it was a subject of contention throughout America as to the conduct of the War. They went so far as to invite Susan to their country and promised to provide her with a new bicycle.She would be paraded in the great cities as the 'Florence Nightingale Flyer' who defied Hitler during the height of the Blitz determined to see to the wounded and dying serviceman injured during the war. A medal would be cast in her honour.
Years later we were invited to contribute to Guy Michelmore and Louise Bachelor's programme retrospective film 'Memories of War' but I am sad to say nothing came of it. There was talk of the film being too expensive.

Copyright of content contributed to this Archive rests with the author. Find out how you can use this.

Forum Archive

This forum is now closed

These messages were added to this story by site members between June 2003 and January 2006. It is no longer possible to leave messages here. Find out more about the site contributors.

Message 1 - Germ Warfare.

Posted on: 01 December 2003 by Michael McEnhill

To Helen. I have added a small addendum to this piece. I don't know if it has been saved correctly. I have further references to American opinion which I shall add as a part of factual history of the time relevant to my Aunt. However, I am not sure of the procedure regarding additional material whether it is welcome or nay.

Message 1 - Clare Hall Hospital

Posted on: 24 January 2004 by Jim Holder-Vale

Dear 23603736
I'm sorry I haven't got a name to address.
I very much enjoyed your article which brought back many memories. In early 1957 I was sent to Clare Hall Hospital as a TB patient. I thought the huts we lived in were very primitive and the food was not much to look forward too. The sister on Bantin Ward was a dear and had been there many years, she told me the day Streptomycin was first introduced as treatment was the happiest day of her life. At last TB could really be treated. She went on to explain the patients were issued with the ampules which they had to shake prior to being injected as it came thick as syrup. I was treated with Strep injected into alternative buttocks each morning with Sunday as a day of rest. It was not a painless process like today as the needles were quite large and seemed very blunt. However, it worked as I was discharged about Easter time, but by the time of my check-up the TB had returned with a vengeance so it was back to Clare Hall which I found very depressing. I was told the best teatment would be the removal of the upper lobe of my right lung. So it was back on the Strep and daily visits by the physiotherapist to improve my breathing and prepare for her to persuade be to breath deeply as soon after the op as possible. This was to inflate the lung to fill the now emty space in the chest cavity; otherwise it would mean another op to close the rib cage down around the space giving one a horrible hunch-back appearance. That year there was a flu epidemic so all operations were suspended for a while. My surgeon was Mr Laird who was much respected in the hospital, he did a very good job on me and I wsas home by November, fully cured!
I am celebrating my 80th birthday today and am most greatful for the kind attention I got at Clare Hall. Foe the last 18 months I have as a Church Recorder been recording the many memorials in the church of St Giles in South Mymms aware that Clare Hall Hospital had not been that far away.
Kind regards
Jim Holder-Vale

Message 2 - Clare Hall Hospital

Posted on: 22 March 2004 by Michael McEnhill

Dear Jim,
I am sorry that I did not pick up on your message earlier. I am pleased to learn that your treatment proved to be effective at Clare Hall Hospital.
Conditions were quite primitive as my Aunt would certainly have agreed but she would have always maintained that the standard of nursing and the care by the doctors was second to none.
Doctor Laird must have been quite an age when you met him.
My Aunty would have used a glass syringe to administer injections whereas today of course they use plastic disposable syringes with narrow sharp needles which would not be so painful as years ago.
It is interesting that you ended up at St. Giles as a recorder very much on the doorstep of the hospital which has been redundant for some years now.
I think that there was a greater awareness in those days as to the necessity for strict hygiene being brought home to them by the dangerous prevalence of TB in the community, and in this regard although the hospital was primitive in the fabric of the hospital one never heard talk of M.R.S.A multiple resistant staphyloccocus aureuas as has been dangerously propogated in our hospitals today.Best wishes Michael.

Message 3 - Clare Hall Hospital

Posted on: 13 October 2004 by CharlieJu

Wonderful to find this article about Clare Hall! Just this morning I established that my uncle died of TB in 1930, and that he had been taken for burial from Clare Hall.
Does the building still exist?
Julia Callaghan

Message 4 - Clare Hall Hospital

Posted on: 14 October 2004 by Michael McEnhill

Dear Julia,
What you say about your uncle is very interesting. Considering that Jim Holder-Vale brings forward an account of some of the rudimentary surgery that was being contemplated at a later date you may well understand that in the 1930's Tuberculosis was regarded as an extremely dangerous condition. I have not got the book to hand that detailed the earlier treatments, a lot of which carried great hope to alleviate the conditions but in most cases proved proved futile until the advent of life saving penicillin. In my Aunts time great credence was given to nursing the patients in a sanatorium, fresh healthy air for the lungs being the order of the day, along with the nurses taking the part of modern day physiotherapists. The nurses in those days as opposed to those of the modern day would practise what my aunt termed, between the beds nursing, rather than the bay type nursing of today.
In effect the Sister in charge of the ward would lead the way.
The beds would all be lined up meticulously, beds would be remade first thing and pillows plumped. After patients temperature, pulse and respiration plus blood pressure was taken there would be an early ward round by doctors.
Patients would be raised in bed, maybe a draw sheet would be adjusted under their feet to stop them slipping down in the bed and then the nurses would tap with both hands on their back to break up infectious phlegm that would have been building up in their lungs. They would be able to cough this out in sputum jars which was always to be found on the bedside lockers.The nurses job in those days was very heavy and arduous, not only were they responsible for the well being of the patients but any minute to spare was spent on making the ward spotless which meant cleaning floors, washing down walls and cleaning windows into the bargain.
On the site of Clare Hall Hospital stands a Cancer Research Building for as Jim puts in his message a lot of the building was composed of wooden, almost nissen type wards. I think that bordering Cross Oak lane their remains some of the nursing homes that were occupied in those days. The village of South Mimms not far distant is little changed since my Aunty's time as are the winding country lanes she would cycle through on her journey from North Avenue to her place of work most days of the week no matter how inclement the weather.
Also the Guinea Pub remains as it was in those days, where the patients used to run, with my Aunt in seemly pursuit, not far behind, their pyjamas hastily covered by some coat they had picked up in their dash for some sort of freedom and relief.There is no getting away from it, in those days a tough regime was employed by the Sister's to reap a cure for those under their care.

Message 5 - Clare Hall Hospital

Posted on: 29 May 2005 by mjprior

Hi I am very interested in any information you may have on Clare Hall Hospital as my nan used to work there as a nurse,(my dad also worked there till it closed around 1973), and I now live oppsite the old site. Have you got any old photos of the hospital?

Message 1 - A2081756 - Germ Warfare: Clare Hall Hospital

Posted on: 29 March 2004 by Michael McEnhill

Archive List

This story has been placed in the following categories.

Working Through War Category
Medical Units Category
London Category
icon for Story with photoStory with photo

Most of the content on this site is created by our users, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the 大象传媒. The 大象传媒 is not responsible for the content of any external sites referenced. In the event that you consider anything on this page to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please click here. For any other comments, please Contact Us.



About the 大象传媒 | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy