´óÏó´«Ã½

Explore the ´óÏó´«Ã½
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

15 October 2014
WW2 - People's War

´óÏó´«Ã½ Homepage
´óÏó´«Ã½ History
WW2 People's War Homepage Archive List Timeline About This Site

Contact Us

Death In Oosterbeekicon for Recommended story

by Bob Scrivener

Contributed byÌý
Bob Scrivener
People in story:Ìý
Lt. Edmund Scrivener, other unknown
Location of story:Ìý
Arnhem, Holland
Background to story:Ìý
Army
Article ID:Ìý
A2661996
Contributed on:Ìý
24 May 2004

My father, Edmund F. Scrivener (1916—2003) served with 1st Battalion, The Border Regiment, Air Landing Brigade, at Arnhem. He wouldn’t talk much about his nine days in hell, but he did once say to me, 'Why is it a man’s scream sounds so much more blood-curdling than a woman’s?'

He wrote this poem about an incident near the end of the battle.

Death In Oosterbeek

At the dawning he came to me again,
That gentle smile, and blood upon his cheek
Reminding me, for his end had come
In the dappled woods of Oosterbeek.
A passing shower of German mortar bombs
Had driven me beneath a fallen tree,
And when, at last I rose, prepared to go,
I saw him turn his head and look at me.
The wonder and compassion in his eyes,
The friendship of the smile upon his face,
Mocked the blood that trickled from his lips,
And made me curse aloud the human race.
He knew they could not hurt him any more,
No longer would he feel the pains and fears,
Forgiveness shone from that young soldier's face,
The mem’ry brings a flood of angry tears.

I wish these tears would wash away the thought
That e’en in death we humiliate them so;
I saw him later at the First Aid Post,
A label tied to his bare and lifeless toe.
I often wonder who that young lad was,
Who gave his life to cross the bloody Rhine;
And if no loved ones have him in their thoughts,
Come haunt me lad, and live again in mine.

© Copyright of content contributed to this Archive rests with the author. Find out how you can use this.

Forum Archive

This forum is now closed

These messages were added to this story by site members between June 2003 and January 2006. It is no longer possible to leave messages here. Find out more about the site contributors.

Message 1 - death in osterbeck

Posted on: 07 July 2004 by lewfred

Hello bob thanks for that I know the fealing.
Lew x 156 bat

Ìý

Message 2 - death in osterbeck

Posted on: 18 July 2004 by merrycharles

Hello I am new to this sight. I would be verry gratfull if the gentleman whowas in the Border regiment happend to know Charlie (Chuck) Dalton from York. He was my mothers brother she is still alive at 87 and would be verry interested. He died of his wounds there

Ìý

Message 3 - death in osterbeck

Posted on: 27 September 2004 by Bob Scrivener

I can tell you he wasn't in 10th Platoon A Company. I suggest you try one of the excellent Arnhen sites which may be of some help.

Ìý

Message 4 - death in osterbeck

Posted on: 29 November 2005 by Morley166

Dear Mr. Scrivener,

In September 2004 I published a book on 13 platoon B Company The Border Regiment.(An English translation is being prepared). I think in A Company there was a Canloan officer Cliffy Aasen whose close friend was the Lt from 13 Platoon, john Wellbelove.
Would you have any memories about seeing those two or of anyone of Wellbelove's platoon?

Would be interested to know,

Thanks a lot already in advance
(Am in contact with Johnny Peters of 14 platoon)

Haks

Ìý

Message 5 - death in osterbeck

Posted on: 30 January 2006 by ODYSSEY

Dear BOB! this is probably the last day to contact anyone in WW2 as it is closing down to morrow.
I just read your contribution + poem.
I t really shook me: I was a nurse in Holland when the battle of Arnhem took place. I took care of many british stayed with the guys dying in my ward whenever possible; I don't think any soldier should die alone in a hospital setting. And I tried to stay with many of them when their end came as I would like them to feel that we DID care about them. I have been writing many stories about occupied Holland as the ´óÏó´«Ã½ thought that people should know WHAT happened under German occupation ccupation.
I was lucky to go to the UK and by troopship to Australia and to the dutch indies to take care of concentration camp victims
I have written under the name ODYSSEY my # is U555516 . Thanks again: i loved the poem sad as it is!

Ìý

Message 6 - death in osterbeck

Posted on: 31 January 2006 by ritsonvaljos

Hello Odyssey, merrycharles, Bob Scrivener et al,

Re: 1st Battalion Border Regiment at Arnhem

The following two books have a lot of detailed information about 1st Borders at Arnhem, including some detailed sketch maps and photos of the campaign. You should be able to find what happened to most of the individuals who were in that Battalion from these:

1. ‘1st Battalion The Border Regiment ARNHEM’ by Alan T. Green (1991) published by the Museum of The Border Regiment and the KORBR.

2. 'When Dragons Flew' by Stuart Eastwood, Charles Gray and Alan Green (1994) published by Silver Link Publishing Ltd.

A few weeks ago I visited the Border Regiment Museum at Carlisle Castle. There is even more information available in their Archives, and they pay a fine tribute to their men who fought at Arnhem. A visit is recommended for anyone wishing to learn more about 1st Border at Arnhem / Oosterbeek in September 1944.

To Bob who posted the poem, I must also say that 'Death in Oosterbeek' poem is very moving. It expresses in words the feelings of what the Allied soldiers must have been at that time.

Thanks!
ritsonvaljos

Message 1 - poem

Posted on: 18 September 2004 by anak-bandung

Hello Bob, this is a beautiful and haunting poem. You must be proud of your father.
regards, anak-bandung

Ìý

Message 2 - Death in Oosterbeek

Posted on: 20 September 2004 by rumbrotheelder

Your father wrote an extremely beautiful poem. He must have been a very sensetive man, of whom you have a right to be really proud. The last two lines made me cry.

Geoff Stead

Ìý

Message 3 - Death in Oosterbeek

Posted on: 27 September 2004 by Bob Scrivener

Thank you for your kind words. My Father's full war Diary is now at the Editorial desk. "Episodes from an uncertain Memory". I think it's wonderful, but then I would, whouldn't I?

Ìý

Message 4 - Death in Oosterbeek

Posted on: 09 July 2005 by worldharmony

This poem is so moving and 'smells' so real. What a wonderfully, insightful and honest man. I just wish none of our family and friends had to go through this.

Remembering everyone ...

Ìý

Message 5 - Death in Oosterbeek

Posted on: 09 July 2005 by Divecon1

I'm always so moved by WW2 stories and experiences. My father served in all the areas of conflict in the royal marines and I have his different medals from each one. Sadly he died when I was nine and so I was unable to hear about his experiences directly. Recently I was also able to gather information on one of my uncles who was killed in a flying training accident in 1941 and who had been 'forgotten' by all of his remaining close relatives (in their eighties).It was such a shame that they did not even remember the circumstances of his death and I had to find out about it from an author who was just about to publish a book on Wiltshire aerodromes and the various incidents that had occured there in the war. I was able to get his photo in the book and so he'll remain for all to see for as long as the book remains in print. I visited his grave at Upavon two summers ago and although I never knew him I was very moved by the experience.

Ìý

Message 6 - Death in Oosterbeek

Posted on: 09 July 2005 by fredsbestfriend

Hello Bob,
Thank you so much for such a moving and telling poem. My Dad's brother, Robbie, was killed in Oosterbeek in a tank. A few years ago we took my Dad to find Robbie's name on the memorial. Robbie has no grave, he's just a name on a list. I remember Dad cried when he saw the inscription. My Dad died in April and before we could take him back to Ooosterbeek, but I visted myself recently and felt that he and Robbie were with me. Thank you again.

Ìý

Message 7 - Death in Oosterbeek

Posted on: 27 September 2005 by rumbrotheelder

Dear Divecon1:-

How wonderful that you cared enough to make sure that your Uncle's memory was preserved. There must be thousands of people who died in WW2 (as well as many other wars) who have been forgotten for all time. But not your Uncle.

Would love to know the name of the book and where to buy it.

Message 1 - Innocents Life

Posted on: 09 July 2005 by India_91

I heard so many times from my Italian Grandparents talking about the WW2 and eachtime they were crying while they were talking about the cruelty of it and for the friends they lost in the war...

Is a shame that in the 21st century we have to still see the war.

I don't understand how the people still send someone to fight for a stupid war(all of them are from the politicians and their stupid greed reasons...)

I believe that the Life of each individual it's so Precious and Unique.

I'm asking How the people can "Play" with the Life of the other and don't want understand the real mean of the Life...

Anyway I really wanna Thanks all the People(especially the Young) for their Braveheart in the WW2, and the meantime I'm so sorry for what they lived in the WW2.

To All,Thank you so much.

Message 1 - Ashame

Posted on: 09 July 2005 by natibrandi

Just thinking that 50 years ago all those terrible things happened makes me fell ashame, simpily because I'm an inhabitant of this world, but nowadays many people are dying too, some of them because they don't have any food and they are extremely poor, others are dying in Irak. In a way we are letting this happen, and that makes me feel much more ashame.. so let's remember that terrible things happened in the second world war and in others moments in the past but let's also bare in mind that TODAY many people died because they were hungry, that on thursday more than 50 people died and that in Irak people are dying not for fighting terrorism they are dying for oil.
I'm a 16-year old girl, I don't want to wake up in 50 years and read the poems of many soliders who died in Irak, I want that solider to be in his home.. so as john lennon said, "War is over if you want it" It's up to us, what do we want??

Archive List

This story has been placed in the following categories.

British Army Category
Poetry Category
Arnhem 1944 Category
Netherlands Category
icon for Story with photoStory with photo

Most of the content on this site is created by our users, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the ´óÏó´«Ã½. The ´óÏó´«Ã½ is not responsible for the content of any external sites referenced. In the event that you consider anything on this page to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please click here. For any other comments, please Contact Us.



About the ´óÏó´«Ã½ | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy
Ìý